Map of the Lombardy region (Italy) showing the location of the 53 air pollution monitors in the 9 areas identified for the study.
Level of exposure to fine particulate matter and the risk of deep vein thrombosis (DVT). The graph demonstrates the observed relationship between the relative risk of DVT and the level of particulate matter of less than 10 μm in aerodynamic diameter (PM10) in the year preceding the diagnosis. These results suggest a linear relationship between exposure and risk, though the 95% confidence intervals (shaded areas) are wide at the extremes of exposure. Risk is depicted in comparison with a reference value of 12.0 μg/m3 (minimum observed PM10 level). The histogram in the bottom part illustrates the density of exposure distribution for air pollution. Risk estimates are adjusted for age, sex, year of diagnosis, area of residence, body mass index, education, current use of oral contraceptives or hormone therapy, Leiden V or prothrombin mutations, season, and ambient temperature.
Baccarelli A, Martinelli I, Zanobetti A, Grillo P, Hou L, Bertazzi PA, Mannucci PM, Schwartz J. Exposure to Particulate Air Pollution and Risk of Deep Vein Thrombosis. Arch Intern Med. 2008;168(9):920-927. doi:10.1001/archinte.168.9.920
Particulate air pollution has been linked to heart disease and stroke, possibly resulting from enhanced coagulation and arterial thrombosis. Whether particulate air pollution exposure is related to venous thrombosis is unknown.
We examined the association of exposure to particulate matter of less than 10 μm in aerodynamic diameter (PM10) with deep vein thrombosis (DVT) risk in 870 patients and 1210 controls from the Lombardy region in Italy, who were examined between 1995 and 2005. We estimated exposure to PM10 in the year before DVT diagnosis (cases) or examination (controls) through area-specific mean levels obtained from ambient monitors.
Higher mean PM10 level in the year before the examination was associated with shortened prothrombin time (PT) in DVT cases (standardized regression coefficient [β] = −0.12; 95% confidence interval [CI], −0.23 to 0.00) (P = .04) and controls (β = −0.06; 95% CI, −0.11 to 0.00) (P = .04). Each increase of 10 μg/m3 in PM10 was associated with a 70% increase in DVT risk (odds ratio [OR], 1.70; 95% CI, 1.30 to 2.23) (P < .001) in models adjusting for clinical and environmental covariates. The exposure-response relationship was approximately linear over the observed PM10 range. The association between PM10 level and DVT risk was weaker in women (OR, 1.40; 95% CI, 1.02 to 1.92) (P = .02 for the interaction between PM10 and sex), particularly in those using oral contraceptives or hormone therapy (OR, 0.97; 95% CI, 0.58 to 1.61) (P = .048 for the interaction between PM10 level and hormone use).
Long-term exposure to particulate air pollution is associated with altered coagulation function and DVT risk. Other risk factors for DVT may modulate the effect of particulate air pollution.
Exposure to particulate air pollution has been associated with increased short- and long-term morbidity and mortality from heart disease and stroke.1- 4 Hypercoagulability and enhanced thrombosis have been indicated as one mechanistic pathway that mediates such effects,4,5 since higher plasma levels of coagulation proteins such as factor VIII, von Willebrand factor, and fibrinogen have been associated with the exposure.5- 7 Recently, changes in coagulation function resulting in shortened prothrombin time (PT) have been observed in association with higher mean level of particulate air pollution of less than 10 μm in aerodynamic diameter (PM10) in the 30 days before the examination, suggesting that extended PM10 exposure may cause effects on blood clotting.8
Procoagulant abnormalities are stronger determinants of venous than of arterial thrombosis,9 and increased risk of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) has been associated with a series of heritable or acquired risk factors that cause hypercoagulability, including factor V Leiden and G20210A prothrombin mutations, deficiencies of the natural anticoagulant proteins antithrombin, protein C and protein S, and use of oral contraceptive or hormone therapy.10,11 In rat and hamster models developed to investigate mechanisms involved in arterial thrombosis, inhalation or intravenous administration of air pollution constituents—such as diesel exhausts and ultrafine particles—induces thrombosis of the femoral6 and ear veins.12 In human subjects, to our knowledge, no evidence is currently available relating air pollution exposure to DVT. In the present study, we investigated whether long-term ambient PM10 exposure was associated with increased thrombotic susceptibility and higher DVT risk in a large epidemiologic investigation conducted in the Lombardy region in northern Italy.
The cases included 871 patients (420 men and 451 women), who were Lombardy region residents and had been diagnosed between January 1995 through September 2005 as having lower limb DVT with or without symptomatic pulmonary embolism. Cases were referred to the Thrombosis Center, University of Milan, and IRCCS (Istituto di Ricovero e Cura a Carattere Scientifico) Maggiore Hospital, Milan, Italy, for a thrombophilia screening and were asked to bring all available clinical documentation. From this documentation, DVT was diagnosed based on evidence from objective methods such as compression ultrasonography or venography. Cases were asked about the presence of transient DVT risk factors in the month preceding the event, including surgery, trauma, immobilization (≥10 days), use of oral contraceptives or hormone therapy, and pregnancy or puerperium (6-week period after delivery). In 170 cases (19.5%), DVT was complicated by symptomatic pulmonary embolism. A total of 761 cases (84.4%) had a first DVT during the study period, whereas 110 (12.6%) had recurrent DVT. Cases with recurrent DVT had not been included in the study after their first diagnosis, since they were recruited after their first visit at the Thrombosis Center.
The controls included 1210 healthy Lombardy region residents (490 men and 720 women), who volunteered to be investigated at the Thrombosis Center in the same study period as the cases. The controls were recruited by asking each of the cases for a list of friends or nonblood relatives, and they were randomly selected from these lists using an algorithm that balanced the age distribution of the controls to that of the cases. To increase power to evaluate a potential effect modification by use of oral contraceptives and hormone therapy, female controls were recruited in excess of female cases. Thrombosis was excluded in controls with a structured questionnaire validated for the retrospective diagnosis of venous thromboembolism. Information on clinical, lifestyle, and reproductive factors was collected from all participants during an in-person interview. For practical reasons, because most of the interviews took place while the patients with DVT were in the hospital, interviewers could not be blinded to the case status. However, the subjects' addresses were confirmed on administrative or other official records, and exposure was assigned, based on the address, by a statistician blinded to the case status. Participants' written informed consents and local institutional review board approvals were obtained before the study. Prothrombin time and activated partial thromboplastin time (aPTT) were measured using laboratory methods previously described.13 Patients with DVT, if receiving anticoagulant drugs, were not asked to stop the treatment.
Methods for exposure assignment were previously described in detail.8,14 Briefly, for each of the 9 geographic areas shown in Figure 1, mean concentrations of PM10 were computed using data from monitors located at 53 different sites throughout the Lombardy region. All participants were assigned to 1 of 9 geographic areas based on their residence at the time of the study.In our statistical analyses, PM10 level was evaluated using ambient PM10 concentrations averaged over the 365 days preceding the index date, also taking into account changes of residence during the same time window. Index dates were the date of diagnosis for DVT cases and the date of the examination for controls.
In previous work, we tested the association of shorter-term PM10 exposure with PT and aPTT in the same healthy subjects who served as controls in the present analysis.13 In the present study, to evaluate the association between PM10 and PT and aPTT between DVT cases or controls, we used the same statistical methods we previously described.13
Differences between cases and controls after stratification by geographic area or study period were tested using the Mantel-Haenszel method. The association of PM10 level with DVT risk was tested in a case-control analysis using unconditional logistic regression models including, as independent variables, sex, area of residence, education (elementary/middle school, high school, college), factor V Leiden or G20210A prothrombin mutation (yes/no), and current use of oral contraceptives or hormone therapy (yes/no). Variables with potentially nonlinear associations with risk, including age, body mass index, day of the year (for seasonality), index date (for long-term time trends), and ambient temperature, were controlled using penalized regression splines with 4 df for each variable.15 Unconditional regression was performed to allow for the use of penalized splines, which are not available for use in conditional logistic models in available software packages, as well as to avoid the loss from the analyses of subjects in incomplete sets due to participation refusal or missing exposure or covariate information. As approximation of the relative risk of DVT, we reported odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for each increase of 10 μg/m3 in the mean level of PM10. We used Stata version 9.0 (StataCorp, College Station, Texas) for descriptive analyses and R version 2.2.0 (R Project for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria) to fit regression models. All statistical tests were 2 sided, and P < .05 was considered statistically significant.
Table 1 gives the characteristics of the 871 DVT cases (420 men and 451 women) and 1210 controls (490 men and 720 women). Cases and controls had similar distributions by age (P = .12) and area of residence (P = .59). Cases had higher body mass index (P < .001); lower education (P = .01); more frequent use of oral contraceptives or hormone therapy (P < .001); and higher prevalences of factor V Leiden (P < .001), G20210 prothrombin mutation (P < .001), inherited deficiencies of natural anticoagulant proteins (P < .001), hyperhomocysteinemia (P < .001), and any of the causes of thrombophilia (P < .001). Controls were less likely to be examined for the study during the summer and their examinations were more frequent in the fall, whereas no major seasonal pattern was found for DVT diagnoses (P < .001). Mean ambient temperatures were higher on the days of diagnosis of DVT cases than on the days of examination of controls (P < .001). A larger proportion of controls were entered earlier in the study compared with cases (P < .001). This difference in recruitment was accounted for by performing analyses stratified by year and through the use of nonlinear terms for long-time trends in multivariable models.
Mean PM10 level over the 1 year before the examination was significantly associated with shortened PT in both cases (standardized regression coefficient [β] = −0.12; 95% CI, −0.23 to 0.00) (P = .04) and controls (β = −0.06; 95% CI −0.11 to 0.00) (P = .04). While the negative effects of mean PM10 levels on PT showed no major differences across means taken over 30, 60, 90, 180, or 270 days or 1 year (data not shown), the 1-year mean PM10 level was the only time window significantly associated with shortened PT among cases. A nonsignificant aPTT shortening was observed in association with the 1-year mean PM10 level among controls (β = −0.09; 95% CI, −0.19 to 0.01) (P = .07) but not in cases (β = 0.01; 95% CI, −0.03 to 0.04) (P = .78) (Table 2).
Table 3 presents the tertiles of the mean PM10 level measured in the area of residence during the year before the date of DVT diagnosis (cases) or date of examination (controls), according to their area of residence and year of study. In both cases and controls, PM10 level was highest in the Milan urban and suburban areas (P < .001). Subjects from the Alpine territory and the lower Valtellina Valley were all in the lowest tertile of PM10 exposure. In both cases and controls, the frequency of subjects being in the highest tertile of PM10 exposure was highest in the earlier years of the study, and it decreased throughout the study period, to reach the lowest frequency in the most recent years (P < .001).
The DVT cases tended to have higher PM10 levels than the controls, and this pattern was more evident after the data were stratified by year of the study (Table 3). The test for the difference between cases and controls by tertile of PM10 level was significant in the analysis stratified by year of the study (P = .002, Mantel-Haenszel test). Such a difference was not statistically significant without stratification by year of the study (P = .44, Fisher exact test), indicating that inequalities in the distribution of cases and controls by study period, if not controlled, would have biased the results.
We estimated the relative risk of DVT associated with PM10 level in a multivariable model controlled for age, sex, year of diagnosis, area of residence, body mass index, education, current use of oral contraceptives or hormone therapy, Leiden V or prothrombin mutations, season, and ambient temperature. In this model, an increase of 10 μg/m3 in PM10 level was associated with an adjusted OR of 1.70 (95% CI, 1.30 to 2.23) (P < .001). The increase in DVT risk was nearly linear across the range of exposure concentrations that were measured (Figure 2).
We also examined DVT risk in association with different exposure time windows using PM10 level averaged over 90 days in the 2 years before diagnosis (see supplementary Figure 1 and supplementary Table 1; available at: http://www.cdldevoto.it/didattic/materiale/Appendix_Archives_online.pdf). Risk of DVT increased progressively with the duration of the time window evaluated and was statistically significant in association with the 270-day, 1-year, and 2-year PM10 mean levels.
Differences in the relationship between DVT risk and PM10 level according to the characteristics of the study subjects are summarized in Table 4. The association between PM10 level and DVT was significantly attenuated in female subjects (P = .02 for the interaction between PM10 level and sex). An increase of 10 μg/m3 in PM10 level was associated with an adjusted OR for DVT of 2.07 (95% CI, 1.50 to 2.84) (P < .001) in men and 1.40 (95% CI, 1.02 to 1.92) (P = .04) in women. No PM10 effect was observed in women taking oral contraceptives or hormone therapy (OR, 0.97; 95% CI, 0.58 to 1.61) (P = .89 for PM10 effect; P = .048 for the interaction between PM10 and hormone use). The other characteristics evaluated, including year of diagnosis, did not significantly modify the association between PM10 exposure and DVT risk (Table 4).
We repeated all the analyses after excluding cases with a recurrent (nonfirst) episode of DVT (n = 110). Risk estimates were very similar to those for the entire study population. Each increase of 10 μg/m3 in PM10 level was associated with an OR of 1.67 (95% CI, 1.27 to 2.22) (P < .001), adjusting for multiple variables. In the subsample of 760 cases with a single episode of DVT, the variations in the association between PM10 level and the risk of DVT due to demographic characteristics, presence of thrombophilia, or use of hormone therapies were similar to those observed in the entire study population.
To evaluate the influence of splines selection in fitting nonliner terms in the logistic models, we repeated all statistical analyses by using natural splines instead of penalized splines. The use of natural splines did not modify the statistical significance of the results, with only small changes in the risk estimates.
We also evaluated the influence of different methods for adjusting for long-term time trends during the study period (supplementary Table 2; available at: http://www.cdldevoto.it/didattic/materiale/Appendix_Archives_online.pdf). As was shown in the subsection “Particle Exposure and Relative Risk of DVT,” ignoring long-term time trends in the analyses would have almost completely obscured the association between PM10 level and DVT risk. However, all of the methods for adjustment for long-term time trends that we evaluated in our sensitivity analysis (fitting dummy variables for each year of the study period, as well as linear terms or penalized splines for index date with degrees of freedom varying between 2 and 8) produced risk estimates indicating a significant association between PM10 level and DVT risk, with only small changes due to different handling of the time trends for most of the methods. However, it is worth noting that using only a linear variable for the long-term trend would have produced a lower OR, likely reflecting less than optimal fitting of the time relationships present in our data.
In this study of DVT cases and healthy controls, exposure to increased concentrations of particulate air pollution in the year before diagnosis was associated with increased DVT risk after controlling for clinical and environmental covariates. Mean level of PM10 before the examination was also correlated with shorter PT in both cases and controls. The DVT risk increase associated with PM10 level was smaller in women and limited to those who were not using oral contraceptives or hormone therapy at the time of diagnosis.
Long-term exposure to particulate air pollution has been associated with increased risk of coronary heart and cerebrovascular disease in multiple investigations conducted in several countries.4 A systemic increase in thrombotic tendency, secondary to the induction of inflammatory mediators produced in the lungs and released in the circulation or to the translocation of particles of smaller diameter from the lungs into the circulation6 has been frequently proposed to account for the cardiac and cerebrovascular effects of particulate air pollution. In contrast, venous thrombosis has received little attention in studies on the cardiovascular outcomes of air pollution. In a time-series analysis from the Netherlands, Hoek et al16 reported an association of short-term exposure to ambient ozone and, to a lesser extent, black smoke and PM10, with increased mortality from embolism and thrombosis, a broad category that included arterial and venous thromboses in various sites. To date, no study has specifically addressed the association between particulate air pollution and DVT. In our population, we estimated an overall 70% increase in DVT risk with each increase of 10 μg/m3 in PM10 level during the year before diagnosis. For comparison, in the Harvard Six Cities Study, the risk of death from cardiopulmonary diseases was 37% higher in the most polluted compared with the least polluted cities.1 In the Women’s Health Initiative Study, an increase of 10 μg/m3 of annual mean concentrations of PM2.5, which is considered a stronger predictor than PM10 level of air pollution effects, was associated with a 24% increase in the risk of cardiovascular events and a 76% increase in the risk of death from cardiovascular disease.2 The estimated increase in risk of death from all cardiovascular causes associated with 10 μg/m3 elevation in long-term PM2.5 level was 19% in the Harvard Six Cities study and 13% in the study by the American Cancer Society.3
In the present study, PM10 exposure did not increase the risk of DVT in women as much as in men. By evaluating additional risk factors, we found that part—if not all—of such risk attenuation was due to the lack of association between PM10 level and the risk of DVT among women using oral contraceptives or hormone therapy. Such hormone therapies are independent risk factors for DVT,10 which is also confirmed in this study by the higher prevalence of oral contraceptive and hormone use in the cases compared with the controls. Use of oral contraceptives and hormone therapy induces changes in coagulation factors, such as increased levels of the procoagulant factors VII, IX, X, XII, and XIII, von Willebrand factor, and fibrinogen and reduced levels of the anticoagulant proteins antithrombin and protein S,13,17,18 that are similar in characteristics and degree to the coagulation changes observed after exposure to air particles.7,8,19- 22 We surmise that prothrombotic mechanisms are already activated in those receiving hormone therapy so that they undergo less or no further induction after air particle exposure.
In our analyses, we evaluated DVT risk in association with the level of PM10 measured during the year before diagnosis. In this study, the use of short-term (hourly or daily) air pollution levels would not have been appropriate because DVT presentation is often subtle and its diagnosis has been shown to lag as long as 4 weeks after the initial DVT symptoms.23 In the present work, we demonstrated that mean PM10 level in the year before the examination was associated with shortened PT, extending our previous observation of an association with shorter exposure time windows.13 Interestingly, while the negative effects of mean PM10 levels on PT were independent of the time-window selected, the 1-year mean PM10 was the only exposure metric significantly associated with shortened PT among the cases. In addition, while in our previous work we could not find any relation between 30-day mean PM10 level and aPTT, in our present study, a nonsignificant (P = .07) association was observed between aPTT shortening and 1-year mean PM10 among the controls. This association, taken together with the similar PT change, suggests that 1-year PM10 exposure may also affect aPTT. Thus, the use of PM10 level in the year before diagnosis appeared to capture a fuller range of prothrombotic effects, while also reducing the risks of confounding by seasonal patterns and ambient temperature. This study has the advantage of being based on a large number of DVT cases and controls recruited using a standardized protocol over a long time span. Cases had objective diagnoses of DVT, and both cases and controls were well characterized for inherited and acquired risk factors for DVT. In the statistical analysis, we used models that included nonlinear regression terms to adjust for long-term time trends and day of the year (thus controlling for confounding from year of the study and seasonal variations), in addition to age, sex, area of residence, education, factor V Leiden, G20210A prothrombin mutation, use of oral contraceptive or hormone therapy, body mass index, and ambient temperature.
Because the healthy controls were selected among nonblood relatives and friends of the DVT cases, they tended to be distributed in the 9 study areas, with proportions that were very similar to those of the DVT cases. This might have generated overmatching in our study, ie, the exposure levels of controls may have been more similar to those of DVT cases than they actually are in the population at risk. Therefore, it is possible that risk estimates were underestimated in our study. A limitation of this study is that we used ambient air pollution estimated at the subjects' address as a surrogate for personal exposure, which may have resulted in measurement error, since most subjects conduct a large part of their daily activities away from their residence. A detailed questionnaire was used to ascertain known risk factors for DVT, but no information was collected concerning daily activities, such as time spent outside or in traffic, that could have refined the assessment of PM10 exposure. In addition, our exposure assessment was done by dividing the Lombardy region into 9 areas for which mean PM10 levels were assigned by averaging measurements from multiple monitors. Although these areas were selected to group together territories with similar population densities and geographical characteristics, thus likely reducing within-area variations of the exposure, we were not able to obtain PM10 level estimates at a smaller scale. However, PM10 levels tend to be spatially homogeneous, and a recent study comparing personal exposures with site monitoring in Boston, Massachusetts, reported that monitor readings and personal exposure are highly correlated.24 In addition, it has been shown that using ambient measures to estimate individual exposure is likely to produce an underestimation of pollution effects25 rather than causing the increased risk of DVT found in our study population.
In conclusion, this study provides evidence in support of an association of exposure to particulate air pollution with enhanced prothrombotic mechanisms and risk of DVT. Given the magnitude of the observed effects and the widespread diffusion of particulate pollutants, our findings introduce a novel and common risk factor into the pathogenesis of DVT and, at the same time, give further substance to the call for tighter standards and continued efforts aimed at reducing the impact of urban air pollutants on human health.
Correspondence: Andrea Baccarelli, MD, PhD, Exposure, Epidemiology, and Risk Program, Harvard School of Public Health, 401 Park Dr, Landmark Center, Ste 415G W, PO Box 15698, Boston, MA 02215 (firstname.lastname@example.org).
Accepted for Publication: December 14, 2007.
Author Contributions:Study concept and design: Baccarelli, Martinelli, Bertazzi, Mannucci, and Schwartz. Acquisition of data: Baccarelli, Martinelli, Zanobetti, and Grillo. Analysis and interpretation of data: Baccarelli, Martinelli, Zanobetti, Grillo, Hou, Bertazzi, and Schwartz. Drafting of the manuscript: Baccarelli, Hou, Mannucci, and Schwartz. Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Martinelli, Zanobetti, Grillo, Bertazzi, and Schwartz. Statistical analysis: Baccarelli, Zanobetti, Grillo, and Schwartz. Obtained funding:Baccarelli, Bertazzi, and Schwartz. Study supervision: Baccarelli, Hou, Bertazzi, and Mannucci.
Financial Disclosure: None reported.
Funding/Support: This work was supported by grants R83241601 and R827353 from the Environmental Protection Agency Particulate Matter Center; grants ES0002 and ES015172-01 and grant PO1 ES009825 from the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences; grant 2004-2006/97-C from the MIUR (Ministero dell'Istruzione, dell'Università e della Ricerca) Internationalization Program; and grants UniMi 8614/2006 and UniMi 9167/2007 from theCARIPLO (Cassa di Risparmio delle Provincie Lombarde) Foundation and Lombardy region.
Additional Contributions: Guido Lanzani, PhD, Nadia Carfagno, BSPH, and Anna Cazzullo, MS, ARPA Lombardia, provided support in air-monitoring data handling; and Steve Melly, MS, Harvard School of Public Health, assisted in the creation of geographic maps.
This article was corrected for typographical errors on 5/12/2008.