[Skip to Content]
Sign In
Individual Sign In
Create an Account
Institutional Sign In
OpenAthens Shibboleth
[Skip to Content Landing]
Article
March 1977

Use of Systemic Antibiotics for Prophylaxis in SurgeryA Critical Review

Author Affiliations

From the Infectious Disease Service, Buffalo General Hospital, and the Departments of Surgery and Medicine, State University of New York at Buffalo.

Arch Surg. 1977;112(3):326-334. doi:10.1001/archsurg.1977.01370030098018
Abstract

• We reviewed the English-language literature over a 16-year period (1960 through 1976) on the subject of prophylaxis with systemic antibiotics in surgery. Trials in genitourinary and cardiovascular surgery were not reviewed. Our definition of prophylaxis is antibiotic administration in the absence of infection or contamination. Of 131 articles reporting clinical trials using systemic antibiotics for prophylaxis, only 24 met the criterion of an appropriately designed study that generated evaluable data. In these, systemic antibiotics were shown to be of value in reducing wound infections after abdominal and vaginal hysterectomy, cesarean section, biliary surgery, total hip replacement, and microneurosurgical craniotomy. Antibiotic prophylaxis was of no value in laparotomy and groin hernia repair. Patients undergoing any of 21 different operations did not benefit from prophylactic antibiotic administration, though study groups were too small or infection rates too low to allow for firm conclusions. In certain patients at high risk of infection, systemic prophylaxis is warranted. Future clinical studies must be designed as randomized, blinded, prospective trials, with antibiotics administered by a parenteral route beginning preoperatively.

(Arch Surg 112: 326-334, 1977)

References
1.
Davidson A, Clark C, Smith G:  Postoperative wound infection: A computer analysis . Br J Surg 58:333, 1971.Article
2.
Postoperative wound infections:  The influence of ultraviolet irradiation of the operating room and of various other factors, Committee on Trauma, Division of Medical Sciences, National Academy of Sciences, National Research Council . Ann Surg 160( (suppl) ):11, 1964.
3.
Tally F, Gorbach S:  Antibiotics in surgery . Adv Surg 9:41, 1975.
4.
Armstrong D, Smith R:  Prophylactic antibiotics in surgery . Clin Bull 4:97, 1974.
5.
Brumfitt W, Hamilton-Miller J:  The place of antibiotic prophylaxis in medicine . J Antimicrob Agents Chemother 1:163, 1975.Article
6.
Condon R:  Rational use of prophylactic antibiotics in gastrointestinal surgery . Surg Clin North Am 55:1309, 1975.
7.
Maclean L:  Prophylactic antibiotic therapy in surgery . Can J Surg 18:243-247, 1975.
8.
Meares E:  Factors that influence surgical wound infections: Role of prophylactic antibiotic therapy . Urology 6:535, 1975.Article
9.
Petersdorf R, Browder A:  Protection against infection in susceptible individuals . J Pediatr 58:174, 1961.Article
10.
Strong M:  Wound infection in otolaryngolic surgery and the expediency of antibiotic prophylaxis . Laryngoscope 73:165, 1963.
11.
Hunt G, Alexander J, Burke J, et al:  Antibiotics in surgery . Arch Surg 110:148-155, 1975.Article
12.
Polk H:  The prophylaxis of infection following operative procedures . J Ky Med Assoc ( (March) ):134, 1974.
13.
Burke J:  Effective period of preventive antibiotic action in experimental incisions and dermal lesions . Surgery 50:161, 1961.
14.
Alexander J:  Prophylaxis of experimental wound infections . Surg Gynecol Obstet 120:243, 1965.
15.
Bernard H, Cole W:  The prophylaxis of surgical infection: The effect of prophylactic antimicrobial drugs on incidence of infection following potentially contaminated wounds . Surgery 56:151, 1964.
16.
Boyd A, Burke J, Colton T:  A double-blind clinical trial of prophylactic antibiotics in hip fractures . J Bone Joint Surg 55A:1251, 1973.
17.
Evans C, Pollock A:  Reduction of surgical wound infections by prophylactic parenteral cephaloridine . Br J Surg 60:434, 1973.Article
18.
Hughes E, Hardy K, Cuthbertson A, et al:  Chemoprophylaxis in large bowel surgery: Effect of intravenous administration of penicillin on incidence of postoperative infection . Med J Aust 1:305, 1970.
19.
Keighley M, Baddeley R, Burdon D, et al:  A controlled trial of parenteral prophylactic gentamicin therapy in biliary surgery . Br J Surg 62:275, 1975.Article
20.
Karl R, Mertz J, Veith F, et al:  Prophylactic antimicrobial drugs in surgery . N Engl J Med 275:305, 1966.Article
21.
Pollock A, Tindal D:  Effect of a single-dose parenteral antibiotic in prevention of wound infection . Br J Surg 59:98, 1972.Article
22.
Polk H, Lopez-Mayor J:  Post-operative wound infections: A prophylactic study of determinant factors and prevention . Surgery 66:97, 1969.
23.
Pavel A, Smith R, Ballard A, et al:  Prophylactic antibiotics in clean orthopedic surgery . J Bone Joint Surg 56:532, 1974.
24.
Eschelman L, Schleuning A, Brummett R:  Prophylactic antibiotics in otolaryngologic surgery: A double-blind study . Am Acad Ophthalmol 75:387, 1971.
25.
Dor P, Klastersky J:  Prophylactic antibiotics in oral, pharyngeal and laryngeal surgery for cancer . Laryngoscope 83:1992, 1973.Article
26.
Griffiths D, Simpson R, Shorey B, et al:  Single-dose preoperative antibiotic prophylaxis in gastrointestinal surgery . Lancet 2:325, 1976.Article
27.
Neu H:  Antimicrobial agents: Mechanism of action and clinical usage . Curr Probi Surg 1-64, (June) 1973.
28.
Caldwell J, Cluff L:  Adverse reactions to antimicrobial agents . JAMA 230:77, 1974.Article
29.
Bennett J, Scheckler W, Maki O: Current patterns of nosocomial infections in the United States. Proceedings of the International Conference on Nosocomial Infections, 1971.
30.
Johanson W, Pierce A, Sanford J:  Nosocomial respiratory infections with Gram-negative bacilli: The significance of colonization of the respiratory tract . Ann Intern Med 77:701, 1972.Article
31.
Rose H, Bobcock J:  Colonization of intensive care unit patients with Gram-negative bacilli . Am J Epidemiol 101:495, 1975.
32.
Rose H, Schreier J:  The effect of hospitalization and antibiotic therapy on the Gram-negative fecal flora . Am J Med Sci 255:228, 1968.Article
33.
Selden R, Lee S, Wang W, et al:  Nosocomial Klebsiella infections: Intestinal colonization as a reservoir . Ann Intern Med 74:657-664, 1971.Article
34.
Ericson C, Lidgren L, Lindberg L:  Cloxacillin in prophylaxis of postoperative infections of the hip . J Bone Joint Surg 55A:808, 1973.
35.
Azar H, Drapanas T:  Relationship of antibiotics to wound infections and enterocolitis in colon surgery . Am J Surg 115:209, 1968.Article
36.
Bloom S:  Combined carbenicillin and gentamicin for prophylaxis of postoperative infection following major abdominal surgery . Postgrad Med J 45:761, 1969.Article
37.
Day T:  Controlled trial of prophylactic antibiotics in minor wounds requiring suture . Lancet 2:1174-1178, 1975.Article
38.
Jackson C, Amstey M:  Prophylactic ampicillin therapy for vaginal hysterectomy . Surg Gynecol Obstet 141:755, 1975.
39.
Johnstone F:  An assessment of prophylactic antibiotics in general surgery . Surg Gynecol Obstet 116:1, 1963.
40.
Ketcham A, Bloch J, Crawford D, et al:  The role of prophylactic antibiotic therapy in control of staphylococcal infections following cancer surgery . Surg Gynecol Obstet 114:345, 1962.
41.
Lacy S, Drach G, Cox C:  Incidence of infection after prostatectomy and efficacy of cephaloridine prophylaxis . J Urol 105:836, 1971.
42.
Longland C, Gray J, Lees W, et al:  Prevention of infection in appendectomy wounds . Br J Surg 58:117, 1971.Article
43.
Naito H, Toya S, Schizawa H, et al:  High incidence of acute post-operative meningitis and septicemia in patients undergoing craniotomy with ventriculateral shunt . Surg Gynecol Obstet 137:810, 1973.
44.
Okubadejo O, Peet T, Turner D:  Clindamycin prophylaxis in appendectomy wound infections , in Williams J, Greddes A (eds): Chemotherapy . New York, Plenum Press Inc, 1976, p 287.
45.
Olix M, Klug T, Coleman C, et al:  Prophylactic penicillin and streptomycin in elective operations in bones, joints, and tendons . Surg Forum 10:818, 1960.
46.
Parsonnet V:  The relationship of postoperative antibiotics to the development of wound infections: A nine-year study of 6468 major operations . J Newark Beth Israel Hosp 13:83, 1962.
47.
Rocha H:  Postoperative wound infection: A controlled trial of antibiotic prophylaxis . Arch Surg 85:456, 1962.Article
48.
Schonholtz G, Borgia C, Blair J:  Wound sepsis in orthopedic surgery . J Bone Joint Surg 44A:1548, 1962.
49.
Stone H, Hester T:  Incisional and peritoneal infection after emergency celiotomy . Ann Surg 177:669, 1973.Article
50.
Wright R:  A survey of possible etiologic agents in postoperative craniotomy infections . J Neurosurg 25:125, 1966.Article
51.
Altemeier W:  Prevention of infection in colon surgery . J R Coll Surg 11:271, 1966.
52.
Barnes B, Behringer G, Wheelock F, et al:  Surgical sepsis: Report on subtotal gastrectomy . JAMA 173:1068, 1960.Article
53.
Bridoux M:  Pre-operative use of antibiotics in colonic surgery . Dis Colon Rectum 17:487, 1974.Article
54.
Chen C, Smink R, Shearburn E:  Use or abuse of antibiotics in surgery of the colon . Surg Clin North Am 53:603, 1973.
55.
Chetlin S, Elliott D:  Biliary bacteremia . Arch Surg 102:303-307, 1971.Article
56.
Clement J:  Prophylactic antibiotics in hysterectomy . NC Med J 9:542, 1975.
57.
Dineen P:  A critical study of 100 consecutive wound infections . Surg Gynecol Obstet 113:91, 1961.
58.
Fikri E, McAdams A:  Wound infection in colonic surgery . Ann Surg 182:724, 1975.Article
59.
Fullen W, Hunt J, Altemeier W:  Prophylactic antibiotics in penetrating wounds of the abdomen . J Trauma 12:282, 1972.Article
60.
Horwitz N, Curtin J:  Prophylactic antibiotics and wound infections following laminectomy for lumbar disc herniation . J Neurosurg 43:727, 1975.Article
61.
Kingsley D:  Some observations on appendicectomy with particular reference to technique . Br J Surg 56:491, 1969.Article
62.
Rosenheim G:  Prophylactic antibiotics in elective abdominal hysterectomy . Am J Obstet Gynecol 119:335, 1974.
63.
Stevens D:  Postoperative orthopedic infections . J Bone Joint Surg 46A:100, 1964.
64.
Vinnicombe J:  Appendectomy, wound infection, drainage and antibiotics . Br J Surg 51:328, 1964.Article
65.
Wyler A, Kelly W:  Use of antibiotics with external ventric ulostomies . J Neurosurg 37:185, 1972.Article
66.
Amstutz H:  Prevention of operative infection . Cleve Clin Quart 40:125, 1973.Article
67.
Arana V, Mueller R:  Abdominal surgery in cancer patients without wound complications . J Surg Oncol 4:42, 1972.Article
68.
Bernard H, Clark W, Leather R:  Chemoprophylaxis of post-operative surgical infection . Arch Surg 99:388-390, 1969.Article
69.
Bernard H, Cole W, Gravens D, et al:  Chemoprophylaxis of post-operative surgical infection . Arch Surg 96:476-482, 1968.Article
70.
Bevan P, Williams J:  Rifamide in acute cholecystitis and biliary surgery . Br Med J 3:284, 1971.Article
71.
Bryant L, Dillon M, Mobin-Uddin K:  Prophylactic antibiotics in medicine . Antimicrob Agents Chemother 1:163, 1975.Article
72.
Burton R:  Post-operative wound infection in colonic and rectal surgery . Br J Surg 60:363, 1973.Article
73.
Carey J, Hughes R:  Control of infection after thoracic and cardiovascular surgery . Ann Surg 172:916, 1970.Article
74.
Dillon M, Postlethwait R:  Pre- and postoperative prophylactic use of cephaloridine . Am J Surg 122:61, 1971.Article
75.
Donaldson J, Snyder I:  Prophylactic chemotherapy in myringoplasty surgery . Laryngoscope 76:1201, 1966.Article
76.
Feltis J, Hamit H:  Use of prophylactic antimicrobial drugs to prevent postoperative wound infections . Am J Surg 114:867, 1967.Article
77.
Fogelberg E, Zitzmann E, Stinchfield F:  Prophylactic penicillin in orthopedic surgery . J Bone Joint Surg 52A:95, 1970.
78.
Fry W:  Vascular prosthesis infection . Surg Clin North Am 52:1419, 1972.
79.
Goldstone J, Moore W:  Infection in vascular prosthesis . Am J Surg 128:225, 1974.Article
80.
Green J:  How to reduce morbidity and mortality in colon surgery . Geriatrics 30:60, 1975.
81.
Hansen J, Ericksen K:  Postoperative infection in thoracic surgery . Acta Chir Scand 128:698, 1964.
82.
Hejhal L, Hejhal J, Firt P, et al:  Value of prophylactic antibiotic therapy in vascular reconstruction . J Cardiovasc Surg 7:344, 1966.
83.
Jebsen O, Larsen S, Thomsen V:  Post-operative wound sepsis in general surgery . Acta Chir Scand (suppl) 396:91, 1969.
84.
Jones D, Warth R, Easter M:  Prophylactic antibiotics in major gynecologic surgery . Milit Med 140:479, 1975.
85.
Ledger W, Gee C, Lewis W:  Guidelines for antibiotic prophylaxis in gynecology . Am J Obstet Gynecol 121:1038, 1975.
86.
Leonard J:  Prophylactic antibiotics in human stapedectomy . Laryngoscope 77:663, 1967.
87.
Maclean L, Goldstein M, MacDonald J, et al:  Results of cholicystectomy in 1000 surgical patients . Can J Surg 18:459, 1975.
88.
Maguire W:  The use of antibiotics locally and systemically in orthopedic surgery . Med J Aust 2:412, 1964.
89.
Marks G, Rodgers J, Moses M:  Clinical effectiveness of intravenous doxycycline: Treatment and prevention of surgical infections of the gastrointestinal tract . Curr Ther Res 18:460, 1975.
90.
Mason G:  Bacteriology and antibiotic selection in biliary tract surgery . Arch Surg 97:533-537, 1968.Article
91.
Miller W, Counts G:  Orthopedic infections: A prospective study of 378 clean procedures . South Med J 68:386, 1975.Article
92.
Miller R, Crichton D:  Ampicillin prophylaxis in cesarean section . S Afr J Obstet Gynecol 6:69, 1968.
93.
O'Riordan C, Adler J, Banks H, et al:  A prospective study of wound infections on an orthopedic service . Clin Orthop 87:188, 1972.
94.
Paterson J, Cardo V, Stratigos G:  An examination of antibiotic prophylaxis in oral and maxillofacial surgery . J Oral Surg 28:753, 1970.
95.
Perdue G:  Antibiotics as an aid in the prevention of infections after peripheral arterial surgery . Am Surg 41:296, 1975.
96.
Polacek M, Sanfelippo P:  Oral antibiotic bowel preparation and complications in colon surgery . Arch Surg 97:412-417, 1968.Article
97.
Pyrtek L, Bartus S:  An evaluation of antibiotics in biliary tract surgery . Surg Gynecol Obstet 125:101, 1967.
98.
Scales J, Roantree B, Towers A:  Influence of antibiotic therapy on wound inflammation and sepsis associated with orthopedic implant: A long-term survey . Proc R Soc Med 64:639, 1971.
99.
Scher S:  Antibiotic administration in surgical patients at increased risk of infection: A comparison of carbenicillin and cephalothin . Curr Ther Res 18:452, 1975.
100.
Singh H:  Prevention of infection in patients undergoing total hip replacement . J Int Med Assoc 60:a291, 1973.
101.
Stone H, Kolb L, Gerber C:  Incidence and significance of intraperitoneal anaerobic bacteria . Am Surg 181:705, 1975.
102.
Todd R, Lightwolen C, Harris J:  Total hip replacement in osteoarthrosis using the Charnley prosthesis . Br Med J 2:752, 1972.Article
103.
Washington J, Everback L, Dearing W, et al:  Effect of preoperative antibiotic regimen on development of infection after intestinal surgery . Ann Surg 180:568, 1975.
104.
Welch R, Taylor L, Wynne G:  The role of prophylactic antibiotics in total hip replacement surgery . J Bone Joint Surg 56A:195, 1974.
105.
Wilson P, Salvati E, Blumenfeld E:  The problem of infection in total prosthetic arthroplasty of the hip . Surg Clin North Am 55:1431, 1975.
106.
Zallen R, Curry J:  A study of antibiotic usage in compound fractures . J Oral Surg 33:431, 1975.
107.
Cowling D:  Comment on a surgical wound infection survey at the Royal Welbourne Hospital . Med J Aust 1:923, 1962.
108.
Burton R, Hughes E, Cuthbertson A:  Prophylactic use of gentamicin in colonic and rectal surgery . Med J Aust 2:597, 1975.
109.
Citron K:  Controlled trial of prophylactic penicillin in thoracic surgery . Thorax 20:18, 1965.Article
110.
Gibbs R, Decherney A, Schwartz R:  Prophylactic antibiotics in cesarean section: A double-blind study . Am J Obstet Gynecol 114:1048, 1972.
111.
Goosenberg J, Emich J, Schwartz R:  Prophylactic antibiotic in vaginal hysterectomy . Am J Obstet Gynecol 105:503, 1969.
112.
Hodgson J, Major B, Portmann K, et al:  Prophylactic use of tetracycline for first trimester abortions . Obstet Gynecol 45:574, 1975.
113.
Morrison J, Coxwell W, Fish S, et al:  Use of prophylactic antibiotics in patients undergoing cesarean section . Surg Gynecol Obstet 136:425, 1973.
114.
Suri D, Johnston D:  Prophylactic role of cephaloridine in surgical wounds . Can J Surg 18:361, 1975.
115.
Thulbourne T, Young M:  Prophylactic penicillin and postoperative chest infections . Lancet 2:907-909, 1962.Article
116.
Alexander J, McCloin J, Altemeier W:  Penicillin prophylaxis in experimental wound infection . Surg Forum 11:299, 1960.
117.
Baker W, Bodensteiner J:  The administration of antibiotics in vascular reconstructive surgery . J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 64:301, 1972.
118.
Bhayana J, Gillespie J, Nolan J, et al:  Prophylactic antibiotics in thoracic surgery: An experimental evaluation . J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 50:868, 1965.
119.
Bowers W, Wilson F, Greene W:  Antibiotic prophylaxis in experimental bone infections . J Bone Joint Surg 55A:795, 1973.
120.
Brient B, Zimmerman J, King T:  Use of prophylactic antibiotics in prolonged hypothermia . Clin Res 13:292, 1965.
121.
Cole W, Bernard H, Lewis E:  Chemoprophylaxis with penicillin . J Surg Res 7:147, 1967.Article
122.
Edlich R, Smith O, Edgerton M:  Resistance of the surgical wound to antimicrobial prophylaxis and its mechanism of development . Am J Surg 126:583, 1973.Article
123.
Gingrass R, Close S, Ellison E:  Effect of various topical and parenteral agents on the prevention of infections in experimentally contaminated wounds . J Trauma 4:763, 1964.Article
124.
Karvounis P, Smith M, Mazapica F, et al:  Antibiotic prevention of experimental staphylococcal meningitis . J Neurosurg 28:45, 1968.Article
125.
Lindenauer S, Fry W, Schaub G, et al:  Use of antibiotics in prevention of vascular graft infections . Surgery 62:487, 1967.
126.
Moore W, Rosson C, Hall A:  Effect of prophylactic antibiotics in preventing bacteremic infection of vascular prosthesis . Surgery 69:825, 1971.
127.
Schurman D, Johnson L, Amstutz H:  Knee joint infections with Staphylococcus aureus and Micrococcus species . J Bone Joint Surg 57A:40-49, 1975.
128.
Weaver J, Middlebrook G:  Experimental penicillin prophylaxis of staphylococcal infection in rabbits . Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 103:108, 1960.Article
129.
Magarey C, Chant A, Rickford C, et al:  Peritoneal drainage and systemic antibiotics after appendectomy . Lancet 2:179-182, 1971.Article
130.
Matolo N, Cohen S, Wolfman E:  Effects of antibiotics on prevention of infection in contaminated abdominal operations . Am Surg 42:123, 1976.
131.
Patzakis M, Harvey J, Ivler D:  The role of antibiotics in the management of open fractures . J Bone Joint Surg 56B:532, 1974.
132.
Rickles J:  Nitrofurantoin sodium as a systemic antibacterial in surgical patients . J Int Coll Surg 43:603, 1965.
133.
Thadepalli H:  Abdominal trauma, anaerobes and antibiotics . Surg Gynecol Obstet 137:270, 1973.
134.
Campbell P:  Large doses of penicillin in prevention of surgical wound infection . Lancet 2:805-810, 1965.Article
135.
Derian D, Green B:  Postoperative wound infections: Five-year review of 1163 consecutive operative orthopedic patients . Am Surg 32:388, 1966.
136.
Lebherz T, Hellman L, Madding R, et al:  Double-blind study of premature rupture of the membranes . Am J Obstet Gynecol 87:218, 1963.
137.
Stokes E, Waterworth P, Watson V, et al:  Short-term routine antibiotic prophylaxis in surgery . Br J Surg 61:739, 1974.Article
138.
Allen J, Rampone J, Wheeless C:  Use of prophylactic antibiotics in elective major gynecologic operations . Obstet Gynecol 39:218, 1972.
139.
Bivens M, Neufeld J, McCarty W:  The prophylactic use of keflex and keflin in vaginal hysterectomy . Am J Obstet Gynecol 122:169, 1975.
140.
Bolling D, Plunkett G:  Prophylactic antibiotics for vaginal hysterectomies . Obstet Gynecol 41:689, 1973.
141.
Breeden J, Mayo J:  Low-dose prophylactic antibiotics in vaginal hysterectomy . Obstet Gynecol 43:379, 1974.
142.
Harralson J, Van Nagell J, Roddick J, et al:  The effect of prophylactic antibiotics on pelvic infection following vaginal hysterectomy . Am J Obstet Gynecol 120:1046, 1974.
143.
Ledger W, Sweet R, Headington J:  Prophylactic cephaloridine in the prevention of postoperative pelvic infections in premenopausal women undergoing vaginal hysterectomy . Am J Obstet Gynecol 115:766, 1973.
144.
Ohm M, Galask R:  The effect of antibiotic prophylaxis in patients undergoing vaginal operations: I. The effect on morbidity . Am J Obstet Gynecol 123:590, 1975.
145.
Gibbs R, Hunt J, Schwartz R:  A follow-up study on prophylactic antibiotics in cesarean section . Am J Obstet Gynecol 17:419, 1973.
146.
Weissberg S, Edwards L, O'Leary J:  Prophylactic antibiotics in cesarean section . Obstet Gynecol 38:292, 1971.
147.
Moro M, Andrews M:  Prophylactic antibiotics in cesarean section . Obstet Gynecol 44:688, 1974.
148.
Rothbard M, Mayer W, Wystepek A, et al:  Prophylactic antibiotics in cesarean section . J Obstet Gynecol 45:421, 1975.
149.
Ketcham A:  Antibiotic prophylaxis in cancer surgery and its value in Staphylococcus carrier patients . Surg Gynecol Obstet 117:1, 1963.
150.
Brown J, Rambo W, Wopen H:  Controlled prospective double-blind evaluation of a prophylactic antibiotic (cephaloridine) in surgery . Antimicrob Agents Chemother , 1969, p 421.
151.
Savitz M, Malis L:  Prophylactic clindamycin for neurosurgical patients . NY State J Med 76:64, 1976.
×