[Skip to Content]
Sign In
Individual Sign In
Create an Account
Institutional Sign In
OpenAthens Shibboleth
Purchase Options:
[Skip to Content Landing]
Article
September 15, 1962

Obesity, Social Class, and Mental Illness

Author Affiliations

Philadelphia; Brooklyn, N.Y.
From the Departments of Psychiatry and Medicine, University of Pennsylvania (Drs. Moore and Stunkard), and the Department of Psychiatry, State University of New York, Downstate Medical Center ( Dr. Srole ).

JAMA. 1962;181(11):962-966. doi:10.1001/jama.1962.03050370030007
Abstract

The relationship between obesity and mental health was investigated, using data obtained from 1,660 persons selected as representative of 110,000 inhabitants of a residential area of New York City. In addition to confirming the previously noted relationship between obesity and age, preliminary analysis revealed a striking relationship between obesity and socioeconomic status of origin. The prevalence of obesity was 7 times higher among women reared in the lowest social class category as compared with those reared in the highest category. Scores made by the obese respondents on 9 mental health indices were compared with scores made by individuals of average weight. The obese respondents made more pathological scores on 8 of the 9 measures and on 3 of these the difference was statistically significant ("immaturity," "rigidity," and "suspiciousness").

References
1.
Bruch, H.:  Importance of Overweight , New York City: W. W. Norton Co., 1957.
2.
Hecht, M.:  Obesity in Women, Psychiatric Study ,  Psychiat Quart 29:203-231 ( (Jan.) ) 1955.Crossref
3.
Huckel, H.:  More Than Bread: 6 Cases of Compulsive Eating ,  Psychoanalysis 4:53-62, 1955.
4.
Fromm, E.:  Dynamics in Case of Obesity ,  J Clin Exp Psychopath 19:292-302 ( (Dec.) ) 1958.
5.
Richardson, H.:  Obesity and Neurosis; Case Report ,  Psychiat Quart 20:400-424 ( (July) ) 1946.
6.
Feiner, A.:  Study of Certain Aspects of Perception of Parental Figures and Sexual Identification of Obese, Adolescent Female Group ,  Amer J Dig Dis 21:298-299 ( (Oct.) ) 1954.Crossref
7.
Friedman, J.:  Weight Problems and Psychological Factors ,  J Counsel Psychol 23:524-527 ( (Dec.) ) 1959.
8.
Fry, P.:  Comparative Study of `Obese' Children Selected on Basis of Fat Pads ,  Amer J Clin Nutr 1:453-467 ( (Sept.) -Oct.) 1953.
9.
Kotkov, B., and Murawski, B.:  Rorschach Study of Personality Structure of Obese Women ,  J Clin Psychol 8:391-396 ( (Oct.) ) 1952.Crossref
10.
Suczek, R.:  Personality of Obese Women ,  Amer J Clin Nutr 5:197-202 ( (March) -April) 1957.
11.
Weinberg, N.; Mendelson, M.; and Stunkard, A.:  Failure to Find Distinctive Personality Features in Group of Obese Men ,  Amer J Psychiat 117:1035-1037 ( (May) ) 1961.
12.
Srole, L. et al.:  Mental Health in the Metropolis: Midtown Manhattan Study , Vol. 1, New York: McGraw-Hill Book Co.; 1962.
13.
Metropolitan Life Insurance Company:  New Weight Standards for Men and Women ,  Statis Bull 40: ( (Nov.) -Dec.) 1959.
14.
Society of Actuaries: Build and Blood Pressure Study, 1959.
15.
Bruch, H.:  Psychiatric Aspects of Obesity in Children ,  Amer J Psychiat 99:752-757 ( (March) ) 1943.
16.
Stunkard, A., and Mendelson, M.:  Disturbances in Body Image of Some Obese Persons ,  J Amer Diet Ass 38:328-331 ( (April) ) 1961.
×