Methadone Maintenance vs 180-Day Psychosocially Enriched Detoxification for Treatment of Opioid Dependence: A Randomized Controlled Trial | HIV | JAMA | JAMA Network
[Skip to Navigation]
Access to paid content on this site is currently suspended due to excessive activity being detected from your IP address Please contact the publisher to request reinstatement.
 New data shows opiates take lead over cocaine in treatment admission.  US Dept of Health and Human Service News.[serial online]. August 26. 1999. Available at: Accessed February 9, 2000.Google Scholar
Simpson DD, Joe GW, Bracy SA. Six-year follow-up of opioid addicts after admission to treatment.  Arch Gen Psychiatry.1982;39:1318-1323.Google Scholar
Ball JC, Lange WR, Myers CP, Friedman SR. Reducing the risk of AIDS through methadone maintenance.  J Health Soc Behav.1998;29:214-226.Google Scholar
Kosten TR, Gawin FH, Rousaville BJ. Cocaine abuse among opioid addicts: demographic and diagnostic factors in treatment.  Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse.1986;12:1-16.Google Scholar
Wasserman DA, Korcha R, Havassy BE, Hall SM. Factors associated with lapses to heroin use during methadone maintenance.  Drug Alcohol Depend.1998;52:183-192.Google Scholar
Simpson DD, Savage LJ, Lloyd MR. Follow-up evaluation of treatment abuse during 1969 to 1972.  Arch Gen Psychiatry.1979;36:772-780.Google Scholar
Hubbard RL, Rachal JV, Craddock SG, Cavanaugh ER. Treatment Outcome Prospective Study (TOPS): Client Characteristics and Behaviors Before, During, and After TreatmentRockville, Md: National Institute on Drug Abuse; 1984:42-68.
McLellan AT, Kuskner AT, Metzger D.  et al.  The fifth edition of the Addiction Severity Index.  J Subst Abuse Treat.1992;9:199-213.Google Scholar
Resnick R. Methadone detoxification from illicit opiates and methadone maintenance. In: Cooper JR, ed. Research on the Treatment of Narcotic Addiction: State of the Art. Rockville, Md: National Institute on Drug Abuse; 1983:160-171.
Mann AR, Feit MD. An analysis of federal narcotic detoxification policy: implications for rehabilitation.  Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse.1982-1983;9:289-299.Google Scholar
Sorensen JL, Hargreaves WA, Weinberg JA. Withdrawal from heroin in three or six weeks: comparison of LAAM versus methadone.  Arch Gen Psychiatry.1982;39:167-171.Google Scholar
 Not Available  54 Federal Register.8954 (1989)(codified at 21 CFR §291).Google Scholar
McLellan AT, Arndt IO, Metzger DS, Woody GE, O'Brien CP. The effects of psychosocial services in substance abuse treatment.  JAMA.1993;269:1953-1959.Google Scholar
Woody GE, Luborsky L, McLellan AT.  et al.  Psychotherapy for opiate addicts: does it help?  Arch Gen Psychiatry.1983;40:639-645.Google Scholar
Zanis DA, McLellan AT, Cnaan RA, Randall M. Reliability and validity of the Addiction Severity Index with a homeless sample.  J Subst Abuse Treat.1994;11:541-548.Google Scholar
Robins LN, Helzer JE, Croughan JL, Ratcliff KS. National Institute of Mental Health Diagnosis Interview Schedule: its history, characteristics and validity.  Arch Gen Psychiatry.1981;38:381-389.Google Scholar
Burnham M, Karno M, Hough R, Escobar J, Forsythe A. The Spanish Diagnostic Interview Schedule: reliability and comparison with clinical diagnosis.  Arch Gen Psychiatry.1983;40:1189-1196.Google Scholar
Erdman HP, Klein MH, Greist JH.  et al.  A comparison of two computer-administered versions of the NIMH Diagnostic Interview Schedule.  J Psychiatr Res.1992;26:85-95.Google Scholar
Levitan RD, Blouin AG, Navarro JR, Hill J. Validity of the computerized DIS for diagnosing psychiatric inpatients.  Can J Psychiatry.1991;36:728-731.Google Scholar
Metzger D, Woody G, De Philippis D, McLellan AT, O'Brien CP, Platt JJ. Risk factors for needle sharing among methadone-treatment patients.  Am J Psychiatry.1991;148:636-640.Google Scholar
McLellan AT, Alterman AI, Cacciola J, Metzger D, O'Brian CF. A new measure of substance abuse treatment: initial studies of the Treatment Services Review.  J Nerv Ment Dis.1992;180:101-110.Google Scholar
Diggle PJ, Liang WR, Myers CP, Friedman SR. Analysis of Longitudinal DataNew York, NY: Oxford University Press; 1994.
Maude-Griffin PM, Hohenstein JM, Humfleet GL, Reilly PM, Tusel DJ, Hall SM. Superior efficacy of cognitive-behavioral therapy for urban crack cocaine abusers: main and matching effects.  J Consult Clin Psychol.1998;66:832-837.Google Scholar
Carroll KM, Rounsaville BJ, Nich C, Gordon LT, Wirtz PW, Gawin F. One-year follow-up of psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy for cocaine dependence.  Arch Gen Psychiatry.1994;51:989-997.Google Scholar
Crits-Christoph P, Siqueland L, Blaine J.  et al.  Psychosocial treatments for cocaine dependence: National Institute on Drug Abuse collaborative cocaine treatment study.  Arch Gen Psychiatry.1999;56:493-502.Google Scholar
Carroll KM, Rounsaville BJ, Gordon LT.  et al.  Psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy for ambulatory cocaine abusers.  Arch Gen Psychiatry.1994;51:177-187.Google Scholar
Higgins ST, Delaney DD, Budney AJ.  et al.  A behavioral approach to achieving initial cocaine abstinence.  Am J Psychiatry.1991;148:1218-1224.Google Scholar
Original Contribution
March 8, 2000

Methadone Maintenance vs 180-Day Psychosocially Enriched Detoxification for Treatment of Opioid Dependence: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Author Affiliations

Author Affiliations: Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Francisco (Drs Sees, Delucchi, Masson, Rosen, Clark, Banys, and Hall and Ms Robillard), and San Francisco Veterans Affairs Medical Center (Drs Sees and Banys).

JAMA. 2000;283(10):1303-1310. doi:10.1001/jama.283.10.1303

Context Despite evidence that methadone maintenance treatment (MMT) is effective for opioid dependence, it remains a controversial therapy because of its indefinite provision of a dependence-producing medication.

Objective To compare outcomes of patients with opioid dependence treated with MMT vs an alternative treatment, psychosocially enriched 180-day methadone-assisted detoxification.

Design Randomized controlled trial conducted from May 1995 to April 1999.

Setting Research clinic in an established drug treatment service.

Patients Of 858 volunteers screened, 179 adults with diagnosed opioid dependence were randomized into the study; 154 completed 12 weeks of follow-up.

Interventions Patients were randomized to MMT (n = 91), which required 2 hours of psychosocial therapy per week during the first 6 months; or detoxification (n = 88), which required 3 hours of psychosocial therapy per week, 14 education sessions, and 1 hour of cocaine group therapy, if appropriate, for 6 months, and 6 months of (nonmethadone) aftercare services.

Main Outcome Measures Treatment retention, heroin and cocaine abstinence (by self-report and monthly urinalysis), human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) risk behaviors (Risk of AIDS Behavior scale score), and function in 5 problem areas: employment, family, psychiatric, legal, and alcohol use (Addiction Severity Index), compared by intervention group.

Results Methadone maintenance therapy resulted in greater treatment retention (median, 438.5 vs 174.0 days) and lower heroin use rates than did detoxification. Cocaine use was more closely related to study dropout in detoxification than in MMT. Methadone maintenance therapy resulted in a lower rate of drug-related (mean [SD] at 12 months, 2.17 [3.88] vs 3.73 [6.86]) but not sex-related HIV risk behaviors and in a lower severity score for legal status (mean [SD] at 12 months, 0.05 [0.13] vs 0.13 [0.19]). There were no differences between groups in employment or family functioning or alcohol use. In both groups, monthly heroin use rates were 50% or greater, but days of use per month dropped markedly from baseline.

Conclusions Our results confirm the usefulness of MMT in reducing heroin use and HIV risk behaviors. Illicit opioid use continued in both groups, but frequency was reduced. Results do not provide support for diverting resources from MMT into long-term detoxification.