Author Affiliations: The George Institute,
University of Sydney, Camperdown, Sydney, Australia (Dr Huxley and Mr Colman);
Department of Community Health Sciences, St George’s Hospital Medical
School, London, England (Drs Owen, Whincup, and Cook); and Clinical Trial
Service Unit and Epidemiological Studies Unit, University of Oxford, Oxford,
England (Dr Collins).
Context Inverse associations between birth weight and subsequent blood cholesterol
levels have been used to support the “fetal origins” hypothesis
of the relevance of fetal nutrition to adult disease.
Objectives To perform a systematic review of the association between birth weight
and total blood cholesterol levels, and to explore the impact of including
unpublished results, adjusting for potential confounders.
Data Sources and Study Selection Relevant studies published by September 30, 2004, were identified through
literature searches using EMBASE and MEDLINE and MeSH heading search strategy
(using terms such as birth weight, intrauterine growth retardation, fetal growth retardation and cholesterol, lipoprotein, lipid). Studies that reported qualitative
or quantitative estimates of the association between birth weight and total
blood cholesterol, or had recorded both measures but not reported on their
associations, were included.
Data Extraction A total of 79 relevant studies involving a total of 74 122 individuals
were identified; 65 had reported on the direction of the association between
birth weight and total blood cholesterol. Although regression coefficients
were published for only 11 studies and other quantitative estimates for 3
other studies, regression coefficients (published or unpublished) were obtained
for 58 studies among 68 974 individuals.
Data Synthesis Inverse associations were observed in 11 of 14 studies that had previously
published quantitative estimates but in only 18 of the remaining 51 that had
reported on the direction of this association (heterogeneity P = .004). Similarly, the weighted estimate for the 11 studies
was –1.89 mg/dL (–0.049 mmol/L) total cholesterol per kilogram
birth weight compared with –0.69 mg/dL (–0.018 mmol/L) per kilogram
for 47 studies that provided unpublished regression coefficients (heterogeneity P = .009). Overall, the weighted estimate from
the 58 contributing studies was –1.39 mg/dL (–0.036 mmol/L) per
kilogram (95% confidence interval, –1.81 to –0.97 mg/dL [–0.047
to –0.025 mmol/L]), but there was significant heterogeneity between
their separate results (P<.001). Part of
this heterogeneity appears to reflect stronger associations reported from
smaller studies and studies of cholesterol levels in infants.
Conclusion These findings suggest that impaired fetal growth does not have effects
on blood cholesterol levels that would have a material impact on vascular
Huxley R, Owen CG, Whincup PH, Cook DG, Colman S, Collins R. Birth Weight and Subsequent Cholesterol LevelsExploration of the “Fetal Origins” Hypothesis. JAMA. 2004;292(22):2755–2764. doi:10.1001/jama.292.22.2755