My colleagues and I appreciate the comments of Gordon and coworkers. They made several interesting points:
They suggested that the link between MDD and motion exposure might be "merely coincidental." We agree that this is possible, but we think that it is highly unlikely that a homogeneous group of middle-aged women should develop these symptoms merely by coincidence. They suggested that there was a lack of a "meticulous neuro-otological examination." While this was the case for some of these patients, examination was simply not possible in all given the survey design of our study.
Hain TC. Mal de Debarquement—Reply. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2000;126(6):805-806. doi: