August 1988

Surface Cultures in the Newborn and Deeper Implications-Reply

Author Affiliations

Departments of Pathology and Pediatrics Arizona Health Sciences Center University of Arizona College of Medicine 1501 N Campbell Ave Tucson, AZ 85724

Am J Dis Child. 1988;142(8):812-813. doi:10.1001/archpedi.1988.02150080017006

In Reply.—The comments by Drs Boutwell and Brown are most appropriate. I consulted with Dr Murray A. Katz, the author of the reference in question, and he concurs that (1) his proposed formula was intended for use when the sensitivity of a test is, or approaches, 1.00, and (2) I had misplaced the parentheses in the denominator of the formula.

I am comforted only by their agreement that the conclusions reached by Evans et al and us remain appropriate. I have certainly learned from this overly enthusiastic excursion into statistical territory and hope that our readers will also benefit from the perspicacity of Drs Boutwell and Brown.

Dr Boutwell also points out quite well some problems previously highlighted by Doubilet et al,1 with respect to the various interpretations of "costeffectiveness" in medicine. As a minimum, cost savings should be coupled with a demonstrable equal (or better) health outcome.

First Page Preview View Large
First page PDF preview
First page PDF preview