—To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of alternative policies for human immunodeficiency testing (HIV) testing of physicians and dentists.
—Decision analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis from a societal perspective were used. Data were derived from extensive literature review and consultation with experts. We conducted sensitivity analyses and also performed a cost-benefit analysis.
—We analyzed policies for mandatory or voluntary testing of all physicians, surgeons, and dentists; for those testing positive, we analyzed mandatory or voluntary exclusion from practice, restriction from performance of invasive procedures, or requirements to inform patients of serostatus.
Main Outcome Measure.
—Cost per patient infection averted.
—Although one-time mandatory testing of surgeons and dentists with mandatory restriction of those found to be HIV-positive is more cost-effective than other policies, the cost-effectiveness varies tremendously under different scenarios. Results were highly sensitive to several data inputs, especially HIV seroprevalence of surgeons and dentists and transmission risk. For example, under a medium seroprevalence and transmission risk scenario, mandatory testing of all surgeons might avert 25 infections at a total cost of $27.9 million or $1 115 000 per infection averted and an incremental cost of $291 000 compared with current testing; however, the incremental cost-effectiveness per patient infection averted ranges from $29 807 000 under a low-risk scenario to a savings of $81 000 under a high-risk scenario.
—Our analysis neither justifies nor precludes a mandatory testing policy. Further research on the key data inputs is needed. Given the ethical, social, and public health implications, mandatory testing policies should not be implemented without greater certainty as to their cost-effectiveness.(JAMA. 1994;271:851-858)
Phillips KA, Lowe RA, Kahn JG, Lurie P, Avins AL, Ciccarone D. The Cost-effectiveness of HIV Testing of Physicians and Dentists in the United States. JAMA. 1994;271(11):851-858. doi:10.1001/jama.1994.03510350061038