Main pathways of essential fatty acid elongation.10
The Utah kindred K4175 pedigree with phenotypic grades. Diagonal lines indicate deceased family members. All of the living family members shown here, not including spouses, have been genotyped. Squares indicate males; circles, females; open symbols, no ELOVL4 deletion; solid symbols, positive for ELOVL4 deletion; and numerals 1, 2, and 3, phenotypic grade of 1, 2, and 3, respectively (see Table 1 for definition of phenotypic grades). The living family members (excluding spouses) with no ELOVL4 deletion served as family controls in the lipid studies.
Fundus photographs of selected family members with phenotypic grades (Table 1 and Figure 2), including grade 1 in the right eye of subject III:13 (A), grade 1 in the left eye of subject III:5 (B), grade 2 in the right eye of subject III:11 (C), grade 2 in the left eye of subject III:9 (D), grade 3 in the right eye of subject IV:11 (E), and grade 3 in the left eye of subject III:3 (F).
Comparison of phenotypes in family controls and subjects with an ELOVL4 mutation with mean ± SD percentage of eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) in red blood cell membranes, with a significant inverse relationship between phenotype and EPA percentage in subjects with an ELOVL4 mutation (r = −0.55; P = .02) (A), mean ± SD percentage of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) in red blood cell membranes, with a significant inverse relationship between phenotype and DHA percentage in subjects with an ELOVL4 mutation (r = −0.54; P = .04) (B), mean ± SD percentage of EPA in adipose tissue, with a significant inverse relationship between phenotype and EPA percentage in subjects with an ELOVL4 mutation (r = −0.48; P = .04) (C), and mean ± SD percentage of DHA in adipose tissue, with no significant relationship between phenotype and DHA percentage in subjects with an ELOVL4 mutation (r = −0.33; P>.05) (D). See Table 1 for definition of phenotypic grades.
Hubbard AF, Askew EW, Singh N, Leppert M, Bernstein PS. Association of Adipose and Red Blood Cell Lipids With Severity of Dominant Stargardt Macular Dystrophy (STGD3) Secondary to an ELOVL4 Mutation. Arch Ophthalmol. 2006;124(2):257-263. doi:10.1001/archopht.124.2.257
JANEY L.WIGGSMD, PhDAuthor Affiliations: Departments of Foods and Nutrition (Ms Hubbard and Dr Askew), Human Genetics (Drs Singh and Leppert), and Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences (Dr Bernstein), University of Utah, Salt Lake City.
To determine whether adipose and red blood cell membrane lipids, particularly long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids such as docosahexaenoic acid and eicosapentaenoic acid, are significantly correlated with phenotype in a family with autosomal dominant Stargardt macular dystrophy (gene locus STGD3). A mutation in the ELOVL4 gene is responsible for the macular dystrophy in this family, and its disease-causing mechanism may be its possible involvement in fatty acid elongation in the retina.
The subjects in this study included 18 adult family members known to have a 2–base pair deletion in the ELOVL4 gene. Control subjects included 26 family members without the mutation. Each subject received a complete eye examination including fundus photographs, the results of which were used to grade the severity of macular dystrophy on a 3-tier scale. Red blood cell membrane and adipose tissue lipids were analyzed as an indication of short-term and long-term dietary fatty acid intake.
When adipose lipids were analyzed, there was a significant inverse relationship between phenotypic severity and the level of eicosapentaenoic acid (r = −0.54; P = .04). When red blood cell lipids were analyzed, there were significant inverse relationships between phenotypic severity and levels of eicosapentaenoic acid (r = −0.55; P = .02) and docosahexaenoic acid (r = −0.48; P = .04).
These results indicate that the phenotypic diversity in this family may be related to differences in dietary fat intake as reflected by adipose and red blood cell lipids.
This study demonstrates that dietary factors can influence the severity of an inherited human macular dystrophy.
Stargardt macular dystrophies are early-onset disorders characterized by macular atrophy and subretinal flecks that lead to central visual loss, typically in the first or second decade of life.1,2 Autosomal recessive Stargardt macular dystrophy (gene locus STGD1) (Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man [OMIM] 248200) is the most common form; it is due to homozygous or compound heterozygous mutations in the ABCA4 gene (also known as ABCR), whose protein product is involved in the transport of retinoids from the rod outer segments.1,3 Autosomal dominant Stargardt macular dystrophy (gene locus STGD3) (OMIM 600110) is much rarer than autosomal recessive Stargardt macular dystrophy.2 In past years, a number of STGD3 pedigrees linked to chromosome 6q14 had been reported, and in 2001, a 5–base pair (bp) deletion in the ELOVL4 gene was described to be causative for STGD3.4 This 5-bp deletion causes a frameshift and premature termination of the ELOVL4 gene's protein product.4 All of the previously described families with STGD3 shared this same mutation, and further analysis revealed that all of these families could be traced to a common ancestor.5 Subsequently, we identified a different mutation in ELOVL4 in an unrelated large Utah family (kindred K4175) with STGD3.6 This mutation was in the same location as the 5-bp deletion in exon 6 of the ELOVL4 gene, but there are 2 1-bp deletions 4 nucleotides apart that are predicted to truncate the protein by 51 amino acids.6
The ELOVL4 gene codes for a protein that is highly homologous to proteins found in yeast that are involved in the elongation of fatty acids.4 The ELOVL4 gene, short for “elongation of very long-chain fatty acids,” is therefore named for the proposed function of its protein product. The ELOVL4 gene is expressed abundantly in the photoreceptor cells of the retina and, to a lesser extent, in the brain, lens, testis, and skin.7 Photoreceptor outer segment membranes are composed of approximately 33% docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), a very long-chain fatty acid.8 Docosahexaenoic acid constitutes 80% of the polyunsaturated fatty acids found there.8 The retina as a whole has been found to contain 16% to 22% DHA, making DHA more abundant than any other single fatty acid.9
Polyunsaturated ω-3 and ω-6 fatty acids are termed essential fatty acids because they must be obtained from dietary sources. Docosahexaenoic acid can be obtained as preformed dietary DHA or elongated in the body from dietary α-linolenic acid (ALA) or other intermediates in the ω-3 biosynthetic pathway (Figure 1).10 In the United States, 88% to 90% of preformed dietary DHA comes from fish intake.11 The recommended intake for DHA and other very long-chain polyunsaturated ω-3 fatty acids, such as eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA), is 0.65 g/d, but current intake in the United States is well below this value at an average of 0.25 g/d.11 In an individual with this average intake, ALA or other intermediates must be elongated to supply DHA to the retina. However, current intakes of ALA in the United States are also well below recommended levels.11
If the ELOVL4 protein product assists in fatty acid elongation, then individuals with a mutation in this gene consuming an intake of DHA average for American persons would have a high risk of developing a local deficiency of DHA in the retina, possibly exacerbating the macular disorders associated with STGD3. However, if individuals with an ELOVL4 mutation were consuming an adequate supply of preformed dietary DHA or one of its immediate precursors, it could be directly used in the retina, bypassing the step in fatty acid elongation mediated by the ELOVL4 gene product. Recently, there was a case report12 of improvement of visual function in response to DHA supplementation in a patient with an ELOVL4 mutation.
A relative deficiency of DHA has been implicated in X-linked retinitis pigmentosa. A placebo-controlled interventional trial has recently been completed,13 but no previous studies to our knowledge have investigated the relationship between dietary fats and the severity of any inherited macular dystrophies. On the other hand, several studies14- 19 have investigated the relationship between dietary fats and the incidence or severity of age-related macular degeneration. Of these studies, a few14- 16,18 have found significant inverse relationships between DHA or fish consumption and the incidence or severity of age-related macular degeneration.
These previous age-related macular degeneration studies generally relied solely on a food frequency questionnaire (FFQ) to indicate individuals' dietary fat intakes. An FFQ assesses nutrient intakes by determining how frequently a person consumes certain foods known to be the major sources of particular nutrients.20 The main limitations of FFQs are that they are time-consuming to administer and that they rely solely on subject recall to describe their typical long-term diet. Studies based on FFQs usually require rather large populations on the order of hundreds or even thousands of subjects to reduce the inherent individual variability of this subjective measure. Thus, there has been considerable interest in the development of surrogate objective biomarkers that capture information on the long-term intake of nutrients but exhibit less variability. In the case of dietary fat intake, 2 techniques have proven to be most useful—red blood cell membrane analysis and fat biopsy analysis. Both tests are easily and rapidly performed on subjects, and they have been successfully cross-validated against FFQs. Red blood cell membrane fatty acids appear to be good indicators of dietary intake for saturated and unsaturated fatty acids over the past 6 to 8 weeks.21- 24 Adipose tissue aspirates are indicative of the habitual diet over the last 2 to 3 years, especially with regard to dietary intake of essential polyunsaturated fatty acids such as ω-3 and ω-6 fatty acids.25- 30
Given the proposed involvement of the ELOVL4 gene in fatty acid elongation, individuals with an ELOVL4 mutation who consume an adequate supply of preformed dietary DHA or an appropriate precursor may have a less severe form of macular dystrophy. In this study, we have examined all of the available adult members of Utah kindred K4175, and we have assessed dietary fat intake by FFQ as well as lipid analyses of red blood cell membranes and fat biopsies to determine whether dietary fat intake can modify the severity of the macular dystrophy phenotype in those individuals with an ELOVL4 mutation. Understanding the role of diet in a genetically defined macular dystrophy may also provide clues as to the etiology and treatment of more common macular disorders such as age-related macular degeneration.
The subjects in this study included 44 genetically related adult family members of Utah kindred K4175 identified at the Moran Eye Center, University of Utah, Salt Lake City. This family has been found to have autosomal dominant Stargardt macular dystrophy caused by a mutation of 2 noncontiguous 1-bp deletions in the ELOVL4 gene.6 All of the subjects read and signed a consent form that was approved by the institutional review board and complied with the Declaration of Helsinki.
Blood collected from the 44 family members was genotyped using the method described by Bernstein et al.6 The ELOVL4 variants were identified using denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography analysis and direct sequencing at the Department of Human Genetics, University of Utah. The subjects received a complete eye examination that included best-corrected visual acuity, dilated fundus examination, and fundus photography.
Two milliliters of blood was drawn from an antecubital vein in the arm to examine red blood cell fatty acids and to estimate fatty acid intake over the past 6 to 8 weeks.24 An adipose sample was collected from a site on the buttocks to assess dietary fat intake over the past 2 to 3 years according to the method by Beynen and Katan.25 Adipose tissue samples were collected from only 35 of the 44 family members because some subjects lived out of state and it is not a commonly performed procedure. The packed red blood cells and adipose tissue samples were transferred to freezing vials and frozen at −80°C until they were shipped on dry ice to the Kennedy Krieger Institute, Baltimore, Md, for analysis.
At the Kennedy Krieger Institute, the red blood cell and adipose tissue samples were analyzed according to the method by Lagerstedt et al31 using capillary gas chromatography with electron-capture negative-ion mass spectrometry. This method was developed to quantify long-chain fatty acids and can identify 14 saturated and 25 unsaturated fatty acids. These fatty acids range from C8 to C26, including transunsaturated and branched-chain fatty acids. Individual lipids were expressed as a percentage of the total lipids analyzed. Since ELOVL4 has very restricted expression in the body—in the retina, lens, brain, testis, and skin7—the use of red blood cell membrane and adipose tissue fatty acids as biomarkers of long-term fat intake should be valid even in the presence of this mutation.
Family members also completed a semiquantitative FFQ to assess dietary fat intake.32 This questionnaire has been extensively validated against diet records and adipose tissue aspirates.32 An additional self-administered questionnaire to identify potential confounding demographic variables was also completed by the family members. This questionnaire consisted of questions about past and present cigarette use, dietary supplements not indicated on the FFQ (including any type of essential fatty acids or fish oil), eye color, height, and weight.
The 18 family members who were positive for the ELOVL4 deletion were divided into 3 phenotypic grades based on the severity of their maculopathy (Table 1). Initially, the grades were assigned by one of us (P.S.B.) who had examined most of the subjects and who was aware of the clinical characteristics of all of the subjects. The grades were then confirmed in a masked manner by 3 other retina specialists (Kang Zhang, MD, PhD, Michael Teske, MD, and Albert Vitale, MD) at the Moran Eye Center who were given photographs but no clinical history. There was unanimous agreement between all 4 of the graders for 13 subjects. In 2 cases, the majority of the masked graders agreed with the initial grader, and the initial grades were left unchanged (subjects II:10 and III:11). In 1 case, the masked graders unanimously disagreed with the initial grader, and the grade for that subject was modified to agree with their assessment (subject IV:14). In 1 case, 2 of the 3 masked graders disagreed with the assessment by the initial grader, but the original grade for this subject was left unchanged (subject III:5). One subject had no photographs, and she was graded based on the clinical examination alone (subject IV:24). To minimize the possibility of bias, all of the phenotypic grades were finalized prior to the availability of any of the lipid analysis data.
Spearman rank correlation was used to assess the correlation between phenotype and dietary intake of fatty acids or other nutrients as measured by red blood cell samples, adipose tissue samples, or the FFQ. If necessary, the Kruskal-Wallis test was then used to examine equality of distributions among the phenotypes for the various nutrients. To analyze the difference in fatty acid levels in red blood cell membranes and adipose tissue between the subjects with the ELOVL4 deletion and a population without the deletion, the Wilcoxon rank sum test for unpaired data was used. Statistical significance was set at P<.05. Statistical analyses were conducted using Stata version 8 software (Stata Corp, College Station, Tex).
Of the 44 enrolled adult family members of Utah kindred K4175, 18 were found to carry the family's truncating deletion in ELOVL4 (Figure 2). Using the grading scheme outlined in Table 1, 8 of these subjects were assigned a moderate phenotypic grade of 2, and 4 of these subjects were assigned a severe phenotypic grade of 3 (Table 2). The remaining 6 family members with an ELOVL4 deletion had minimal to no symptoms; however, fundus photographs and clinical examinations revealed that most but not all of these subjects had at least some macular changes, and they were all assigned phenotypic grades of 1.
Among the 12 family members who had been clinically diagnosed with autosomal dominant Stargardt macular dystrophy, the ages at onset varied from 6 to 63 years, but onset most commonly occurred in the second decade of life. Their fundus photographs varied, showing macular atrophy and flecks to butterfly-pattern dystrophy to bull’s-eye maculopathy (Figure 3). Their visual acuities also differed, with 6 of the family members considered legally blind but others able to drive and perform job functions. Many of these affected family members have been followed up for more than 6 years at the Moran Eye Center, and only rarely has any clinical progression been detected.
Initially, we compared the red blood cell membrane and adipose tissue EPA and DHA levels of the 18 family members with ELOVL4 mutations vs the 26 family controls to determine whether there were obvious deficiencies in systemic levels of long-chain ω-3 fatty acids similar to those seen in patients with X-linked retinitis pigmentosa.13Table 3 shows that this is clearly not the case. In fact, in all of the cases, the average levels of DHA and EPA were higher in the subjects with ELOVL4 deletions. Interestingly, the family as a whole had much lower average red blood cell EPA and DHA levels relative to the Kennedy Krieger Institute laboratory control values, which was consistent with the very low median fish intakes of 1 to 3 servings of fish per month that were noted in the FFQs.
The somewhat higher levels of EPA and DHA in the ELOVL4 deletion group vs the family controls likely reflect different average dietary fat intakes. Since Utah kindred K4175 as a whole has a milder phenotype than other described families with the ELOVL4 mutation,5,6 we hypothesized that some of the family members of Utah kindred K4175 with the mutation may be practicing a particularly healthy, protective lifestyle with a diet higher in EPA and/or DHA intake. To investigate this further, we explored whether biomarkers of long-term fat intake correlated with phenotypic severity in the 18 subjects with ELOVL4 deletions. When red blood cell lipids were analyzed, significant inverse relationships were found between the phenotype and levels of EPA (r = −0.55; P = .02) and DHA (r = −0.48; P = .04), ie, as the levels of EPA and DHA increased, phenotypic severity decreased (Figure 4 and Table 4). When adipose tissue lipids were analyzed, data were available for only 14 of the 18 subjects, causing a substantial imbalance between the 3 phenotypic groups. Despite this imbalance, a significant inverse relationship was found between the phenotype and the level of EPA (r = −0.54; P = .04), although not between the phenotype and the level of DHA (r = −0.33; P>.05). In all of the cases, the most severe phenotype (grade 3) had the lowest average EPA and DHA levels, although these levels would be considered to be within the normal range as defined by the family controls. There was also a marginally significant positive relationship between the phenotype and the ratio of arachidonic acid to DHA in red blood cells (r = 0.46; P = .05), ie, as the ratio of arachidonic acid to DHA increased, phenotypic severity increased. There were no significant correlations between the phenotype and total saturated fatty acids, total monounsaturated fatty acids, total transunsaturated fatty acids, total ω-6 fatty acids, total ω-3 fatty acids, linoleic acid, arachidonic acid, ALA, or the ratio of total ω-6 to ω-3 fatty acids (all P>.05) as measured by red blood cell samples or adipose tissue samples (Table 4).
There were no significant correlations between the phenotype of the 18 family members with ELOVL4 mutations and the intake of individual fatty acids, total calories, total animal fat, total vegetable fat, total fat, total polyunsaturated fat, cholesterol, lutein and zeaxanthin combined, zinc, vitamin C, vitamin E, servings of tuna per month, or servings of dark-meat fish per month (all P>.05) as measured by the FFQ. None of the subjects reported receiving any type of essential fatty acid or fish oil supplement. As discussed in the introduction, the lack of significance of FFQ data is not surprising because FFQ analysis is generally better suited for the study of much larger populations.
The ages of the 18 subjects with ELOVL4 mutations ranged from 21 to 71 years, with the average age being 38 years, which was well older than the median age at onset of 13 years in this family.6 Ten (55%) of the subjects were female; 8 (45%) of the subjects were male. The majority of the subjects (11 subjects [61%]) had a desirable body mass index of less than 25, with 7 (39%) considered overweight according to the Quetelet index for body mass.20 There were no significant relationships found between the phenotype and the demographic variables of age, age at onset, sex, or body mass index (all P>.05) (Table 2).
All of the subjects had light-colored eyes. Only 1 subject reported being a current cigarette smoker, and 2 reported smoking in the past. Only 1 family member consumed any alcohol (2-4 glasses of beer per week). No statistical tests were conducted using these variables owing to the severe imbalances between categories.
The results described here indicate that the phenotypic diversity in this family with STGD3 is likely to be related to differences in dietary fatty acid intake, particularly intake of EPA and DHA, as reflected by adipose tissue and red blood cell membrane lipids. Interestingly, this result appears to be driven by unusually high DHA and EPA levels in the family members with mild and moderate phenotypes (grades 1 and 2) relative to family controls, whereas family members with the severe phenotype (grade 3) have average EPA and DHA levels that would be considered to be within the family's normal range. This is in contrast to the observation in X-linked retinitis pigmentosa where family members who are severely affected generally have very low red blood cell membrane DHA levels.13
The significant inverse relationship that was found between the phenotype and the red blood cell membrane DHA level supports the hypothesis that individuals with adequate DHA intake may effectively bypass the defective ELOVL4 gene and avoid severe maculopathy. A similar inverse trend between the adipose DHA level and phenotypic severity was noted, but it did not reach statistical significance. In the biosynthesis of DHA, there are multiple metabolic steps that occur between ALA and DHA. The fact that higher levels of red blood cell membrane and adipose tissue EPA but not ALA were significantly correlated with a less severe phenotype implies that EPA but not ALA can still be elongated to supply DHA to the retina in patients with ELOVL4 mutations. The exact function of ELOVL4 in retinal long-chain fatty acid biosynthesis is still unknown, but our results suggest that it is likely to be involved prior to EPA in the metabolic pathway shown in Figure 2.
This study indicates that phenotypic expression of a genetically defined macular dystrophy can be influenced by a dietary factor. Although this family was relatively large, this study would benefit from extension to even more individuals with ELOVL4 mutations, namely the very large, extended family with a 5-bp deletion in the ELOVL4 gene,5 to show that DHA and EPA are protective against STGD3 in an even more convincing manner. Prospective studies using DHA and/or EPA supplements in patients with an ELOVL4 mutation should also be considered a biochemically rational intervention against this disorder.
Correspondence: Paul S. Bernstein, MD, PhD, Moran Eye Center, University of Utah, 50 N Medical Dr, Salt Lake City, UT 84132 (email@example.com).
Submitted for Publication: October 1, 2004; final revision received December 29, 2004; accepted January 3, 2005.
Financial Disclosure: None.
Funding/Support: This study was supported by a center grant from the Foundation Fighting Blindness, Owings Mills, Md, and by a departmental grant from Research to Prevent Blindness, Inc, New York, NY. Dr Bernstein is a Sybil B. Harrington Research to Prevent Blindness scholar in macular degeneration research.
Previous Presentation: Presented in part at the annual meeting of the Macula Society; February 26, 2004; Las Vegas, Nev; and the annual meeting of the Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology; April 26, 2004; Fort Lauderdale, Fla.
Acknowledgment: We greatly appreciate the assistance of Kang Zhang, MD, PhD, Michael Teske, MD, and Albert Vitale, MD (fundus photograph grading) and of Clint Thompson, PhD (statistical analyses). Barry Fallesen, OD, facilitated the eye examinations of the Northern California branch of the family.