Polymorphonuclear leukocyte viability after 24 hours of incubation in RPMI 1640 with varying concentrations of granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor. Bars represent SEM for each data point and n=4 for each dose.
Goodman ER, Stricker P, Velavicius M, Fonseca R, Kleinstein E, Lavery R, Deitch EA, Hauser CJ, Simms HH. Role of Granulocyte-Macrophage Colony-Stimulating Factor and Its Receptor in the Genesis of Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Through an Effect on Neutrophil Apoptosis. Arch Surg. 1999;134(10):1049-1054. doi:10.1001/archsurg.134.10.1049
Copyright 1999 American Medical Association. All Rights Reserved. Applicable FARS/DFARS Restrictions Apply to Government Use.1999
That granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) and its receptor modulate the suppression of apoptosis (Ao) of normal neutrophils incubated in the plasma of patients with postraumatic acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS).
Experimental study using cultured human neutrophils.
University hospital, level I trauma center.
Plasma was obtained from 14 patients with early, fulminant posttraumatic ARDS (mean Injury Severity Score, 22). All samples were drawn within 24 hours after injury. Plasma was also taken from up to 21 healthy control subjects. These volunteers were also used as sources of polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs).
Main Outcome Measures
(1) Effect of early, fulminant ARDS and normal plasma on spontaneous Ao and GM-CSF receptor expression in PMNs in vitro. (2) Effect of ligation of either GM-CSF or its receptor with a neutralizing monoclonal antibody (mAb) on PMN Ao in ARDS and normal plasma. (3) Correlation of extracellular GM-CSF concentration with rate of PMN Ao. (4) Levels of GM-CSF in ARDS and normal plasma and in culture supernatant of normal PMNs incubated in early, fulminant ARDS and normal plasma.
Plasma from patients with ARDS enhanced PMN viability at 24 hours (data are given as mean±SEM) 52%±3% control vs 60%±3% ARDS, P<.05). Binding of the GM-CSF receptor with a neutralizing mAb significantly reduced PMN viability in ARDS plasma, but not in normal plasma (60%±3% ARDS vs 53%±3% ARDS + mAb, P<.05). Ligation of GM-CSF with mAb had no significant effect on PMN viability in either plasma. Only 1% of PMNs expressed detectable levels of the GM-CSF receptor when incubated for 24 hours in either ARDS or normal plasma. The GM-CSF levels were undetectable (>7 pg/mL) in both ARDS and normal plasma and in culture supernatants taken after 24 hours of incubation in both plasma types. Levels of GM-CSF ranging from 0 to 50,000 pg/mL had no effect on PMN Ao in plasma-free medium.
The antiapoptotic effect of ARDS plasma appears to be mediated by the GM-CSF receptor. This effect occurs at both low levels of plasma GM-CSF and surface expression of its PMN receptor. Ligation of GM-CSF had no effect of PMN Ao, suggesting that Ao is triggered by Fc portion-mediated receptor cross-linking. These results provide the theoretical basis for αGM-CSF receptor mAb therapy as a novel modality of treatment for ARDS.
ACUTE respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) appears to be an inflammatory process mediated by polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs).1 Large numbers of intra-alveolar PMNs accumulate in the early phase of ARDS, such that PMNs constitute 80% or more of the total cells obtained by bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL), compared with approximately 3% in normal subjects. Stimulation of PMNs to secrete elastase, myeloperoxidase, and toxic oxygen metabolites leads to the observed lung injury.1
Elimination of PMNs through the induction of programmed cell death or apoptosis (Ao) is thought to help modulate the inflammatory response in the lung after major trauma. Inhibition of Ao may have beneficial effects by perpetuating the phagocytic function of PMNs in inflammatory foci. It can, however, also increase the risk of ARDS by causing the abnormal persistence of inflammation and tissue destruction within the lung.
Many cytokines, including interleukin (IL) 8, granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), and growth-related oncogene-α, have been implicated in the modulation of PMN activity and survival in the lung in ARDS.2- 6 We previously hypothesized that soluble factors in early fulminant (E/F) ARDS plasma could inhibit spontaneous PMN Ao in vitro and that alterations in PMN Ao due to these factors in vivo might be implicated in the pathogenesis of E/F ARDS after major trauma.7 We reported that IL-8, although present in high concentrations in the plasma of patients with posttraumatic E/F ARDS, does not appear to modulate normal PMN Ao in vitro.7 The purpose of this study was to determine whether GM-CSF, which exists in high concentrations within the alveoli of patients with ARDS,8 plays a central role in this antiapoptotic effect. Plasma from burn patients inhibits normal PMN Ao in vitro: neutralization of GM-CSF in burn plasma with monoclonal antibody (mAb) suppresses this antiapoptotic effect.9 We therefore postulated that increases in plasma levels of GM-CSF after major trauma predispose to ARDS through the suppression of normal PMN Ao.
All research was conducted and all patient samples were collected in accordance with the requirements of the Institutional Review Board of University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey, Newark, NJ.
The PMNs were prepared from minimally heparinized whole blood of healthy volunteer donors. Specimens were spun at 1500 rpm for 15 minutes. Plasma was removed and kept at 4°C until cells were prepared for incubation. The PMNs were isolated by sequential separations using the Ficoll-Hypaque technique and dextran sedimentation. Osmotic lysis with 0.14-mol/L ammonium chloride was used to remove contaminating red blood cells. The cells were washed twice and resuspended in RPMI 1640 at 106 cells/mL. The PMN purity was assessed by flow cytometric staining for the PMN surface marker CD15: purity was typically found to be greater than 95%. Only samples that showed viability greater than 85% (as determined by trypan blue dye exclusion) were used for the experiments.
Blood was obtained from 14 patients with clinical and radiological evidence of early posttraumatic ARDS (as defined by the following: PaO2/FiO2 [fraction of inspired O2] <150 mm Hg, diffuseparenchymal infiltrates on chest x-ray film, pulmonary capillary wedge pressure <18 mm Hg, and no evidence of sepsis) and from healthy volunteers. The mean Injury Severity Score of the patients was 22 (range, 9-43) and the mortality rate was 36% (5/14). Samples were drawn from patients within 24 hours of injury. Plasma was prepared by spinning down minimally heparinized whole blood at 1500 rpm for 15 minutes. The plasma was decanted and either kept at 4°C for immediate use or aliquoted and stored at −80°C. Patient samples were obtained according to appropriate institutional review board protocols.
First, 100,000 PMNs from volunteers were suspended in 80 µL of RPMI 1640. Then, 20 µL of autologous plasma or ARDS patient plasma was added to make a total of 100 µL suspension (20% plasma) and the cells were incubated at 37°C for 24 hours. Cell viability and Ao were assessed with Annexin V (Trevigen Inc, Gaithersburg, Md) fluorescein isothiocyanate, and propidium iodide (Trevigen Inc). Cells were stained with Annexin V and propidium iodide for 30 minutes at room temperature in the dark. The samples were placed in ice and analyzed fresh using commercial software (FACSCalibur flow cytometer and CELLQuest; Becton Dickinson, San Jose, Calif).
Two micrograms of anti–GM-CSF receptor blocking mAb (Pharmingen Inc, San Diego, Calif) were added to 100,000 PMNs in 80 µL RPMI 1640 sixty minutes prior to the addition of 20 µL of ARDS or volunteer plasma. The mAb (clone 17-A) is a mouse IgGα2 specific for the α chain of the human receptor. This concentration of mAb (20 µg/mL) provides more than 90% neutralization of the receptor, based on inhibition of the GM-CSF dependent proliferation of the erythroleukemic cell line TF-1.10 Cells were incubated at 37°C for 24 hours and then stained and analyzed as previously described.
In those experiments in which GM-CSF itself was ligated, 0.15 µg of mAb was added to 20 µL of ARDS and control plasma prior to its addition to 80 µL of PMN suspension (106 cells / mL). The BVD2-23B6 clone is a rat IgGα2 that neutralizes human GM-CSF bioactivity: 40 ng/mL has been found to neutralize the proliferative effect of 100 pg/mL of GM-CSF.11 The 1500 ng/mL concentration of mAb used in this experiment was therefore more than enough to neutralize the GM-CSF in both ARDS and volunteer plasma and culture supernatant.
One hundred thousand donor PMNs were suspended in 95 µL of RPMI 1640, to which 5 µL of sterile phosphate buffered saline (Gibco BRL, Grand Island, NY) containing varying doses of recombinant human GM-CSF (R&D Systems, Minneapolis, Minn) was added. Final GM-CSF concentrations ranging from 0 to 50,000 pg/mL were chosen because they more than encompass the range of levels detected in clinical samples of plasma and BAL fluid (BALF) taken from patients with ARDS.8 Cells were incubated at 37°C for 24 hours and then stained and analyzed as previously described.
Granulocyte-macrophage colony–stimulating factor receptor expression was determined by adding 0.5 µg of FITC-labeled anti–GM-CSF receptor mAb to 100,000 donor PMNs, which were then incubated in the dark at room temperature for 20 minutes. Cells were washed twice and fixed with 1% methanol-free formaldehyde (Polysciences, Warrington, Pa). They were stored in the dark at 4°C until analyzed via flow cytometry within 36 hours.
The GM-CSF levels in ARDS and volunteer plasma samples and in supernatants of PMN suspensions incubated in ARDS and volunteer plasma over 24 hours were determined by means of a sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay kit (R&D Systems) as described by the vendor. The range of detectable levels was 7 to 500 pg/L.
Mean values and SEs of the mean were calculated for cell viability, Ao, GM-CSF receptor surface expression, plasma, and supernatant GM-CSF concentration. The Mann-Whitney test was used to analyze the differences in viability and Ao.
Plasma from patients with ARDS enhanced PMN viability at 24 hours when compared with control plasma (all data are given as mean±SEM unless otherwise indicated) (60%±3% ARDS vs 52%±3% control, P<.05; analysis of variance followed by Duncan multiple range test) (Table 1). The Ao was suppressed by ARDS plasma (37%±2% ARDS vs 47%±3% control, P<.05: analysis of variance followed by Duncan multiple range test) (Table 1). In ARDS plasma, binding of the GM-CSF receptor with a neutralizing mAb both significantly reduced PMN viability (60%±3% ARDS vs 53%±3% ARDS + mAb, P<.05; analysis of variance + Duncan multiple range test) and enhanced Ao (37%±3% ARDS vs 47%±2% ARDS + mAb, P<.05: analysis of variance + Duncan multiple range test). It had no effect on viability or Ao in normal plasma (Table 1). Neutralization of GM-CSF had no effect on either viability or Ao in both ARDS and normal plasma (Table 2).
Only 1% of PMNs expressed detectable levels of the GM-CSF receptor when incubated for 24 hours in either ARDS (n=6) or normal plasma (n=6). The GM-CSF levels were undetectable (ie,<7 pg/mL) in ARDS (n=6) or normal plasma (n=6); culture supernatants taken from PMNs incubated for 24 hours in either 20% ARDS (n=6) or normal plasma (n=6) also showed no detectable level of GM-CSF.
The GM-CSF had no effect on the viability of normal PMNs in plasma-free medium at even very high levels (50,000 pg/mL) (Figure 1). Similarly, there was no dose-dependent effect on PMN Ao (data not shown).
Prevention or termination of PMN-driven inflammatory processes such as ARDS may be effected through PMN Ao. Induction of PMN Ao with the subsequent rapid removal of the PMNs by alveolar macrophages provides the lung with a mechanism by which it can minimize PMN-mediated damage to the surrounding tissue. Normal PMNs undergo Ao after 24 hours in the peripheral circulation, but Ao is delayed in PMNs migrating into inflammatory foci.12 This inhibition is mediated through cytokines such as granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF), GM-CSF, IL-1β, and IL-8.12 Prolongation of PMN survival through the suppression of Ao has been identified in circulating PMNs isolated from patients with severe burns.9 This dysregulation of Ao may enhance the tendency of these patients to develop ARDS.
The mechanisms by which PMN Ao is suppressed after injury are still unknown. It is probably in part inhibited by soluble factors. Several studies have attempted to correlate circulating and BALF cytokine levels with risk of ARDS, systemic inflammatory response syndrome, or multiple organ failure. Bronchoalveolar lavage fluid levels of G-CSF, GM-CSF, IL-8, IL-6, ENA-78, and growth-related oncogene-α are all significantly elevated in patients with ARDS after trauma, intra-abdominal sepsis, or pneumonia.2- 6 Survival after ARDS is typically associated with a rapid reduction in BALF cytokine levels, whereas persistent elevations portend a poor outcome.3
Plasma from patients with systemic inflammatory response syndrome and major burns suppresses Ao of normal cultured PMNs.9,12 Neutralization of GM-CSF in burn plasma suppresses this antiapoptotic effect.9 Similarly, BALF from patients with ARDS inhibits normal PMN Ao when compared with volunteer lavage fluid.9 This effect can be blocked by immunodepleting BALF of G-CSF and GM-CSF,8 the alveolar levels of which are greatly increased in ARDS.8 High levels of G-CSF and GM-CSF (G-CSF>>GM-CSF) have also been isolated from the supernatants of colonic mucosal specimens taken from patients with inflammatory bowel disease.13 These supernatants inhibited normal PMN Ao in vitro, an effect that could be abrogated with preincubation of the supernatants with an anti–G-CSF mAb (but not with anti–GM-CSF mAb). Thus, high levels of proinflammatory cytokines such as G-CSF and GM-CSF within inflammatory foci in the lung and bowel may potentiate PMN-mediated tissue injury in ARDS and inflammatory bowel disease, respectively, by suppressing normal PMN Ao.
The GM-CSF is a proinflammatory cytokine produced by several cell types such as monocytes,14 activated eosinophils,15 T lymphocytes,16 and even pulmonary fibroblasts.17 It supervises the maturation process of granulocyte and monocyte progenitors.18 Several of the biological activities of mature PMNs are also modulated by GM-CSF, which acts mainly by priming PMNs and making them more receptive to activation by secondary stimuli.
While the effects of GM-CSF on PMN function are well known, the underlying mechanisms by which GM-CSF works are poorly understood. The GM-CSF receptor is a high-affinity receptor composed of 2 subunits, α and β.19 The β subunit, which is unique to the GM-CSF receptor, is thought to serve mainly as a binding site for GM-CSF.20 It may also contribute to signaling. The α subunit, however, has a larger intracytoplasmic tail and is believed to be critically involved in GM-CSF–mediated signaling.21 The GM-CSF signal transduction seems, in part, to involve cytoplasmic tyrosine kinases (eg, Lyn).22 The physical coupling of the Lyn kinase to the GM-CSF receptor seems to be central to the inhibition of PMN Ao.23 It is unknown how kinase activation signals the inhibition of PMN Ao. It seems, likely, however, that alterations in the expression of members of the Bcl-2 family of proteins (eg, Mcl-1, Bcl-2, A-1, Bcl-x[L], Bad, Bak, Bcl-x[S] and Bax) lead to inhibition of Ao through the maintenance of normal mitochondrial function and the suppression of cytochrome c release into the cytosol. Cytochrome c, if released into the cytosol, binds the protein Apaf-1: this complex activates the first member (caspase 9) of a cascade of cytosolic proteases (caspases), all of which act through the cleavage of vital cellular proteins both within the cytoplasm and nucleus.24 Induction of Mcl-1, Bcl-2, A-1, and Bcl-x(L) suppresses Ao, whereas Bad, Bak, Bcl-x(S) and Bax all promote cell death.25 The GM-CSF receptor may act through tyrosine kinase activation to alter the equilibrium between antiapoptotic and proapoptotic members of the Bcl-2 family of proteins: this would then stabilize mitochondrial function, suppress cytosolic cytochrome c release, and prevent caspase activation.
The caspases are all homologous to ced-3, a cell death gene described in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. The first mammalian homologue of ced-3 to be identified was IL-1β converting enzyme.25 The caspases have been grouped according to sequence homology as being either IL-1β converting enzyme–like proteases (caspases 1, 4, and 5) or ced-3–ones like (caspases 3, 6, 7, 9, and 10). They are all synthesized as inactive proenzymes that are activated by proteolytic cleavage. Casapse-3 has been implicated as a key enzyme that is activated during the early stages of Ao.24 Active casapse-3, found only in cells undergoing Ao, consists of a heterodimer of 17- and 12-kd subunits, which are derived from the 32-kd proenzyme. The active enzyme cleaves and activates other caspases, as well as relevant targets in the cytoplasm (eg, actin)26 and nucleus (eg, poly[adenosine diphosphate-ribose] polymerase).26 Thus, the caspase cascade triggers the DNA, cytoskeletal and membrane changes characteristic of Ao. No studies have yet demonstrated a correlation between risk of inflammatory complications (eg, ARDS) after major trauma and level of PMN caspase activity in humans. Watson et al,27 however, have shown in a small animal model of lipopolysaccharide-induced acute lung injury that depressed levels of Ao seen in inflammatory PMNs obtained from BALF are associated with decreased levels of caspase-1 and caspase-9. We have also recently shown that normal PMNs incubated in ARDS plasma for 12 hours show a 30% reduction in caspase-3 activity when compared with similar cells incubated in normal plasma (Elliot R. Goodman, MD, unpublished data, August 1999). The effect of manipulating GM-CSF receptor activity on caspase-3 is still unknown, but these preliminary findings do suggest that those antiapoptotic factors present in ARDS plasma appear to act early on in the sequence of cellular events culminating in PMN Ao.
As with our previous study,7 we obtained plasma samples from a highly selective group of severely traumatized patients with fulminant ARDS developing early after injury in the absence of sepsis (presumably due to a global ischemia-reperfusion phenomenon). Once again, the high Injury Severity Score (mean=22) portended a high mortality (36%). Our previous data demonstrated that soluble antiapoptotic factors exist in E/F ARDS plasma that inhibit spontaneous Ao in normal PMNs in vitro.7 This antiapoptotic effect of ARDS plasma appears to be (at least partially) mediated by the GM-CSF receptor. It occurs at both low levels of plasma GM-CSF and low surface expression of GM-CSF receptor. Ligation of GM-CSF has no effect on PMN Ao in ARDS plasma. We have also observed no effect of even very high levels (50,000 pg/mL) of GM-CSF on normal PMN Ao in plasma-free medium.
These data suggest that the antiapoptotic effect of ARDS plasma is not mediated by simple blockade of GM-CSF ligand-receptor interaction. Rather, it seems that cross-linking of GM-CSF receptors with mAb activates the apoptotic cascade, perhaps via kinase suppression and alterations in the activity of certain members of the Bcl-2 protein family. Ligation of the receptor with mAb had no effect on PMN Ao in control plasma. Normal plasma might therefore either lack an endogenous factor that potentiates receptor cross-linking in ARDS plasma or might contain a factor that suppresses cross-linking and that is absent in ARDS plasma. These findings are, obviously, in contrast to most other published results, which have shown abrogation of the antiapoptotic effect of both burns plasma and ARDS BALF with neutralization of GM-CSF activity with mAb.8,9 The reasons for the discrepancy in findings are unknown. Related work on the control of eosinophil Ao has recently shown that the GM-CSF analogue E21R, which selectively binds to the α-chain of the GM-CSF receptor (as did the mAb used in our study), stimulates Ao even in the absence of detectable endogenous GM-CSF messenger RNA or protein.28 These results, like ours, indicate that induction of Ao can occur through mechanisms other than interruption of the normal binding of GM-CSF to its receptor.
In conclusion, plasma of patients with ARDS after major trauma inhibits PMN Ao through a pathway mediated by the GM-CSF receptor. This effect occurs at both low levels of plasma GM-CSF and surface expression of GM-CSF receptor. Ligation of the α-chain of the GM-CSF receptor with mAb triggers PMN Ao in ARDS plasma. Ligation of GM-CSF has no effect on PMN Ao in ARDS plasma, suggesting that PMN Ao is augmented by receptor cross-linking by mAb rather than simple blockade of ligand-receptor interaction. The GM-CSF, even at very high doses, has no effect on PMN Ao in plasma-free medium, confirming that regulation of PMN Ao may occur through mechanisms other than modulation of GM-CSF binding to its receptor. These results provide the theoretical basis for anti–GM-CSF receptor mAb manipulation of PMN Ao as a novel modality of treatment for posttraumatic ARDS.
Presented at the 19th Annual Meeting of the Surgical Infection Society, Seattle, Wash, April 29th, 1999.
Activated PMNs are widely accepted as key mediators of posttraumatic ARDS. Proinflamatory cytokines such as GM-CSF prime PMNs, thereby making them more receptive to activation by secondary stimuli. Cytokines also help to regulate PMN function by modulating the apoptotic elimination of PMNs within inflammatory foci. Changes in cytokine production within the peripheral circulation and lung after major trauma can lead to a suppression of PMN Ao, the abnormal persistence of activated PMNs, and the exaggerated production of reactive oxygen intermediates and proteases within inflammatory foci. Under these conditions, PMN activity is transformed from a controlled and beneficial antimicrobial function to an excessive and autodestructive phenomenon, which can produce the lung damage associated with ARDS.
If alterations in the normal equilibrium of cytokine activity in the plasma and lung are responsible for the abnormal persistence of activated PMNs in tissues such as the lung after major trauma, therapies aimed at restoring this equilibrium may help to reduce a patient's risk of posttraumatic ARDS. Because previous studies have shown that GM-CSF is present at high concentrations in the lungs of patients with ARDS, our study aimed to demonstrate that GM-CSF is an important modulator of PMN apoptosis in vitro. Furthermore, we wished to see whether neutralization of GM-CSF activity in ARDS plasma could restore normal patterns of PMN Ao. Our results provide the theoretical basis for anti–GM-CSF receptor monoclonal antibody manipulation of PMN Ao as a novel modality of treatment for posttraumatic ARDS.
Corresponding author: Elliot R. Goodman, MD, Department of Surgery, Montefiore Medical Center, 111 E 210th St, Bronx, NY 10467 (e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org).
Ori D. Rotstein, MD, Toronto, Ontario: The authors test the now popular hypothesis that persistent systemic inflammation in the critically ill patient might be related to delayed apoptosis of the critical injurious cell, the neutrophil. They show that drawing plasma from patients 24 hours after major trauma delays apoptosis of normal donor neutrophils. They suggest a role of granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) in this effect based on the ability of anti–GM-CSF receptor antibody to reverse the inhibition. Curiously, neutralization of plasma GM-CSF did not have a similar effect, levels of GMCSF in patient plasma were undetectable, GM-CSF receptors were virtually undetectable, and GM-CSF itself had no effect at any concentration studied. They conclude a role for GM-CSF and its receptor in modulating apoptosis and suggest GM-CSF receptor antagonism as a potential novel therapy. I have 3 questions.
First, the authors' main finding relates to the reversal of the antiapoptotic effect with the monoclonal antibody directed against the receptor. Did the investigators control for this nonspecific effect by using an irrelevant antibody?
Second, endotoxin also inhibits apoptosis. What evidence do the authors have that the effect is not due to endotoxin in the trauma patient serum? Have they heated the serum? Have they used specific antibodies to deplete the endotoxin?
And finally, the authors suggest that cross-linking the GM-CSF receptor may exert an effect directly, thus acting more as a modulator of the antiapoptotic effect of plasma than implicating a role for GM-CSF as the inhibitor. Did engagement of the receptor with GM-CSF alter the effect of patient plasma on spontaneous apoptosis? Did it have an effect on Fas-induced apoptosis?
Dr Goodman: I would join Dr Rotstein in being very puzzled by the fact that whereas we were able to inhibit the apoptosis binding the receptor, we couldn't do the same thing by binding the GM-CSF itself. We didn't look at the irrelevant antibody, nor did we look at endotoxin. What we are hoping to do is to answer the question whether this is a crosslinking phenomenon by looking at F(ab‘)2 fragments of the antireceptor antibody, which would not be able to crosslink receptors, and seeing whether we can get a different effect or whether it is the same effect. Although it is a very good idea, we haven't looked at Fas-induced apoptosis, but that obviously is a good question to ask.
Cynthia Ogle, PhD, Cincinnati, Ohio: In the transplant world, OKT3, when you treat lymphocytes with that, you get a TNF release. When you treat your neutrophil with an anti–GM-CSF receptor, do you get any other cytokine release or any stimulation of your neutrophil?
Dr Goodman: We haven't looked at cytokine production, but, again, that would be something to look into.