This article is only available in the PDF format. Download the PDF to view the article, as well as its associated figures and tables.
Minneapolis, Minn., Oct. 2, 1898.
To the Editor:
—A medical friend having called my attention to your interesting article on "The Hygiene of Music," in your issue of September 24, I beg leave to offer a few suggestions in amplification of your remarks.The question as to whether music appeals exclusively to the emotional appears to be mooted rather one-sidedly. In music, as in any other field of education, we do not make a sufficiently clear distinction between appreciation and creation. Waiving the discussion as to whether the excessive indulgence in either branch (I use this expression for want of a better one) must needs result detrimentally to the individual, I desire to call attention to the fact that when the intellect is to be employed, there is a vast difference between a mere indulgence in rendered music and the execution of music. Your esteemed colleague, the recently departed Dr.
Hermann AL. Hygiene of Music.. JAMA. 1898;XXXI(16):939-940. doi:10.1001/jama.1898.02450160061013