The shuttle vector containing the expression cassette (Rous sarcoma virus/complementary DNA/polyadenylation+[RSV/cDNA/pA+]) with the foreign gene of interest is cotransfected with the plasmid containing the adenoviral genome (A). The vector containing the adenovirus (Adeno) genome is missing the packaging sequence (ψ) and cannot produce virus. The shuttle vector also cannot replicate and produce virus because it is missing a large piece of the adenoviral genome. For virus production, the shuttle vector containing the packaging sequence and the expression cassette must recombine with the adenovirus genome (B). This recombination occurs at a region of DNA that is similar to both vectors (X) and is downstream from the expression cassette. Successful recombinations contain the genetic elements from both vectors that will allow virus production (rescue). Once rescued, the recombinant virus can replicate in human embryonic kidney 293 cells. Replicating virus is easily identified by the lysis of cells in tissue culture. After growth and plaques purification, large quantities of recombinant adenovirus can be grown and purified over a cesium chloride density gradient (C). After dialysis, replication-defective adenovirus can be used for in vitro or in vivo transfections. For example, clinical trials of quality-assured adenovirus encoding the HSV-tk gene are currently being examined after injection into tumors in humans (D).
Smith GM. Adenovirus-Mediated Gene Transfer to Treat Neurologic Disease. Arch Neurol. 1998;55(8):1061-1064. doi:10.1001/archneur.55.8.1061
Within the last 10 years the development of tools used to manipulate DNA have shown promise in the generation of a new form of therapeutic intervention known as gene therapy. Gene therapy involves the introduction of genetic material into cells to replace or supplement defective genes or to induce the expression of a novel gene to help alleviate a disease. These manipulations can be done in cells either outside the body and transplanted back in (ex vivo gene therapy) or directly within a specific target organ (in vivo gene therapy). To target and transfer DNA or RNA to cells a variety of techniques have been developed, including the use of replication-defective viruses, lipid bilayers that encapsulate DNA (liposomes), and DNA-coated gold particles that are ballistically shot into cells (gene gun). Most of these topics will be discussed in articles to follow in this series.
This article describes the use of replication-defective adenoviruses as both a potential clinical as well as basic tool for transferring DNA into cells of the nervous system. Adenoviruses are intermediate-sized, nonenveloped viruses containing a linear double-stranded DNA of approximately 36000 base pair.1 The virus is relatively easy to generate, highly stable, and the viral genome does not undergo rearrangement at a high rate, so inserted foreign genes are generally maintained without change through successive rounds of replication.1
Adenoviruses and other viruses are highly efficient at transferring their DNA into a target cell. This process is mediated through endocytosis after adenovirus binds to a specific cell surface receptor. Once inside the cell, the virus forms a pore in the endosome and releases the DNA, which translocates to the nucleus. In wild-type adenovirus this initiates activation of the viral genome and replication of adenovirus leading to the lysis of the cell. The adenoviruses used for gene therapy, however, are rendered replication defective by removal of the early 1 (E1) region that is vital for transformation and viral transcription. Therefore, adenovirus with E1 deletions replicates only in host cells engineered to contain this region of the adenoviral genome. One such cell line, human embryonic kidney 293 cells, were transformed into an immortal line using the adenoviral E1 region. Deleting the genetic information from the adenoviral genome within this and other regions provides space within the virus to accompany more than 10 kilobases of foreign genetic material.
To express RNA and protein from the foreign complementary DNA transferred into a cell, several key elements must be designed into the vector to produce an expression cassette. These include a promoter, an intron, and a polyadenylation signal sequence. The promoter is a short stretch of DNA in front of the protein-coding region that the RNA polymerase binds to for synthesis of messenger RNA. When the RNA polymerase reaches a start site it begins to transcribe the messenger RNA. This continues until the polymerase reaches a stop signal located on the far side of the coding region within the polyadenylation signal sequence. At the stop site, the polymerase releases from the DNA and the messenger RNA is further processed with the establishment of a polyadenosine tail.
There are several different types of promoters, and promoter selection is important in directing the conditions of expression within selective cell types. Constitutive promoters are those that induce gene expression in most cells continually over a long period. These promoters have either been isolated from viruses, such as the cytomegalovirus promoter or the Rous sarcoma virus long terminal repeat promoter, or represent a gene that is transcribed in numerous tissues, such as B-actin. A second type of promoter, the inducible promoters, are those in which expression can be turned on and off with the application of a specific drug. One such inducible promoter uses the modified tetracycline repressor to regulate gene expression in the presence or absence of tetracycline. A third type of promoter is the tissue-specific promoter that induces gene expression within specific cell population. To restrict expression to either astrocytes or neurons, the glial fibrillary acidic protein promoter (astrocytes) or the neuron-specific enolase promoter (neurons) are commonly used.
To generate adenoviruses a competent cell line (human embryonic kidney 293) is cotransfected with an adenoviral shuttle vector containing the expression cassette as described above and a second vector containing the adenoviral genome (Figure 1). The shuttle vector contains a piece of adenovirus sequences that contains the viral packaging sequence, but is missing the E1 region. Within the E1 deletion is the expression cassette. The second vector is designed to contain all the necessary adenoviral genes to produce virus, but is missing essential genes for packaging into virions and reproducing itself. Only when successful recombination causes the transfer of DNA from the shuttle vector (including the packaging sequence and the expression cassette) to the second vector will virus be rescued and produced (Figure 1). Adenoviruses generated by this process are replication defective and will only propagate in specific cell lines expressing the adenoviral E1 region and not in normal cells lacking this region. The exact mechanism leading to DNA recombination is not known and isolating successful recombinants is one of the biggest challenges associated with the generation of adenovirus. To maximize the potential for successful recombination, usually equal molar concentrations of the 2 vectors are cotransfected into cells using the liposome or some other efficient transfection protocol.
Successful recombination produces virions that induce lysis of human embryonic kidney 293 cells. This cytopathic effect can be visually monitored as a small plaque that progressively gets larger over time. Once all the cells in individual wells lyse, the supernatant is examined for successful viral recombinants and for contaminating adenovirus that contains the E1 region by polymerase chain reaction.2 Viruses containing DNA inserts of interest with no or little wild-type contamination are plaque purified. Finally, recombinant adenovirus is purified, separated from cell debris, and concentrated by centrifugation over cesium chloride gradients.1
Adenovirus may prove beneficial in the treatment of several central nervous system (CNS) disorders such as CNS tumors, neurodegenerative diseases, and autosomal recessive disorders. The furthest along in clinical trials are adenoviruses used to destroy CNS tumors. Currently several approaches are being explored. One approach uses adenovirus that encodes a suicide gene, such as herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase gene (HSV-tk).3 Cells transfected with HSV-tk convert noncytotoxic nucleoside analogs, such as ganciclovir, into phosphorylated compounds that act to terminate DNA synthesis in dividing cells. These compounds will therefore destroy tumor cells but not nondividing glia and neurons. A secondary benefit to this approach is that phosphorylated nucleosides can diffuse away from the dying cells or be transferred to adjacent cells through gap junctions and cause a "bystander effect" to destroy adjacent tumor cells that are not transduced with HSV-tk. Effectiveness of this treatment in animal models of spinal cord tumors demonstrated that HSV-tk eliminated the tumor and dramatically increased survival when compared with nontreated controls.4
Another approach uses mutated adenovirus with no foreign DNA insert to directly destroy tumor cells by replication-dependent cytolysis.5 For adenovirus to replicate it must be able to block the function of the cell-cycle arrest protein p53. Wild-type adenovirus produces a 55-kd protein that binds and inhibits the function of p53. Adenovirus that is missing this 55-kd protein cannot replicate in normal cells, but can replicate in cells deficient for p53. More than 50% of all human tumors produce an inactive mutant form of p53 and allow replication of the 55-kd deficient adenovirus. Studies show that this method is effective in killing many types of tumors and significantly increased animal survival in mouse-human xenografts of p53-defective tumors.
Another potential clinical application for recombinant adenovirus is the treatment of some neurodegenerative disorders. Neurotrophins could potentially contribute to the treatment of many neural degenerative diseases; however, systemic application of these factors has proved problematic.
An alternative strategy would be limited expression of specific neurotrophins to the neurons and discrete locations needed. In animal models for degenerative disorders, such as Parkinson disease and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, adenovirus encoding for neurotrophins has proved successful in increasing neuronal survival after application to specific cell populations. For a model of Parkinson disease in animals, 6-hydroxydopamine is injected into the striatum to destroy the tyrosine hydroxylase–containing neurons in the substantia nigra. Preinjection of recombinant adenovirus encoding glial cell line–derived neurotrophic factor into the striatum doubled the number of surviving dopaminergic neurons after treatment with 6-hydroxydopamine and resulted in minimal behavior dysfunction when compared with control animals.6
Numerous studies for animal models of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis have demonstrated that application of neurotrophins can reduce morbidity and mortality by increasing motor neuron survival and muscle tone. In 1 such study,7 adenovirus encoding neurotrophin-3 was injected into the muscle of mice with the genetic disorder progressive motor neuronopathy. Normally these mice develop neurogenic atrophy and become paralyzed and die within 6 to 7 weeks of age. The mice with progressive motor neuronopathy treated with neurotrophin-3 adenovirus, however, showed an increased number of motor axons, improved neuromuscular function, and a 50% increase in life span when compared with control mice with progressive motor neuronopathy.
Although adenovirus has the potential to be a useful vector for the treatment of many CNS disorders, initial clinical use may be limited to treatments that require relatively short-term expression, such as treatment of CNS malignancies. This problem is primarily due to the lack of persistent transgene expression after adenoviral transfection. In most experimental paradigms, adenovirus persistence rarely extends more than several months. This might be due to several factors such as promoter shutdown, elimination of the adenovirus DNA from the host cell since the virus does not integrate, or reduced expression due to an immune response. However, improvements in the design and construction of adenoviral vectors are beginning to greatly increase the persistence of transgene expression.
The relative ease for generating recombinant adenovirus and the broad spectrum of CNS cells transduced by this virus has greatly expanded its application in basic neuroscience research. Recombinant adenovirus can be used to transfer genetic material into neurons, astrocytes, oligodendrocytes, and Schwann cells both in vitro and in vivo. This allows for the examination of protein function from a desired gene in a variety of experimental paradigms. For example, neurons transduced with adenovirus encoding green fluorescent protein to identify transfected cells displayed electrophysiologic properties statistically similar to normal nontransfected neurons.8 In addition, multiple genes can be expressed so that a marker protein such as green fluorescent protein can be coexpressed with a second gene. The coexpression of green fluorescent protein and the serotonin type III receptor allowed easy and consistent identification of live transduced neurons for patch-clamping determination of receptor expression and function.8 The use of similar recombinant viruses could be used in hippocampal slice preparations to help dissect the molecular mechanisms involved in synaptic plasticity and function.
Animal research is also showing promise for the use of recombinant adenovirus in numerous neurologic disorders such as those associated with inherited diseases, neurodegenerative diseases, ischemia, and CNS wound repair and regeneration, to name a few (for review see Davidson and Bohn9). In many inherited diseases, the disorder is caused by the mutation of a single gene that renders the gene product ineffectual. The transfer of a normal gene into the defected cells could replace the defective gene product with a fully functional one to treat the disease. One such example is the reversal of diabetes insipidus in the Brattleboro rat.10 Rare forms of diabetes insipidus in humans are caused by a mutation in the arginine vasopressin gene. Injections of adenovirus encoding a correct version of arginine vasopressin into the hypothalamus reduced water intake and urine volume in treated rats for up to 4 months. This study demonstrates that gene replacement therapy using adenovirus can correct functional deficits associated with autosomal recessive single-gene disorders within the CNS.
In conclusion, recombinant adenovirus is adaptable to many experimental paradigms in which DNA transfer to cells of the nervous system is required. This virus will efficiently transfect both dividing and nondividing cells and induce high expression of the transgene for at least several weeks. The technology for generating replication-defective adenovirus is also readily available either from other researchers or from commercial sources. For these and other reasons, adenovirus is one of the most widely used viral systems for transferring genetic material in basic neuroscience research. Currently, the 2 main problems associated with the use of adenovirus are the lack of long-term transgene persistence and the elicitation of an immune response by the initial injection bolus. Remedies to these problems, however, are presently under way by generating third-generation viruses with more deletions or "gutless" viruses that lack more than 95% of the adenoviral genomic DNA. Basic understanding of the receptors and mechanisms by which adenovirus binds to cells and is internalized is also providing clues to aid in the efficient targeting of adenovirus to more specific cell populations. In the future, adenovirus and other gene transfer systems will greatly augment our ability to cure diseases by allowing clinicians to transfer specific genes to increase neuronal survival, help repair traumatic brain injury, destroy tumors, or replace defective genes.
Accepted for publication April 9, 1998.
Reprints: George M. Smith, PhD, Pain Management Research, Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Management, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, 5323 Harry Hines Blvd, Dallas, TX 75235-9068.