Mountaineers in group 1 during their ascent to camp 2, at 6265 m.
Two different ascent profiles.
Central corneal thickness and oxygen saturation values in a group of healthy mountaineers. A, Mean central corneal thickness values, including significant differences, are shown in both groups (N = 23). B, Mean central corneal thickness measurements in healthy climbers (N = 23) and climbers who underwent laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) (n = 1) and who wore contact lenses (n = 3). C, Mean oxygen saturation measurements of the 23 healthy climbers. During ascent, oxygen saturation decreased significantly at each altitude in both groups, except for the climb from camp 1 (5533 m) to camp 2 (6265 m) in group 2. On descent, measurements in group 1 at base camp 2 (4497 m) compared with those at base camp 1 did not differ significantly. D, The negative correlation between central corneal thickness and oxygen saturation measurements is shown in a scatter plot. Error bars denote 95% confidence intervals; NS, not significant; *significant.
Bosch MM, Barthelmes D, Merz TM, Knecht PB, Truffer F, Bloch KE, Thiel MA, Petrig BL, Turk AJ, Schoch OD, Hefti U, Landau K. New Insights Into Changes in Corneal Thickness in Healthy Mountaineers During a Very-High-Altitude Climb to Mount Muztagh Ata. Arch Ophthalmol. 2010;128(2):184-189. doi:10.1001/archophthalmol.2009.385
To investigate the effect of very high altitude and different ascent profiles on central corneal thickness (CCT).
Twenty-eight healthy mountaineers were randomly assigned to 2 different ascent profiles during a medical research expedition to Mount Muztagh Ata (7546 m) in western China. Group 1 was allotted a shorter acclimatization time prior to ascent to 6265 m. The main outcome measure was CCT. Secondary outcome measures were oxygen saturation (SpO2) and symptom assessments of acute mountain sickness (cerebral acute mountain sickness score). Examinations were performed at 490, 4497, 5533, and 6265 m.
Central corneal thickness increased in both groups with increasing altitude and decreased after descent. In group 1 (with the shorter acclimatization), mean CCT increased from 537 to 572 μm. Mean CCT in group 2 increased from 534 to 563 μm (P = .048). The amount of decrease in SpO2 paralleled the increase in CCT. There was no significant decrease in visual acuity. There was a significant correlation between CCT and cerebral acute mountain sickness score when controlled for SpO2 and age.
Corneal swelling during high-altitude climbs is promoted by low SpO2. Systemic delivery of oxygen to the anterior chamber seems to play a greater role in corneal oxygenation than previously thought. Adhering to a slower ascent profile results in less corneal edema. Visual acuity in healthy corneas is not adversely affected by edema at altitudes of up to 6300 m. Individuals with more acute mountain sickness–related symptoms had thicker corneas, possibly due to their higher overall susceptibility to hypoxia.
High-altitude mountaineering is a popular recreational sport among healthy lowlanders. As a consequence of the exposure to hypobaric atmospheric conditions with a consecutive decrease in oxygen saturation (SpO2), high-altitude climbing may lead to acute mountain sickness (AMS) and the rare but potentially fatal high-altitude cerebral edema.1 Besides AMS, corneal changes during high-altitude climbs may also be a dangerous hazard owing to a potential significant decrease in visual acuity. The often-quoted experience of Dr Beck Weathers, a Mount Everest climber who had undergone radial keratotomy prior to ascent and incurred severe vision loss during the climb, is such an example.2
To date, only a few publications have addressed changes in normal unoperated corneas in the hypobaric and hypoxic environmental conditions present at high altitudes.3,4 The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of very high altitude and different ascent profiles on central corneal thickness (CCT). Assessment of these factors was performed, taking confounding variables into consideration. Thus, measurements were performed at similar times of day to minimize the effect of diurnal variation. Contact lens wearers, climbers with previous corneal surgery, and drug intake during the study period were analyzed separately.
This prospective, multidisciplinary, observational cohort study was performed within the scope of a high-altitude medical research expedition (Figure 1).5- 7 The study was approved by the ethical committee of the University Hospital Zurich and adheres to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki (1983 revision). Informed, written consent was obtained from all subjects prior to their examinations.
The ophthalmology study was composed of 28 healthy mountaineers (age, 26-62 years; mean age, 43 years; 6 women; 22 men). None were taking any medication long-term.
Prior to the expedition, all participants were randomly assigned to 1 of 2 ascent protocols on Mount Muztagh Ata (Figure 2), located in the western Xinjiang province in China. The ascent started at 3750 m above sea level and progressed to base camp (4497 m; barometric pressure, 447 torr), camp 1 (5533 m; barometric pressure, 392 torr), camp 2 (6265 m; barometric pressure, 357 torr), camp 3 (6865 m; barometric pressure, 333 torr), and then to the summit (7546 m; barometric pressure 301 torr) within 20 days in group 1 and 19 days in group 2. Group 1 was allotted a shorter acclimatization time prior to ascent to camp 2 than group 2 (7 vs 11 days from base camp to camp 2). All subjects underwent general and ophthalmic baseline examinations at the University Hospital Zurich before the expedition (490 m).
Ultrasound pachymetry was performed at the University Hospital Zurich and on the day after arrival at base camp (base camp 1), camp 1, and camp 2, and again at base camp (base camp 2) using a Pocket II Precision pachymeter (Quantel Medical Clermont-Ferrand, France). After benoxinate hydrochloride, 0.4%, single-dose units were administered (Novartis Pharma AG, Bern, Switzerland), CCT was determined by averaging 5 successive readings in each eye. A maximum standard deviation (SD) of 15 μm was defined a priori, and if this was exceeded, the complete measurement was repeated. According to the protocol, climbers were assessed in the same group at each examination starting at 9 AM, about 2 hours after awakening. Participants were asked to remove their contact lenses in the evening prior to the ophthalmic examinations.
Best-corrected visual acuity was measured using an Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study chart.8 Daily pulse oximetry was performed in the evening during quiet rest in a standing position with a finger pulse oximeter (Onyx 9500 SportStat; Nonin Medical Inc, Plymouth, Minnesota). Stable values after at least 3 minutes were recorded.
Cerebral AMS (AMS-c) scores on the Environmental Symptoms Questionnaire III were assessed daily during the expedition.6,9 The AMS-c score represents symptoms that seem to reflect altered cerebral function in conjunction with being ill.
Any drug intake was assessed by analyzing daily personal diaries. Medication other than nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs could only be taken by prescription from the expedition physician. Temperature in the examination tents was measured with a digital thermometer.
Statistical analyses were computed with commercially available software packages (SPSS, version 13, SPP Inc, Chicago, Illinois; Statistica 6, StatSoft Inc, Tulsa, Oklahoma; and Instat 3.06, Graphpad Inc, La Jolla, California). Differences between groups for normally distributed variables (Kolmogorov-Smirnov test) were assessed by analysis of variance for repeated measurements using 1 dependent variable (CCT), 1 grouping factor (group), and 1 within-subject factor (altitude). Assumption of sphericity was tested using the Mauchly sphericity test. When significant time × group interactions occurred, a separate analysis of variance for repeated measurements was performed in each group. If within-group analysis of variance was significant, differences between groups were tested at each time using unpaired t test and Bonferroni correction for multiple testing. Data are expressed as mean (SD) unless otherwise noted. Bivariate linear regression analysis was applied to investigate a possible correlation between SpO2 and CCT measurements. Multiple regression analysis was used to analyze associations between CCT and independent variables (SpO2, AMS-c scores, and age). Two-sided P < .05 was considered statistically significant.
Six participants of the initially 34 enrolled were excluded because of ocular disease prior to the expedition (n = 2) or incomplete data collection during the expedition (n = 4). Three contact lens wearers, 1 mountaineer with a history of laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis surgery on both eyes, and 2 mountaineers with drug intake (one of these a contact lens wearer) were analyzed separately (total, n = 5).
Central corneal thickness readings were normally distributed in each group at each altitude, and no significant differences of variances were detected. There was a significant altitude × group (ie, 2 different ascent profiles) interaction regarding the mean CCT (P = .048) (Figure 3A and Table).
Mean CCT in group 1 (short acclimatization) was increased at base camp 1 (547 μm [55 μm]) compared with that at University Hospital Zurich (537 μm [44 μm]) and remained stable at camp 1 (544 μm [56 μm]). Thereafter, a significant increase (P < .001, compared with University Hospital Zurich) was noted at camp 2 (572 μm [51 μm]).
Mean CCT in group 2 (longer acclimatization) steadily increased from the measurement at University Hospital Zurich (534 μm [28 μm]) to camp 2, where the thickest CCT readings (573 μm [29 μm]) were documented (they were significantly higher compared with measurements at all other altitudes) (Table and Figure 3A). On descent to base camp 2, CCT decreased to values that were significantly different from the ones at the same altitude before ascent (563 μm [28 μm] at base camp 2 vs 554 μm [31 μm] at base camp 1, P < .05). For logistical reasons, base camp 2 measurements were only performed in group 2.
Best-corrected visual acuity did not decrease significantly during the course of the expedition. Mean temperature during examinations on Mount Muztagh Ata was 21°C (SD, 7°C; range, 9°C-37°C).
Mean age (42 years in group 1, 43 years in group 2) and mean AMS-c scores did not differ significantly between groups (P = .68 and P = .35, respectively). The AMS-c scores and SpO2 measurements were unavailable for group 2 at base camp 2 because of logistical reasons (bad weather conditions).
Oxygen saturation measurements during the expedition for both groups were significantly lower than values recorded at baseline at University Hospital Zurich. During ascent, SpO2 decreased significantly at each altitude in both groups, except for the climb from camp 1 to camp 2 in group 2. On descent in group 1, measurements at base camp 2 compared with base camp 1 did not differ significantly (Figure 3C). As seen in Figure 3, the decrease in SpO2 during ascent from base camp 1 to camp 1 was more marked in group 2 than group 1.
Multiple regression analysis with CCT as the dependent variable and ascent group, SpO2, AMS-c score, and age as independent variables revealed a partial correlation coefficient of β = .12 (P = .20) for ascent group, β = −.11 (P = .22) for SpO2, β = .24 (P = .01) for AMS-c score, and β = .05 (P = .57) for age. Multicolinearity was not observed.
Bivariate linear regression analysis for each group with SpO2 as an independent variable and CCT as a dependent variable showed a Pearson correlation coefficient of r = −0.19 at a significance level of P = .08 in group 1 and a correlation coefficient of r = −0.37 (P < .001) in group 2 (Figure 3D).
Figure 3 shows the variations in CCT at different altitudes. During ascent from base camp 1 to camp 1, there was a greater increase in mean CCT in group 2 (6 μm) than in group 1 (3 μm). From camp 1 to camp 2, differences in CCT of 28 μm and 13 μm were noted in groups 1 and 2, respectively. Central corneal thickness at camp 2 in group 1 was measured after a shorter time following arrival at base camp (7 days) compared with those of group 2 between base camp 1 and camp 2 (11 days). Considering the decrease in CCT from camp 2 to base camp 2, we found no correlation between decrease and age (β = .05, P = .76). The changes of CCT measurements during the expedition in contact lens wearers and in the one climber with prior laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis paralleled those of the normal climbers (Figure 3B).
Two climbers, whose violent headaches had been nonresponsive to nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, were treated with 250 mg of acetazolamide, 8 mg of dexamethasone, and 20 mg of nifedipine on the second to last day of the observation period. Intake of these drugs took place more than 24 hours before examination. Central corneal thickness readings in the mountaineers after drug intake were similar to those of all the other mountaineers.
Four main findings of interest concerning CCT changes in healthy mountaineers were revealed by our study. (1) For the first time, in a very-high-altitude setting, a substantial increase in CCT (up to 13%) was documented during the ascent to 7564 m, followed by a subsequent rapid decrease on descent. (2) Changes in systemic SpO2 paralleled those of CCT, showing that a slower acclimatization profile resulted in less corneal edema. (3) Edema did not affect Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study visual acuity. (4) A significant and strong correlation between CCT and symptoms of AMS (AMS-c score) was observed.
The exact cause of corneal swelling due to hypoxic conditions is still the subject of controversy in numerous publications. Davson10 was the first to describe changes in different corneal hydration states in excised eyes. A comprehensive review by Bonanno11 highlights multiple factors that induce hypoxic corneal edema, which is caused almost entirely by swelling of the stroma.12- 14 Oxidative metabolism is reduced in hypoxic epithelial cells, which convert to anaerobic glycolysis for energy production, leading to increased lactate production. The latter diffuses posteriorly across the stroma and the endothelium and is then washed out by the aqueous humor. The higher lactate concentration within the corneal stroma may lead to an osmosis-driven influx of water15- 17 and a reduced activity of the endothelial pump function.18 Moreover, anterior surface hypoxia due to reduced atmospheric oxygen pressure leads to endothelial hypoxia, further reducing the pump function and resulting in a swelling of the cornea.19 Environmental oxygen partial pressure plays a prominent role in corneal oxygen supply. Only a small proportion of the corneal oxygen demand is met by diffusion from the aqueous humor,20 and oxygen is mainly supplied transcorneally via tear fluid to the aqueous humor.21 However, under conditions of low environmental oxygen supply and hence grossly impaired transcorneal oxygen transport, endothelial supply of physically bound oxygen in the anterior chamber may become increasingly important.
We did find a difference in the measured SpO2 and CCT values in the 2 groups with different ascent protocols. Climbers in group 1 were allotted less time for acclimatization than those in group 2. As seen in Figure 3, the decrease in SpO2 during ascent from base camp 1 to camp 1 was more marked in group 2 than in group 1. This was paralleled by a greater CCT increase in group 2, though CCT in all climbers was measured at the same altitude with the same environmental oxygen pressure. Thereafter a more marked increase in thickness from camp 1 to camp 2 was noted in group 1, which also presented a more extensive drop in SpO2 than group 2. These findings further support our hypothesis that blood SpO2 becomes more important for the endothelial pump function when environmental oxygen pressure and thus tear film SpO2 is reduced to a critical level. Our results thus highlight the importance of aqueous humor oxygen delivery. Systemic delivery of oxygen to the anterior chamber seems to play a greater role in corneal oxygenation than previously thought.
Central corneal thickness measurements at base camp 2, eg, at base camp after having reached the summit and descended, were slightly, albeit significantly, higher than at base camp 1, after 16 days on the mountain. Impaired endothelial pump function seems to recuperate quickly but not fully during prolonged hypoxia to clear stromal hydration. The time of recovery with repeated measurements of CCT during a short time postexposition to high altitudes should be a topic for future studies.
Previously, Morris et al3,4 found an average increase in CCT of 3.3% at an altitude of 5200 m. This is comparable with our results at 5533 m (camp 1), where an average increase of 3.2% was documented. Continuing with ascent and subjecting the body to more marked hypoxia leads to further increase of CCT, as seen in our climbers. Despite the marked increase in CCT, Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study visual acuity never deteriorated during our expedition. It seems that visual acuity in healthy corneas is not adversely affected despite the presence of edema at altitudes up to 6300 m. It is most likely that an even higher ascent to extreme altitudes above 8000 m induces more extensive endothelial pump function failure and may result in profuse edema leading to dangerous visual loss.
As previously shown, individuals who are more affected by AMS symptoms demonstrate more marked ocular changes with respect to optic disc swelling and ocular circulation.6,7 Accordingly, we expected individuals with more AMS-related symptoms to have thicker corneas owing to their evidently higher overall susceptibility to hypoxia. Our results of a significant correlation of CCT with AMS-c scores support this hypothesis.
We found no correlation between age and CCT. This may be surprising since it has been shown that corneal hydration control under hypoxic conditions is impaired in older subjects.22,23 Our older climbers appeared to be more robust and less affected by the significant decrease in SpO2 than some of their younger colleagues during the expedition6,7; fewer AMS-related symptoms and less optic disc swelling were detected in this subgroup. This may explain the lack of difference in endothelial pump function compared with the younger climbers.
Acetazolamide is used as a mainstay for the prevention and treatment of AMS and high-altitude cerebral edema.1 Carbonic anhydrase activity can be found in several ocular tissues, including the cornea, where it plays a central role in endothelial cell function.24 There are several reports of negative effects of systemically and locally applied acetazolamide on the endothelium.25- 27 Although we did not observe any adverse effects in our 2 climbers who took acetazolamide during the expedition, we did find increasing endothelial impairment during ascent. Thus, we suggest that acetazolamide be used with caution in climbers who have reduced endothelial cell function as found in diseases such as Fuchs endothelial dystrophy, as this might worsen the corneal edema.
Ultrasound pachymetry is considered the gold standard for measuring corneal thickness and has an excellent repeatability.28 Although newer measurement techniques with even higher repeatability are available, we chose handheld ultrasound pachymetry owing to transportation reasons.29 Limitations of our study include lack of daily CCT measurements. Not all measurements could be performed at every altitude owing to difficult weather conditions.
Correspondence: Martina Monika Bosch, MD, Department of Ophthalmology, University Hospital Zurich, Frauenklinikstrasse 24, 8091 Zurich, Switzerland (email@example.com).
Submitted for Publication: June 4, 2009; final revision received July 28, 2009; accepted July 29, 2009.
Author Contributions: Dr Martina Bosch indicates that she had full access to all the data in the study and takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis. Drs Bosch and Barthelmes share first authorship (equal contribution by both authors). More than 6 authors are listed since this high-altitude research expedition required a great amount of work that could not have been achieved successfully by fewer researchers. All authors contributed substantially to this study.
Financial Disclosure: None reported.
Funding/Support: This project was supported by research grant EK 11 1146 from the Swiss National Research Science Foundation, a research grant by the Swiss Society of Mountain Medicine, a private grant to the Department of Ophthalmology, University Hospital Zurich, and by an unconditional grant from Pfizer, Switzerland.
Previous Presentations: Parts of this study were presented as a poster at the Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology 2009 Annual Meeting; Fort Lauderdale, Florida; May 3-7, 2009 (abstract number 1808).
Additional Contributions: Timothy Holmes, MCS, Gregor Schubiger, MD, Jacqueline Pichler, MD, and Thomas Hess, MD, provided valuable help on Mount Muztagh Ata. We also convey our gratitude towards Professor Marco Maggiorini who was of substantial help in planning our research expedition.