Age-adjusted mortality rates for bullous skin diseases, 1979 through 2002. TEN indicates toxic epidermal necrolysis.
Risser J, Lewis K, Weinstock MA. Mortality of Bullous Skin Disorders From 1979 Through 2002 in the United States. Arch Dermatol. 2009;145(9):1005-1008. doi:10.1001/archdermatol.2009.205
To identify and analyze trends in bullous disease mortality from 1979 through 2002 in the United States.
Retrospective population-based analysis.
Mortality records from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention mortality database.
Mortality records from 1979 through 2002 for persons who died of bullous disease.
Main Outcome Measures
Age-adjusted mortality rates and trends for 4 bullous disease subgroups: toxic epidermal necrolysis, pemphigoid, pemphigus, and epidermolysis bullosa.
The overall age-adjusted (to the 2000 US standard population) annual mortality rate from bullous diseases of the skin was 0.103 death per 100 000. The average mortality from bullous disorders was 0.098 per 100 000 in 1979 through 1982 and remained stable at 0.099 per 100 000 during the final 4 years of the study, 1999 through 2002. Pemphigoid had a significant increase in mortality from 1979 through 2002, while pemphigus demonstrated a significant decrease in mortality. The mortality rate for toxic epidermal necrolysis was much higher among blacks (0.192 death per 100 000) than whites (0.025 per 100 000) (P < .001), with a mortality rate ratio of 7.57 (95% confidence interval, 6.97-8.21).
Overall mortality from bullous diseases remained stable from 1979 through 2002, although an increasing mortality from pemphigoid and a decreasing mortality from pemphigus occurred during this period. A very large racial disparity in mortality from toxic epidermal necrolysis was observed.
Not since Savin1 published data in 1976 regarding international mortality from bullous diseases have there been any significant attempts to quantify mortality and evaluate population trends in the broad category of bullous diseases of the skin in the United States. His analysis of mortality associated with bullous disorders between the years 1950 and 1972 showed a declining number of deaths from bullous diseases including pemphigus, pemphigoid, and dermatitis herpetiformis in England and Wales and in the United States. This decline in overall mortality coincided with the introduction of systemic corticosteroids for the treatment of bullous disorders, and Savin's findings of declining mortality were largely thought to reflect the therapeutic success achieved with corticosteroid medications for this group of disorders.
Although several studies have examined mortality rates within local or hospital-based populations since Savin's publication,2- 12 large national analyses in the United States are lacking and current mortality trends of these disorders are not well established. Bullous disorders remain a major source of noncancer deaths from dermatologic disease and continue to be therapeutically challenging diseases for dermatologists, hospitalists, internists, and ophthalmologists. In 1998, bullous skin disorders were the fourth most common cause of death from skin disease, following skin cancers, ulcers, and bacterial infections.13 Relatively high mortality rates for the bullous skin disorders and the complexity of care they present to multiple physicians across several disciplines highlight the need for further examination of current overall mortality trends in these diseases.
The purpose of this study is to describe trends in US national mortality rates for the 24-year period beginning in 1979 for the spectrum of bullous diseases including toxic epidermal necrolysis (TEN), pemphigoid, pemphigus, and epidermolysis bullosa.
We report a population-based analysis of bullous skin disease mortality in the United States from 1979 through 2002 based on death certificate records from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention mortality database (http://wonder.cdc.gov/). This database, Wide-Ranging Online Data for Epidemiologic Research, provides access to public health information for public health professionals and the public at large and was accessed in January 2008.14
Mortality was analyzed in 4 general bullous disease subgroups: TEN (including erythema multiforme and Stevens-Johnson syndrome, which share the same codes in the International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision [ICD-9] and Tenth Revision [ICD-10]), pemphigoid disorders (hereinafter referred to as pemphigoid), pemphigus disorders (hereinafter referred to as pemphigus), and epidermolysis bullosa.
Codes from ICD-9 were used to identify the underlying cause of death from 1979 through 1998, and ICD-10 codes were used to identify the underlying cause of death from 1999 through 2002, reflecting the transition to the updated classification schema that occurred between these 2 periods.
The ICD-9 codes used in our study included 695.1 for TEN, 694.5 and 694.6 for pemphigoid, 694.4 for pemphigus, and 757.3 (other specified anomalies of skin) for epidermolysis bullosa. The ICD-10 codes that were used in our study included L51, L10, L12, and Q81 and their subgroups for TEN, pemphigoid, pemphigus, and epidermolysis bullosa, respectively.
Mortality rates were analyzed by both sex and race by means of StatXact (version 3.1; Cytel Software Corp, Cambridge, Massachusetts). Linear regression was performed to assess trends in death rates over time by means of SPSS statistical software (version 17.0; SPSS Inc, Chicago, Illinois). P < .05 was considered to be statistically significant. Institutional review board approval was not applicable to this study because it used publicly available data.
A total of 5848 deaths were attributable to bullous diseases in the United States from 1979 through 2002. The overall age-adjusted (to the 2000 US standard population) annual mortality rate from bullous diseases of the skin was 0.103 death per 100 000. A total of 2378 deaths in the 24-year period that we examined were from TEN. During this same period, pemphigoid led to 1530 deaths, pemphigus to 1226 deaths, and epidermolysis bullosa to 714 deaths; the age-adjusted mortality rate for TEN was 0.041 death per 100 000, whereas the age-adjusted mortality rates for pemphigoid, pemphigus, and epidermolysis bullosa were 0.028, 0.023, and 0.011 per 100 000, respectively.
Mortality varied by age, with pemphigoid and pemphigus having the highest concentration of deaths among the very old. Deaths were also concentrated among the elderly for patients with TEN, although less so than for pemphigoid and pemphigus. Death from epidermolysis bullosa occurred almost exclusively among infants, and there was a very small proportion of TEN deaths among infants as well (Table).
During the first 4 years of the period studied (1979-1982), the average mortality from bullous disorders was 0.098 death per 100 000, and during the last 4 years of the period (1999-2002), the average mortality from bullous diseases was similar, 0.099 per 100 000.
For some of these disorders, age-adjusted mortality rates varied over time during this 24-year period. For pemphigoid we noted a significant increase of 0.0055 death per 100 000 per decade (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.0025-0.0086 per 100 000; F = 14.6, P = .001), from 0.020 in 1979-1982 to 0.029 twenty years later. By contrast, there was a significant decrease in the age-adjusted mortality rate for pemphigus of 0.0066 death per 100 000 per decade during the study period (95% CI, −0.0096 to −0.0041 per 100 000; F = 26.5, P < .001). This change reflects a decrease from 0.033 in 1979-1982 to 0.021 in 1999-2002. Linear regression failed to show any significant changes in mortality trends from 1979-2002 for TEN or for epidermolysis bullosa (Figure).
The mortality rate for TEN was much higher among blacks (0.192 death per 100 000) than whites (0.025 per 100 000) (P < .001), with a mortality rate ratio of 7.57 (95% CI, 6.97-8.21). The relative risk of death from TEN for black females vs black males was 1.40 (P < .001; 95% CI, 1.21-1.60), whereas the relative risk of death from TEN for white females vs white males was 1.16 (P = .01; 95% CI, 1.03-1.30).
Mortality rates were also higher among blacks than whites for pemphigoid (0.051 vs 0.026 death per 100 000; P < .001). The relative risk of death from pemphigoid in blacks vs whites was 1.95 (P < .001; 95% CI, 1.68-2.25), and females were at slightly increased risk of death from pemphigoid (relative risk, 1.18; P = .004; 95% CI, 1.06-1.32).
Blacks had greater mortality rates for pemphigus than whites (0.030 vs 0.022 death per 100 000), and their relative risk of death was 1.38 (P < .001; 95% CI, 1.16-1.65). There was no significant difference in risk of death from pemphigus by sex.
The mortality rate for blacks was similarly higher than that for whites in the epidermolysis bullosa group (0.016 vs 0.011 death per 100 000), and blacks were 1.44 times as likely as whites to die of epidermolysis bullosa (P < .001; 95% CI, 1.20-1.73). Females had a slightly increased risk of death from epidermolysis bullosa (relative risk, 1.23; P = .007; 95% CI, 1.06-1.43).
This study of mortality from bullous disorders during a 24-year period found that pemphigoid mortality increased while mortality from pemphigus decreased. A very large racial disparity in mortality from TEN was observed.
A recently published study identified that the incidences of bullous pemphigoid and pemphigus vulgaris are increasing in the United Kingdom,15 but changes in incidence of pemphigoid and pemphigus in the United States are unknown, as is their effect on mortality rates. Several prospective and retrospective studies have evaluated prognostic factors in patients with bullous pemphigoid, and the type of therapy patients have received has not been found to be related to overall prognosis or mortality.2,4- 6,8- 12,16- 18 There is also no obvious relationship between the introduction of the limited number of agents used to treat bullous pemphigoid and the shifts in mortality during the period studied. Thus, changes in therapy may not be contributing to the observed increase in bullous pemphigoid death rates. Indeed, a recent study found little impact in overall mortality due to bullous pemphigoid.9 A retrospective study by Carson et al19 suggested that mortality from pemphigus decreased significantly with the addition of adjuvant therapy (azathioprine, cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, and gold) to corticosteroids during the period from 1969 through 1991. Further introduction of plasmapheresis and then intravenous immunoglobulin in the mid-1990s for treatment-refractory cases may have also contributed to declining mortality.20- 22
Mortality for black persons was significantly higher for every bullous disease studied and was particularly marked in the TEN group of disorders, but the cause, perhaps including social or other factors, cannot be determined from our data.
This study provides a broad descriptive analysis of trends in bullous disease mortality in the United States during the 24-year period from 1979-2002 through interpretation and analysis of national mortality records. Key strengths include the use of a large population-based data source covering billions of person-years of observation using routine death certification, and the ability to use these data to assess trends over a quarter-century. The size of the population and the duration of the observation period allow examination of issues that might not otherwise be assessable. However, there were several limitations of our investigation. First, the accuracy of the reporting of deaths from bullous disorders was not independently verified. Hence, we may have overestimated or underestimated the true mortality of these disorders or the trends in rates. Second, the classification schemas used to report the diseases may also lead to inaccurate measurements of mortality rates. This is particularly possible in the classification of epidermolysis bullosa with the ICD-9 code of 757.3, which covers a broad range of skin diseases beyond epidermolysis bullosa alone. Therefore, mortality attributable to this group of disorders may be overestimated for the years 1979 through 1998. Finally, very little information about the persons who died of these diseases was available for analysis, and therefore interpretation of the findings is limited to rather broad speculation about the factors driving the trends observed.
We have provided an overview of trends of bullous skin diseases that demonstrates significant shifts in mortality for both pemphigus and pemphigoid, and important racial discrepancies in mortality. Although this study perhaps raises more questions than it answers, we hope it will serve as a springboard to the investigation of the causes of these trends so that dermatologists, internists, and other specialists will be better able to reduce bullous disease mortality in the future.
Correspondence: Martin A. Weinstock, MD, PhD, Dermatoepidemiology Unit, Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Mail Stop 111D, 830 Chalkstone Ave, Providence, RI 02908 (firstname.lastname@example.org).
Accepted for Publication: February 4, 2009.
Author Contributions: All authors had full access to all the data in the study and take responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis. Study concept and design: Weinstock. Acquisition of data: Risser, Lewis, and Weinstock. Analysis and interpretation of data: Risser, Lewis, and Weinstock. Drafting of the manuscript: Risser and Weinstock. Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectualcontent: Risser and Weinstock. Statistical analysis: Risser, Lewis, and Weinstock. Study supervision: Weinstock.
Financial Disclosure: None reported.
Funding/Support: Dr Weinstock is supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs Office of Research and Development Cooperative Studies Program and by grants R01CA106592, R01CA106807, R25CA087972, and R01AR49342 from the National Institutes of Health.
Additional Contributions: Jason Machan, PhD, made invaluable contributions to our statistical analysis.