[Skip to Content]
Sign In
Individual Sign In
Create an Account
Institutional Sign In
OpenAthens Shibboleth
[Skip to Content Landing]
September 3, 1997

Cardiac Auscultatory Skills of Internal Medicine and Family Practice TraineesA Comparison of Diagnostic Proficiency

Author Affiliations

From the Department of Medicine (Dr Mangione), Office of Faculty Affairs (Dr Nieman), and Department of Family Medicine (Dr Nieman), Allegheny University of the Health Sciences, Philadelphia, Pa.

JAMA. 1997;278(9):717-722. doi:10.1001/jama.1997.03550090041030

Context.  —Medical educators have had a growing sense that proficiency in physical diagnostic skills is waning, but few data have examined the question critically.

Objective, Design, and Setting.  —To compare the cardiac auscultatory proficiency of medical students and physicians in training. A multicenter cross-sectional assessment of students and house staff. A total of 8 internal medicine and 23 family practice programs of the mid-Atlantic area.

Participants.  —A total of 453 physicians in training and 88 medical students.

Interventions.  —All participants listened to 12 cardiac events directly recorded from patients, which they identified by completing a multiple-choice questionnaire.

Main Outcome Measures.  —Scores were expressed as the percentage of participants, for year and type of training, who correctly identified each event. Cumulative scores were expressed as the total number of events correctly recognized. An adjusted score was calculated whenever participants selected not only the correct finding but also findings that are acoustically similar and yet absent.

Results.  —Trainees' cumulative scores ranged between 0 and 7 for both internal medicine and family practice residents (median, 2.5 and 2.0, respectively). Internal medicine residents had the highest cumulative adjusted scores for the 6 extra sounds and for all 12 cardiac events tested (P=.01 and.02, respectively). On average, internal medicine and family practice residents recognized 20% of all cardiac events; the number of correct identifications improved little with year of training and was not significantly higher than the number identified by medical students.

Conclusions.  —Both Both internal medicine and family practice trainees had a disturbingly low identification rate for 12 important and commonly encountered cardiac events. This study suggests a need to improve the teaching and assessment of cardiac auscultation during generalists' training, particularly with the advent of managed care and its search for more cost-effective uses of technology.

Kern DC, Parrino TA, Korst DR.  The lasting value of clinical skills . JAMA . 1985;254:70-76.Article
Kaufman M.  Try a little tenderness . Philadelphia Inquirer Sunday Magazine . (October 27) ,1991;C3.
Verrees M.  Touch me . JAMA . 1996;276:1285-1286.Article
Montagu A. Touching: The Human Significance of the Skin . 3rd ed. New York, NY: Perennial Library; 1986.
Peterson MC, Holbrook JH, Hales DV, Smith NL, Staker LV.  Contributions of the history, physical examination, and laboratory investigation in making medical diagnoses . West J Med . 1992;156:163-165.
Wiener S, Nathanson M.  Physical examination: frequently observed errors . JAMA . 1976;236:852-855.Article
Nassar ME.  The stethoscopeless cardiologist . J R Soc Med . 1988;81:501-502.
Mangione S, Nieman LZ, Gracely E, Kaye D.  The teaching and practice of cardiac auscultation during internal medicine and cardiology training: a nationwide survey . Ann Intern Med . 1993;119:47-54.Article
Mangione S, Loudon RG, Fiel SB.  Lung auscultation during internal medicine and pulmonary training: a nationwide survey . Chest . 1993;104:70S. Abstract.
St Clair EW, Oddone EZ, Waugh RA, Corey GR, Feussner JR.  Assessing housestaff diagnostic skills using a cardiology patient simulator . Ann Intern Med . 1992;117:751-756.Article
Paauw DS, Wenrich MD, Curtis JR, Carline JD, Ramsey PG.  Ability of primary care physicians to recognize physical findings associated with HIV infection . JAMA . 1995;274:1380-1382.Article
Danford D, Nasir A, Gumbiner C.  Cost assessment for the evaluation of heart murmurs in children . Pediatrics . 1993;91:365-368.
Rahko PS.  Prevalence of regurgitant murmurs in patients with valvular regurgitation detected by Doppler echocardiography . Ann Intern Med . 1989;111:466-472.Article
Mangione S, O'Brien K, Peitzman SJ. Small group teaching of chest auscultation to third-year medical students. Acad Med. In press.
Westberg J, Jason H.  Fostering learners' reflection and self-assessment . Fam Med . 1994;26:278-282.
Smith RC, Mettler JA, Stoffelmayr BE, et al.  Improving residents' confidence in using psycho-social skills . J Gen Intern Med . 1995;10:315-320.Article
Lembo N,Dell'Italia L, Crawford M, O'Rourke R.  Bedside diagnosis of systolic murmurs . N Engl J Med . 1988;318:1572-1578.Article
Roldan CA, Shively BK, Crawford MH.  Value of the cardiovascular physical examination for detecting valvular heart disease in asymptomatic subjects . Am J Cardiol . 1996;77:1327-1331.Article