Adjusted odds ratios (ORs) for each cancer for patients with schizophrenia (S) and bipolar disorder (B) compared with patients without mental health problems. Error bars represent 95% confidence intervals.
Hippisley-Cox J, Vinogradova Y, Coupland C, Parker C. Risk of Malignancy in Patients With Schizophrenia or Bipolar DisorderNested Case-Control Study. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2007;64(12):1368-1376. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.64.12.1368
There is conflicting evidence on whether people with schizophrenia have a different risk of cancer from that of the general population.
To determine the risk of 6 common cancers in patients with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder.
Population-based, nested, case-control study.
A total of 454 practices contributing to the QRESEARCH general practice database.
We analyzed 40 441 incident cases of 6 cancers (breast, colon, rectal, gastroesophageal, prostate, and respiratory) and up to 5 controls per case matched by single year of age, sex, general practice, and calendar time.
Main Outcome Measures
Odds ratios (ORs) for cancer risk associated with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, adjusting for smoking, body mass index, socioeconomic status, comorbidities, and prescribed medications, including antipsychotics.
For breast cancer, we identified 10 535/50 074 cases/controls; colon cancer, 5108/24 458; rectal cancer, 3248/15 552; gastroesophageal cancer, 3854/18 477; prostate cancer, 10 190/48 748; and respiratory cancer, 7506/35 981. After adjustment, patients with schizophrenia had a 190% increased colon cancer risk (adjusted OR, 2.90; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.85-4.57), a marginal increased breast cancer risk (adjusted OR, 1.52; 95% CI, 1.10-2.11), and a 47% decreased respiratory cancer risk (adjusted OR, 0.53, 95% CI, 0.34-0.85). Patients with schizophrenia taking antipsychotics had a 308% increased colon cancer risk (adjusted OR, 4.08; 95% CI, 2.43-6.84). Patients with bipolar disorder had cancer risks similar to patients with neither condition after adjustment.
Patients with schizophrenia have a significantly higher risk of colon cancer and a lower risk of respiratory cancer compared with patients without schizophrenia after adjustment for confounders. In contrast, the risks of cancer in patients with and without bipolar disorder are similar, suggesting that residual confounding is unlikely to explain the findings. The increased risk of colon cancer is particularly marked in patients with schizophrenia who take antipsychotic medications.
For almost 100 years, there has been speculation that patients with schizophrenia have lower cancer risks than the general population. In 1909, this possibility was raised by the Board of Control of the Commissioners in Lunacy for England and Wales,1 but a century later the evidence is still far from clear. Whereas some studies have suggested a lower cancer incidence or mortality rate in people with schizophrenia,2- 7 others have found either an increased cancer incidence8 or mortality9 associated with schizophrenia or nonsignificant effects.10,11 Existing studies have been limited by size, use of biased populations (such as hospital-based cohorts), and lack of ability to control for potential confounding effects. Failure to adjust for these factors is extremely important given that patients with mental health problems have a higher prevalence of common risk factors, including smoking, alcohol consumption, and obesity12,13; they are also less likely to report physical symptoms or to adhere to treatment regimens.14,15
Considerable uncertainty therefore exists regarding the risk of common cancers in patients with schizophrenia. This is important with respect to designing screening programs as well as etiology. For example, there are theories that schizophrenia itself has a possible protective effect, including a tumor suppressor gene or enhanced natural killer cell activity.16,17 Alternatively, medication used in the treatment of schizophrenia may have an antipsychotic effect via the inhibition of enzymes involved in mutation.18
Therefore, we undertook a study to compare the risks of 6 common cancers between patients with and without schizophrenia using a very large population-based research database called QRESEARCH, which enabled us to adjust for many potential confounding variables. In addition, we compared cancer risks in patients with bipolar disorder, who have similar lifestyle characteristics as patients with schizophrenia but who are likely to differ with respect to use of medication and any inherent physical correlates of the disease.
The full QRESEARCH database (http://www.qresearch.org/) currently contains the anonymized primary care clinical records of more than 10 million people registered at any time in the past 16 years with 525 general practices in the United Kingdom. Consent to provide data is sought from practices using the Egton Medical Information Services (EMIS) medical records system, and detailed analyses have shown that participating practices are somewhat larger than nonparticipating practices but in all other respects are very similar.19 The database derives from a representative sample of 6% of all the general practices throughout England, Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland. The database includes patients' medical records before their registration with any of these practices. The computer system at each participating practice automatically uploads data every 24 hours, ensuring that the most recent information is available. The database has been subjected to detailed analyses of age-sex distributions, birth rates, death rates, consultation rates, prevalence rates, and mortality rates, showing good correspondence with other sources20 and good levels of completeness and consistency.21
We obtained ethical approval from the Trent Multicenter Research Ethics Committee. We used version 7 of the QRESEARCH database, which contained data until August 1, 2005, and included general practices that had used their current computer system for at least 12 months. We identified an open cohort of patients registered with these practices during the 10-year study period (January 1, 1995, to July 1, 2005). For each of 6 common cancers (breast, colon, rectal, gastroesophageal, prostate, and respiratory), we assembled a separate set of individually matched cases and controls from this cohort. Cases all involved patients aged 25 to 100 years with a first-ever record of the index cancer during the study period, including those where the diagnosis was recorded post mortem. We used incidence density sampling to identify up to 5 controls for each incident case matched by single year of age, calendar time, sex, and practice. All the controls were alive and registered with the practice at the date their matched case was first recorded to have the relevant cancer; this was the index date for each case and its controls. Patients were excluded from the study if they had any cancer diagnosis in their record before the first diagnosis of the index cancer (for cases) or the equivalent date (for controls).
We included only patients with at least 12 months of computerized medical record data before their index date to ensure that prescribing data were complete. We excluded breast cancer cases with a record of mastectomy or tamoxifen use more than 12 months before their first record of cancer because these treatments could indicate that they were not incident cases at the time of cancer diagnosis. We also excluded controls with any prior record of mastectomy or tamoxifen use because they could be breast cancer cases without a formal diagnosis in their record.
We extracted demographic information, including year of birth, sex, and Townsend score (a measure of socioeconomic status). We also extracted each patient's most recent body mass index (BMI) (calculated as weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared) and smoking status before their index date. Cancer cases and controls were coded as having schizophrenia or bipolar disorder if there was a recorded diagnosis at least 12 months before their index date. We included data on 4 comorbid physical conditions before the index date (ischemic heart disease, diabetes mellitus, hypertension, and rheumatoid arthritis).
We assessed exposure to medications on the basis of at least 1 prescription before the index date. To avoid bias due to reverse causality, we excluded medication used in the 12 months immediately preceding the index date. We included medications for which there was previous evidence of positive or negative association with malignancy, including nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, cyclooxygenase 2 inhibitors, aspirin, statins, hormone therapy, oral contraceptives, antidepressants (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors and tricyclic antidepressants), and antipsychotic medications (conventional antipsychotics, atypical antipsychotics, and lithium).
For each cancer, we undertook multiple conditional logistic regression to estimate odds ratios (ORs) associated with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. We adjusted the models for the possible confounding effects of smoking (current smoker, not current smoker, or not recorded), BMI (<25, 25-29, ≥30, or not recorded), Townsend score (in fifths), comorbidities (binary), and medications (binary) as well as the other serious mental health condition. We adjusted for use of hormone therapy and oral contraceptives in the breast, colon, and rectal cancer models. All cases and controls were included in the analyses by treating “missing” as a category for the smoking, BMI, and socioeconomic variables. The analyses were repeated on the subset of cases and controls with full data on all variables.
To further examine the relationship between cancer risk and use of antipsychotic medications, we calculated ORs for each cancer for patients with schizophrenia with and without recorded use of antipsychotic medications compared with patients with neither mental health problem. All analyses were conducted using a software program (Stata version 9.1; StataCorp, College Station, Texas).
A total of 454 QRESEARCH practices met the inclusion criteria for this analysis. The total study population consisted of 4 040 494 patients, giving rise to 18 772 868 person-years of observation. We identified 47 924 incident cases of the 6 cancers, of which 7483 met the exclusion criteria, leaving 40 441 cases for analysis. For breast cancer, 740 cases with mastectomy or tamoxifen use more than 12 months previously were excluded, as were 416 controls with any prior record of mastectomy or tamoxifen use. Almost 92% of the respiratory cancer cases were lung cancer (6894 of 7506). Table 1 gives the number of cases and controls for each cancer and the prevalence of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder in each group. Nine cases and 37 controls had diagnoses of both schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Table 2 summarizes the characteristics of cases and controls for each cancer, and Table 3 compares patients with and without schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, showing that the groups with mental health problems were somewhat younger and more likely to smoke and had lower rates of some comorbidities than the group with neither mental health problem.
Table 4 gives the ORs for each cancer associated with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, unadjusted and adjusted for socioeconomic status, smoking, BMI, comorbidities, and use of medications. The adjusted analysis (also shown in the Figure) shows that people with schizophrenia had significantly higher risks of breast cancer (adjusted OR, 1.52; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.10-2.11) and colon cancer (adjusted OR, 2.90; 95% CI, 1.85-4.57) and a significantly lower risk of respiratory cancer (adjusted OR, 0.53; 95% CI, 0.34-0.85). There were no significant differences in their risks of rectal, gastroesophageal, or prostate cancer. Patients with bipolar disorder had ORs closer to unity for each cancer, and there were no statistically significant associations after adjustment for confounders.
Restricting the respiratory cancer analysis to lung cancer cases and their controls made little difference to the observed reduction in risk for people with schizophrenia (adjusted OR, 0.59; 95% CI, 0.37-0.95). Restricting the analysis for each cancer to patients with full data on all confounding variables made no substantial difference to the adjusted ORs for colon, rectal, gastroesophageal, or prostate cancer. For breast and respiratory cancers, the adjusted ORs were closer to unity and the CIs were wider (breast: OR, 1.28; 95% CI, 0.84-1.96; respiratory: OR, 0.67; 95% CI, 0.39-1.15).
Overall, 489 of the 710 patients with schizophrenia (68.9%) had 1 or more prescriptions for antipsychotic medications at least 12 months before their index date. Table 5 shows separate ORs for each cancer for patients with schizophrenia who had or had not been prescribed antipsychotic medications compared with patients with neither mental health condition, first unadjusted and then adjusted as described in the “Statistical Methods” subsection of the “Methods” section. The 52.2% increase in breast cancer risk found for patients with schizophrenia overall (after adjustment) was not substantially different in the subgroups with and without antipsychotic medication use (55.0% and 42.6%, respectively). The almost 3-fold increased risk of colon cancer in patients with schizophrenia overall was stronger (>4-fold) in the subgroup of patients with schizophrenia also prescribed antipsychotic medications. The overall 46.5% reduced risk of respiratory cancer in patients with schizophrenia was most marked (85.8%) in the subgroup not taking antipsychotics. In view of the small numbers in some of the subgroup analyses, particularly for rectal and gastroesophageal cancers, caution is needed in interpreting these ORs.
This is a very large population-based study to determine the risks of 6 common cancers (breast, colon, rectal, gastroesophageal, prostate, and respiratory) in patients with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. The key finding in patients with schizophrenia was a 3-fold increased risk of colon cancer, which was more than 4-fold in patients also prescribed antipsychotic medications, despite adjustment for the potential confounding effects of socioeconomic status, smoking, obesity, comorbidity, and concurrent use of other medications. This is a novel and unexpected finding that needs further investigation. We also found a 52.2% increased risk of breast cancer, and a 46.5% decreased risk of respiratory cancer (predominantly lung cancer) after adjustment for the same variables. Patients with bipolar disorder had similar cancer risks as people without either mental health condition after adjustment for the potential confounding variables.
The most important finding in this study is a marked increased risk of colon cancer in patients with schizophrenia. This is a novel finding and one that is in contrast with previous studies,4,8,22 which have tended to suggest no difference in risk of colon cancer in patients with schizophrenia. The previous UK study by Goldacre et al22 found a nonsignificant rate ratio of 0.72. Their study differed from this one in a variety of ways, being based on records of hospital admissions rather than on the primary care records of the whole population, the reference cohort being drawn from patients admitted to the hospital for other conditions, and rates being standardized by age and sex but no adjustment being made for potential confounding variables. The finding of an almost 3-fold increased risk of colon cancer persisted whether or not the results were adjusted for known risk factors, including obesity23 and socioeconomic status,24 and for use of hormone therapy or oral contraceptives, which might reduce risk.25 We did not adjust for diet, exercise, or alcohol consumption,26 and these factors tend not to be reliably recorded in electronic medical records. We found that the increase in colon cancer was greatest in patients with schizophrenia prescribed antipsychotic agents. This is in contrast to a recent study27 that reported a reduction in risk associated with these drugs, although this was found in a wider population, of whom only 6% had schizophrenia.
For rectal cancer, which has few established risk factors, we found no significant increase or decrease in risk for patients with severe mental illness, in contrast to other studies,4,8,22 which demonstrate a decrease in risk, but our numbers in these subgroups were small.
We found a marginal 52.2% increase in risk of breast cancer in women with schizophrenia. This is consistent with some4,28,29 but not all studies, which have generally found no difference5,8,22,30 or a reduction in risk.2 There have been suggestions that an increase in risk of breast cancer could be mediated by a prolactin-releasing effect of neuroleptic medications,31 but a recent study did not confirm this,27 and we found only a marginal association with medication. We adjusted for some risk factors that could confound the relationship between schizophrenia and cancer risk, including obesity32 and use of oral contraceptives or hormone therapy.33,34 However, we did not adjust for the observed lower parity in women with schizophrenia,4 which tends to be associated with an increased risk of breast cancer. In other words, it is possible that the marginal increased risk of breast cancer demonstrated in this study is due to residual confounding by lower parity rather than a true increase in risk.
Some previous studies have reported a higher incidence or mortality due to respiratory cancer,6,8,10 but others report a lower risk consistent with the present findings4,7 or a nonsignificant difference.5,22 Smoking is a major risk factor for lung cancer and is more prevalent in people with schizophrenia,12 making it a potential source of substantial confounding in these studies; it was adjusted for in the present analysis. The largely institutionalized life of many people with schizophrenia could protect them from some environmental risks, and antipsychotic drugs have been suggested as being protective, but in this sample the reduction in risk was greatest in patients not taking antipsychotic medications. The authors of a recent study27 that found an increased risk of lung cancer associated with antipsychotic medication suggested residual confounding by smoking. Again, we found that patients with bipolar disorder did not share the reduced risk associated with schizophrenia.
We found no significant difference in risk of gastroesophageal cancer in people with schizophrenia, which is consistent with 2 previous studies.2,8 Other studies have reported a higher risk of cancer of the esophagus after adjusting for age and sex4,22 and reduced mortality from gastric cancer.35 In the present study, adjustment for potential confounders, including socioeconomic status,24 moved the OR closer to unity, but we did not adjust for alcohol consumption, which is a strong risk factor for cancers of the upper digestive tract.36
The adjusted analysis suggests a 40.7% lower risk of prostate cancer in people with schizophrenia, but in view of the small numbers in these subgroups, this was not a statistically significant reduction. The magnitude of the association is consistent with that of previous studies, which have shown an approximately 50% lower risk.4,6- 8 Little is known about risk factors for prostate cancer, but a protective effect of neuroleptic medications, particularly phenothiazines, has been suggested27,37; our subgroup analysis is consistent with this but is based on numbers too small to reach a firm conclusion. Alternatively, the lower risk could represent an ascertainment bias if patients with schizophrenia are less likely to have screening for prostate cancer.
Aggregated general practice databases, such as QRESEARCH, have previously been used successfully to evaluate risk factors for diseases in the population.38- 41 The use of routine clinical records and a nested case-control design gave this study a large and representative population-based sample, matched cancer cases and controls, no response or recall bias, and a comparison group with another mental health condition (bipolar disorder). Recording of clinical diagnoses was shown to have good levels of accuracy and completeness in general practice in the United Kingdom, including malignancy and psychiatric illness, where the diagnosis is recorded after specialist investigations and consultations.42,43 The quality of the electronic medical record is thought to be highest in practices that contribute to primary care databases.44 Advantages of this study in contrast to previous work are that we adjusted for confounders such as smoking, BMI, and socioeconomic status and for commonly used medications, including antipsychotics. Information on alcohol consumption, diet, exercise, and reproductive history is less reliably recorded and was not included. However, in people with bipolar disorder, who would be expected to share some of the increased risk attributable to these lifestyle factors, we did not find the associations with cancer observed in patients with schizophrenia. Even with almost 19 million person-years of observation, the small number of patients with mental health problems in some subgroups limited the size of the effect that could be detected.
It is possible that some cancers were undiagnosed in people with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, perhaps owing to underreporting of physical problems or lack of participation in screening programs. However, such a misclassification of outcomes would tend to bias the OR downward rather than generating spuriously positive findings, such as the increased risk of colon cancer in patients with schizophrenia. By excluding diagnoses of schizophrenia or bipolar disorder made in the 12 months preceding the diagnosis of cancer, we minimized the possibility that apparent psychiatric symptoms were a manifestation of the cancer.
The possible association between schizophrenia and increased risk of colon and breast cancers is of practical and theoretical importance not only in terms of the organization of services (such as screening) but also in the understanding of the etiology of disease. Given the study design, it is not possible to eliminate the possibility of residual confounding by such factors as alcohol consumption, diet, and reproductive history. However, in people with bipolar disorder, who would be expected to share some of the increased risk attributable to lifestyle, we did not find higher rates of breast or colon cancer.
In particular, the increased risk of colon cancer demonstrated in this study, which was greatest for those taking antipsychotic medications, is a novel and unexpected finding. The magnitude of the risk and the degree of statistical significance does not rule out a chance finding, although it does make it unlikely. The finding of a lower risk of respiratory cancer, particularly in those who were not taking antipsychotic drugs, argues for an intrinsic protection associated with schizophrenia rather than the previously suggested effect of medication. Further research is needed to confirm or refute these findings using an independent data source with a more detailed analysis of individual drugs, including a comparison of the older class of antipsychotics with the newer atypical agents.
The higher rate of some common cancers in people with schizophrenia emphasizes the need for proactive monitoring of their physical health, which has previously been highlighted.45 Factors such as obesity, smoking, and high alcohol consumption are more prevalent in this group12,13 and increase the risk not only of cancer but of many other conditions, including diabetes mellitus and cardiac disease. Antipsychotic medications differ in the extent to which they increase the risk of obesity and other conditions.46,47 If there is an inherently higher risk of some cancers in people with schizophrenia, it is particularly important to minimize any additional risks associated with lifestyle or prescribed medications.
Correspondence: Julia Hippisley-Cox, MD, Division of Primary Care, University of Nottingham, 13th Floor Tower Bldg, University Park, Nottingham NG7 2RD, England (email@example.com).
Submitted for Publication: January 11, 2007; final revision received March 22, 2007; accepted April 27, 2007.
Author Contributions: Dr Hippisley-Cox takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis; all authors had full access to all the data in the study.
Financial Disclosure: None reported.
Funding/Support: This study was funded by the UK Disability Rights Commission; by core funding from the University of Nottingham (Drs Hippisley-Cox and Coupland and Ms Vinogradova); and by research and development funding from the National Health Service (Ms Parker).
Role of the Sponsor: The Disability Rights Commission had no role in the study design, data extraction, analysis, interpretation, or writing or approval of the manuscript.
Additional Contributions: We acknowledge the EMIS practices that contribute data to the QRESEARCH database free of charge. Egton Medical Information Services and David Stables, MBCHB (medical director of EMIS) provided support in creating and maintaining the research database.