By Ernst Harms, PhD. Price, $7.75. Pp 256. Charles C Thomas, Publisher, 301-327 E Lawrence Ave, Springfield, Ill 1967.
This article is only available in the PDF format. Download the PDF to view the article, as well as its associated figures and tables.
To cultivate a garden, one must not only tend to the flowers but also cut down the weeds. This sage injunction is sole warrant for the reviewer's labors and the ARCHIVES' space accorded to a work that merits neither.
In Origins of Modern Psychiatry the former editor of the long-defunct journal The Nervous Child has strung together a miscellany of 28 previously published articles—and called it a book.
In this book each article is counted a chapter and the "chapters" are strung together with little rhyme or reason. Some chapters are "itsy-bitsy crumbs" of medical history. Thus Chapter 5, dealing with Stahl, is three pages long. Chapter 6, devoted to Monro II, is even shorter—11/2 pages. Chapter 9, on the origin and early history of electroshock therapy (EST), is 21/22 pages long. In this brief gem the author manages to confuse electrotherapy with EST, to indict Ugo
Galdston I. Origins of Modern Psychiatry.. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1968;18(6):762-763. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.1968.01740060122016