[Skip to Content]
Access to paid content on this site is currently suspended due to excessive activity being detected from your IP address Please contact the publisher to request reinstatement.
Sign In
Individual Sign In
Create an Account
Institutional Sign In
OpenAthens Shibboleth
[Skip to Content Landing]
April 1969

Villous Adenomas of the Colon, Benign or Malignant?

Author Affiliations

From the Department of Surgery, University of Nebraska College of Medicine (Drs. Olson and Davis), and the Surgical Service, Veterans Administration Hospital, (Dr. Davis), Omaha.

Arch Surg. 1969;98(4):487-492. doi:10.1001/archsurg.1969.01340100119016

"When a thing ceases to be a subject of controversy, it ceases to be a subject of interest." William Hazlitt, 1830

Controversy exists over the definition, nature, diagnosis, and treatment of villous adenomas of the colon. We have analyzed our experience and reviewed the reports of others hoping to answer some of these questions. Our study included 97 patients from the University of Nebraska Hospitals and 1,330 patients reported in the English language. As a result, we accept some old ideas, question others, and introduce a new concept of treatment.

Method and Material  It was our purpose to review our experience with clinically benign villous adenomas. We considered clinically benign those villous adenomas of the colon showing no evidence of induration, ulceration, or metastases by history and physical examination, sigmoidoscopy, barium enema, and x-ray film studies of the chest.In order to find the patients with villous adenomas, we had

Sunderland, D.A., and Binkley, G.E.:  Papillary Adenomas of the Large Intestine: Clinical and Morphological Study of 48 Cases , Cancer 1:184-207 ( (July) ) 1948.Article
Earle, J., et al:  Discussion on Pathology and Treatment of Nonmalignant Tumors of Rectum and Colon , Proc Roy Soc Med 45:685-700 ( (Oct) ) 1952.
Welch, CE.; McKittrick, J.B.; and Behringer, G.:  Polyps of the Rectum and Colon and Their Relation to Cancer , New Eng J Med 247:959-965 ( (Dec 18) ) 1952.Article
Fisher, E.R., and Castro, A.F.:  Diffuse Papillomatous Polyps (Villous Tumors) of Colon and Rectum , Amer J Surg 85:146-151 ( (Feb) ) 1953.Article
Bacon, H.E.; Lowell, E.J., Jr.; and Trimpi, A.D.:  Villous Papillomas of Colon and Rectum , Surgery 35:77-87 ( (Jan) ) 1954.
Thiele, G.H., in discussion, Hines, M.O.; Hanley, P.H.; and Schramel, R.:  Villous Tumors of Colon and Rectum: Clinical Experience With 37 Cases , Southern Med J 48:891-897 ( (Sept) ) 1955.
Freund, N.L.:  Villous Tumors of the Rectum , Amer J Surg 90:873-876 ( (Nov) ) 1955.Article
Moran, T.F.:  Surgical Treatment of Villous Tumors of the Rectum , J Int Coll Surg 28:227-233 ( (Aug) ) 1957.
Wheat, M.W., and Ackerman, L.V.:  Villous Adenomas of the Large Intestine , Ann Surg 147:476-487 ( (April) ) 1958.Article
Grinnell, R.S., and Lane, N.:  Benign and Malignant Adenomatous Polyps and Papillary Adenomas of the Colon and Rectum Int Abstr Surg 106:519-538 ( (June) ) 1958.
Welch, J.S., and Dockerty, M.B.:  Villous Carcinoma of the Colon , Dis Colon Rectum , 1:251-261 ( (July) -Aug) 1958.Article
Smith, W.T.:  Villous Papillomas of the Rectum: A Review of 25 Cases , Minn Med 43:106-108 ( (Feb) ) 1960.
Enterline, H.T., et al:  Malignant Potential of Adenomas of Colon and Rectum , JAMA 179:322-330 ( (Feb 3) ) 1962.Article
Hanley, P.H., et al:  Villous Tumors: Experience With 163 Patients , Southern Med J 55:233-238 ( (March) ) 1962.Article
Harp, R.A.; Waugh, J.M.; and Dockerty, M.B.:  Noninfiltrating Villous Colonic Tumors , Dis Colon Rectum 5:121-133 ( (March) -April) 1962.Article
Dreese, W.C., et al:  Villous Tumors of the Rectum and Sigmoid , Surg Gynec Obstet 115:182-186 ( (Aug) ) 1962.
Boling, E., and Finch, H.:  Villous Tumors of the Colon and Rectum , Amer Surg 29:413-417 ( (June) ) 1963.
Cram, R.W., and Bond, A.F.:  Malignant Polyps of the Colon , Canad J Surg 7:378-382 ( (Oct) ) 1964.
Derjanecz, J.J., and Clark, C.W.:  Papillary Adenomas of the Colon and Rectum: Clinical and Pathologic Behavior , Canad J Surg 7:389-396 ( (Oct) ) 1964.
Ramirez, R.F., et al:  Villous Tumors of the Lower Part of the Large Bowel , JAMA 194:863-867 ( (Nov 22) ) 1965.Article
Porter, S.D., and Liechty, R.D.:  Villous Adenoma in 108 Patients , Amer J Surg 116:13-16 ( (July) ) 1968.Article
Starr, A.; Mueller, S.; and McKittrick, J.R.:  Villous Adenomas of the Colon Associated With Severe Hypopotassemia , Arch Surg 73:995-998 ( (Dec) ) 1956.Article
Davis, J.E.; Seavey, R.W.; and Sessions, J.T., Jr.:  Villous Adenoma of Rectum and Sigmoid Colon With Severe Fluid and Electrolyte Depletion , Ann Surg 155:806-816 ( (May) ) 1962.Article
Nicoloff, D.M.; Ellis, CM.; and Humphrey, E.W.:  Management of Villous Adenomas of the Colon and Rectum , Arch Surg 97:254-260 ( (Aug) ) 1968.Article
Rider, J.A., et al:  Polyps of the Colon and Rectum, Their Incidence and Relationship to Carcinoma , Amer J Med 16:555-564 ( (April) ) 1954.Article
Spratt, J.S., Jr.; Ackerman, L.V.; and Moyer, C.A.:  Relationship of Polyps of the Colon to Colonic Cancer , Ann Surg 148:682-698 ( (Oct) ) 1958.Article