To the Editor In their From The JAMA Network Commentary1 on our article,2 Drs Apovian and Aronne stated “Perhaps the 96.9% 1-year return visit authors call ‘retention rate’ should instead be called ‘1-year return rate,’ because the 58 participants who returned for final assessment were nonadherent with the treatment protocol. Of the 58 participants who were nonadherent, 51 came back for the 1-year assessment, leaving 7 lost to follow-up. Therefore, the study completion rate was 95.6%, which is excellent for a weight loss trial.” I believe this was an inaccurate statement.
Gadde KM. Weight Loss Treatment in Obese Adults. JAMA. 2013;310(23):2568. doi:10.1001/jama.2013.282258