To the Editor.—
While commenting on coffee, tobacco, and cardiovascular disease in a letter to the editor (228:160, 1974), Hickey et al stated that "Pearl, in a prospective study of males, found more survivors among moderate smokers than among nonsmokers or heavy smokers at age 95, and that for five-year subsets increasing from age 70, the mortality rates of moderate smokers were lower than rates for nonsmokers or heavy smokers." This statement is not warranted by the data in Pearl's paper.1Pearl's study was based on 2,094 nonsmokers, 2,814 moderate smokers, and 1,905 heavy smokers. It is true that the death rates for moderate smokers aged 75 and over were slightly smaller than those for nonsmokers and heavy smokers, but the rates were undoubtedly calculated from populations of such small size that the differences could not possibly be statistically significant. Figure 1 in Pearl's paper, based on the calculated
Weiss W. Smoking and Statistical Significance. JAMA. 1974;228(11):1368. doi:10.1001/jama.1974.03230360016003
Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Create a personal account or sign in to: