Copyright 2011 American Medical Association. All Rights Reserved. Applicable FARS/DFARS Restrictions Apply to Government Use.2011
The occurrence of multiple Spitz nevi is rare, especially the disseminated variant. Multiple Spitz nevi may be confused with, and must be differentiated from, primary spitzoid melanoma and cutaneous melanoma metastases. Over the past decade, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) has emerged as a tool for studying melanocytic neoplasms, helping to differentiate between melanoma and benign melanocytic nevi. We describe 2 cases of patients with multiple Spitz nevi and their FISH results.
One case of disseminated Spitz nevi, in a 17-year-old female, showed balanced tetraploidy using FISH, while the other case, in a 51-year-old female with multiple Spitz nevi, showed normal diploid cells without significant gains or losses in chromosomes 6 or 11.
Patients may present with multiple, even disseminated, Spitz nevi. This phenotype should not be confused with melanoma and/or cutaneous metastasis. The use of FISH studies in context with careful correlation of clinical features and dermoscopic and histologic findings can assist in the diagnostic workup.
Spitz nevi are benign melanocytic proliferations with distinct histologic features. They usually present as solitary lesions, but some patients develop multiple lesions. Multiple Spitz nevi may present with an agminated pattern or widely scattered over different parts of the body. Individual lesions of Spitz nevi typically present as red or pink dome-shaped papules to brown or black macules. While most commonly found in children younger than 10 years on the head, trunk, or extremities,1 they can also be seen in adults.2 More than 42 cases of the agminated type have been described, occurring most frequently on the face, back, and extremities.1,3,4 The disseminated variant is the most rare, with only 15 cases reported in the literature.5- 9
These cases can be challenging to interpret from a clinical and histologic perspective, and distinction from melanoma or melanoma with multiple epidermotropic metastases is critical. Cutaneous metastases has a poor prognosis and is staged as either IIIB or IIIC for in-transit disease if localized to an anatomic region, or stage IV for distant cutaneous metastases according to the most current American Joint Committee on Cancer Staging system. The 5-year survival rate is less than 25%, with almost no 10-year survivors.10 In contrast, the disseminated variant of Spitz nevi is entirely a benign entity, with no reports of malignant transformation or disease progression.5- 7,9 Hence, the importance of recognizing and differentiating between the 2 must be stressed to avoid unnecessary diagnostic procedures and therapeutic interventions.
Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) is evolving to become a routine diagnostic tool for the evaluation of melanocytic lesions. FISH findings in malignant melanomas include frequent imbalanced clonal chromosomal alterations.11,12 While most Spitz nevi are karyotypically normal, approximately 5% to 10% may have balanced gains with tetraploidy,13 and approximately 20% may have an isolated gain in chromosomal locus 11p.14 We describe 2 cases of patients with multiple Spitz nevi, 1 of which was found to have balanced tetraploidy by FISH, the other with normal diploid cells without significant gains or losses. The first patient was part of an earlier study looking at incidence of polyploidy in Spitz nevi.15 We review how the clinical and histologic features, along with the FISH results, confirm the diagnosis of disseminated Spitz nevi in these 2 patients.
A 17-year-old female of Italian descent was referred to the Pigmented Lesions Clinic at the Department of Dermatology, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois, in late 2007 with multiple pink and brown dome-shaped papules. All lesions had appeared during the 1 year prior to presentation. Several lesions were first noted on her elbows and buttocks as pink to tan macules. She continued to develop more lesions over the next 10 months as many became enlarged to raised dome-shaped papules. The lesions seemed to be precipitated by sun exposure. There was no family history of melanoma.
Physical examination revealed more than 50 pink, brown, and multicolored macules and papules, measuring from 1 mm up to 7 mm, on the head and neck, bilateral elbows, extensor and flexor aspects of the arms, thighs, and bilateral buttocks (Figure 1). No lymphadenopathy or hepatosplenomegaly was detected. Dermoscopic evaluation showed features atypical of Spitz nevi with most lesions showing a pink asymmetric peripheral corona (Figure 1B).
Pink to brown and multicolored Spitz nevi on the buttocks of patient 1. A, Clinical close-up of Spitz nevus from patient 1. B, Dermoscopic findings of the lesion shown in panel B reveal asymmetric brown globular and reticulated pigment with loss of pigment in some areas. Measurements are given in centimeters.
A review of 17 biopsies performed over 18 months showed mostly classic histologic features of Spitz nevi (left forearm, left lateral thigh, right lateral posterior thigh, left superior buttock, left mid buttock, right arm, and right wrist), while others showed desmoplastic Spitz (chin, right knee) or conventional Spitz nevi with variable cytologic atypia (left ear; right buttock, ×3; left elbow; right posterior upper arm; right medial thigh; right lateral anterior thigh).
Typical lesions from the first patient showed epithelial hyperplasia surmounting a symmetric proliferation of epithelioid and spindled-shaped melanocytes arranged in nests and vertically oriented fascicles with occasional Kamino bodies and good maturation (Figure 2A). Occasional nuclear atypia was noted (Figure 2B). All the biopsy specimens were reviewed by 2 dermatopathologists (J.G. and P.G.), and none of these lesions showed features concerning for malignant disease.
A symmetrical compound melanocytic lesion. A, Histologic findings with uniform epidermal hyperplasia from patient 1 (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnification ×40). B, Large nests of epithelioid melanocytes with variable pigment and pagetoid spread of melanocytes in the epidermis (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnification ×100). C-F, Polyploidy with uniform gains in all probes studied: C, 6p25 ; D, Cep6 ; E, 6q23 ; and F, 11q13 (original magnification ×600; fluorescence in situ hybridization).
Four of these lesions were tested by FISH targeting 4 distinct loci and specific genes: 6p25 (RREB1), 6q23 (MYB), 11q13 (cyclin D1), and Cep6 (the centromeric portion of chromosome 6). Detailed methods have been reported in previous manuscripts.16 FISH analysis showed a significant population of tetraploid cells in 3 of 4 cases, while the fourth case showed typical diploid cells. The tetraploid cells showed balanced gains in 6p25 (RREB1), 6q23 (MYB), 11q13 (cyclin D1), and Cep6, with all cells having 3 or 4 identifiable copies of each chromosomal segment (Figure 2C-F). In each of these cases, tetraploidy was confirmed with a probe targeting the X chromosome, showing 4 copies (female) in the same regions in which copy number gains were identified with the original probe set. A diagnosis of disseminated Spitz nevi was rendered, and follow-up of the patient over the subsequent 2.5 years has been uneventful.
A 51-year-old white woman was referred to Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center (MSKCC), New York, New York, with a history of “atypical Spitz nevi/tumors.” Her first such lesion was removed from the groin at age 35 years. There was no associated preceding event prior to the development of that lesion. She had no family history of melanoma and was otherwise in good health.
Prior to her visit to MSKCC, the patient had a spitzoid melanocytic proliferation excised from the left buttock that had been reported as a “borderline Spitz tumor.” She then subsequently developed several additional pink papules on the left buttock, the right hip, and upper thigh (Figure 3A and B). Dermoscopic evaluation of these pink papules revealed the presence of irregular linear and serpentine blood vessels, both of which can be seen in melanoma (Figure 3,inset). Based on the medical history and clinical and dermoscopic examination, the clinical concern for a spitzoid melanoma with cutaneous metastases was raised. There was no lymphadenopathy or hepatosplenomegaly.
Spitz nevi. A, Multiple Spitz nevi on the buttocks and upper thigh of patient 2. B, Clinical close-up of Spitz nevus from patient 2. Inset, Dermoscopic findings of lesion shown in panel B reveal atypical blood vessels.
Four outside biopsy specimens were rereviewed, and 2 additional biopsy specimens were taken and examined histopathologically. All biopsy specimens were interpreted as being variants of Spitz nevus. The histologic appearance ranged from densely cellular compound melanocytic nevi with a predominant nested growth pattern at the dermoepidermal junction with Kamino bodies to sclerosing Spitz nevi, showing epithelioid melanocytes in a fibrotic dermal stroma, with lack of evidence of proliferation (a mitotic index of 0, a Ki-67 labeling index of <1%). Given the previously stated concerns by an outside pathologist about a “borderline” tumor and keeping in mind the diagnostic difficulty and controversy regarding the accurate diagnosis of spitzoid melanocytic tumors, FISH analysis was performed on 1 of the biopsy samples performed at MSKCC. The results of the analysis revealed normal diploid cells without significant gains or losses in chromosomes 6 or 11, a frequent site of genomic alteration in melanomas.
As with patient 1, the constellation of clinical and histologic findings was felt to fit best with an eruption of multiple Spitz nevi. To date, follow-up over the subsequent 1 year has been uneventful.
In the cases of Spitz nevi presenting with an agminated, eruptive, or disseminated pattern, it is important to exclude melanoma with cutaneous in-transit disease or disseminated cutaneous metastases. Cutaneous melanoma metastases may clinically appear to be very similar to disseminated Spitz nevi, as small-to-medium dome-shaped papules or nodules that may be skin-colored, pink, brown, or black. The average age of patients with in-transit or cutaneous metastases is older than 50 years, and metastases occur most frequently with primary tumors on the lower extremity,17,18 whereas the average age of patients with disseminated Spitz nevi is 23 years without clear lesional site predilections.9 Cutaneous pigmented metastases dermoscopically lack the classic features of pigmented Spitz nevi, such as a starburst pattern. Frequently, history of sunburn,19 intravenous drug use,6 pregnancy,20 and other types of cutaneous stimulation, including trauma and radiotherapy5,21 have been reported as triggers to disseminated Spitz nevi. The eruptive presentation of clinically typical lesions following acute sun exposure favored a diagnosis of disseminated Spitz nevi in patient 1.
Histologically, in-transit melanoma metastases tend to lie within the reticular dermis or subcutis, often with an intralymphatic component. Epidermotropic cutaneous metastases may occur. Typical features of Spitz nevi, including Kamino bodies, and prominent maturation, would be unlikely, whereas high mitotic counts and expansile nodular growth would be more common in cutaneous metastases. Cutaneous metastases also frequently have more fibrosis and more of an inflammatory host response.22 However, some overlapping features may exist. For example, amelanotic melanoma metastases often reveal atypical vessels, which are indistinguishable from those encountered in some amelanotic Spitz nevi (Figure 3C), thus making it impossible in some cases to clinically differentiate between these 2 entities.
While both cytogenetic tools like comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) and FISH may be clinically useful diagnostic aids for such situations, they both have distinct advantages and disadvantages. CGH offers the advantage of evaluated the entire chromosomal spectrum. However, a disadvantage is that it requires a pure population of melanocytes in order to isolate sufficient DNA, typically requiring a bulky dermal component. In addition, chromosomal aberrations need to be representative in most of the lesion in order to be identifiable. Hence, chromosomal aberrations present in a small focus of melanoma arising in a nevus maybe diluted by the larger nevus component and therefore undetectable. FISH offers the advantage of greater sensitivity within any specific targeted locus and better morphologic comparison with molecular findings. The disadvantage, of course, is the lower overall sensitivity since only the targeted loci are evaluated.
FISH studies in both of our cases failed to show diagnostic changes of melanoma. Patient 1 had a number of samples with many tetraploid cells. Our previous study15 has shown that this is a finding in perhaps 5% to 10% of Spitz nevi and hence is not a diagnostic finding of melanoma. Patient 2 showed typical diploid cells and also lacked any diagnostic FISH findings of melanoma. In conjunction with the clinical and histologic features, we believe this strongly supports a final diagnosis of disseminated Spitz nevi in both cases and shows that molecular techniques maybe used to help confirm the diagnosis in such novel and challenging cases.
Correspondence: Pedram Gerami, MD, Department of Dermatology, Northwestern University, 676 N St Clair St, Ste 1600, Chicago, IL 60611 (Pedram.Gerami@nmff.org).
Accepted for Publication: September 16, 2010.
Author Contributions: Drs Boone and Gerami had full access to all of the data in the study and take responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis. Study concept and design: Boone, Busam, and Gerami. Acquisition of data: Boone, Busam, Marghoob, Fang, Martini, and Gerami. Analysis and interpretation of data: Boone, Busam, Marghoob, Fang, Guitart, and Gerami. Drafting of the manuscript: Boone and Busam. Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Boone, Busam, Marghoob, Fang, Guitart, Martini, and Gerami. Administrative, technical, and material support: Boone, Marghoob, Fang, Martini, and Gerami. Study supervision: Boone, Busam, Guitart, Martini, and Gerami.
Financial Disclosure: Dr Gerami has served as a consultant to and received honoraria from Abbott Molecular and Neogenomics Inc. The FISH materials used in these cases were purchased from Abbott Molecular Inc for clinical purposes.
Funding/Support: Dr Gerami receives research support from the Dermatology Foundation, the Irene D. Pritzker Foundation, and the American Cancer Society, Illinois Division.
Role of the Sponsors: The sponsors had no role in the design and conduct of the study; in the collection, analysis, and interpretation of data; or in the preparation, review, or approval of the manuscript. The sponsors provided no funding or materials, such as probes, for this study.
Boone SL, Busam KJ, Marghoob AA, Fang Y, Guitart J, Martini M, Gerami P. Two Cases of Multiple Spitz NeviCorrelating Clinical, Histologic, and Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization Findings. Arch Dermatol. 2011;147(2):227-231. doi:10.1001/archdermatol.2010.439