From the Departments of Medicine (Drs Burke and Motulsky) and Genetics (Dr Motulsky), University of Washington, Seattle; the National Center for Human Genome Research, Bethesda, Md (Ms Thomson and Drs Meslin and Collins); the Office of Genetics and Disease Prevention (Dr Khoury) and the Division of Nutrition and Physical Activity (Drs McDonnell and Cogswell), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Ga; Department of Psychiatry and Biobehavioral Medicine, University of California, Los Angeles (Dr Press); Department of Medicine, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada (Dr Adams); Southern Iron Disorders Center, Birmingham, Ala (Dr Barton); Department of Molecular and Experimental Medicine, Scripps Research Institute, La Jolla, Calif (Dr Beutler); Department of Medicine, Case Western Reserve University, Metrohealth Medical Center, Cleveland, Ohio (Dr Brittenham); the School of Business, University of Wisconsin, Madison (Dr Buchanan); Department of Pediatrics and School of Law, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tenn (Dr Clayton); Department of Medicine, University of Queensland and the Queensland Institute of Medical Research, Brisbane, Australia (Dr Powell); Mercator Genetics, Menlo Park, Calif (Dr Sigal); and Department of Pediatrics, University of Arizona, Tucson, (Dr Wilfond). Dr Meslin is now with the National Bioethics Advisory Committee, Washington, DC. Dr Press is now with the Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, Oregon Health Sciences University, Portland. Dr Buchanan is now with the Department of Philosophy, University of Arizona, Tucson. Dr Sigal is now an employee of Bristol-Myers-Squibb, Princeton, NJ.
Objective.— To evaluate the role of genetic testing in screening for hereditary
hemochromatosis to help guide clinicians, policymakers, and researchers.
Participants.— An expert panel was convened on March 3, 1997, by the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention (CDC) and the National Human Genome Research Institute
(NHGRI), with expertise in epidemiology, genetics, hepatology, iron overload
disorders, molecular biology, public health, and the ethical, legal, and social
implications surrounding the discovery and use of genetic information.
Evidence.— The group reviewed evidence regarding the clinical presentation, natural
history, and genetics of hemochromatosis, including current data on the candidate
gene for hemochromatosis (HFE) and on the ethical
and health policy implications of genetic testing for this disorder.
Consensus Process.— Consensus was achieved by group discussion confirmed by a voice vote.
A draft of the consensus statement was prepared by a writing committee and
subsequently reviewed and revised by all members of the expert group over
a 1-year period.
Conclusions.— Genetic testing is not recommended at this time in population-based
screening for hereditary hemochromatosis, due to uncertainties about prevalence
and penetrance of HFE mutations and the optimal care
of asymptomatic people carrying HFE mutations. In
addition, use of a genetic screening test raises concerns regarding possible
stigmatization and discrimination. Tests for HFE
mutations may play a role in confirming the diagnosis of hereditary hemochromatosis
in persons with elevated serum iron measures, but even this use is limited
by uncertainty about genotype-phenotype correlations. To address these questions,
the expert group accorded high priority to population-based research to define
the prevalence of HFE mutations, age and sex-related
penetrance of different HFE genotypes, interactions
between HFE genotypes and environmental modifiers,
and psychosocial outcomes of genetic screening for hemochromatosis.
Burke W, Thomson E, Khoury MJ, McDonnell SM, Press N, Adams PC, Barton JC, Beutler E, Brittenham G, Buchanan A, Clayton EW, Cogswell ME, Meslin EM, Motulsky AG, Powell LW, Sigal E, Wilfond BS, Collins FS. Hereditary HemochromatosisGene Discovery and Its Implications for Population-Based Screening. JAMA. 1998;280(2):172-178. doi:10.1001/jama.280.2.172