[Skip to Content]
[Skip to Content Landing]
Article
February 20, 1967

Evolution of the Medical Audit

Author Affiliations

†Deceased. Prepared from material in the files of Dr. Lembcke by Olive G. Johnson. From Preventive Medicine and Public Health, School of Public Health and School of Medicine, University of California at Los Angeles.

JAMA. 1967;199(8):543-550. doi:10.1001/jama.1967.03120080077012
Abstract

The first effective demand for the systematic review and scientific evaluation of medical care that is now termed "medical audit" originated soon after 1910. Surgery had gained great popular favor in the years just past when the dramatic relief of suffering and disability and the prolongation of life that were offered by surgery at its best had overcome much of the former dread of the hospital and surgeon. Although the need for welltrained surgeons far exceeded the available supply at that time, there was a surplus of poorly trained surgeons. The medical literature of the day, particularly Flexner's famous survey of medical education, gives us the picture of a greatly overcrowded profession made up in large part of poorly educated doctors. In the period between 1900 and 1909, some 165 medical schools had been turning out 5,200 doctors annually, a majority of whom had not even a high school education

References
1.
Flexner, A.:  Medical Education in United States and Canada: Report to Carnegie Foundation for Advancement of Teaching , New York: Merrymount Press, 1910.
2.
Wetherill, H.G.:  A Plea for Higher Hospital Efficiency and Standardization ,  Surg Gynec Obstet 20:705-707 ( (June) ) 1915.
3.
Finney, J.M.T.:  President's Address, American College of Surgeons , bulletin 1, Chicago, 1916.
4.
Codman, E.A.:  The Product of a Hospital ,  Surg Gynec Obstet 18:491-496 ( (April) ) 1914.
5.
Codman, E.A.:  A Study in Hospital Efficiency: The First Five Years , Boston: Thomas Todd Co., 1916.
6.
 Suggested End Result System, Committee on Standardization of Hospitals, Clinical Congress of Surgeons of North America ,  Surg Gynec Obstet 18 ( (suppl) ):9-12, 1914.
7.
 Report of a Committee on Hospital Standardization ,  Surg Gynec Obstet 22:119-120 ( (Jan) ) 1916.
8.
 Transactions of the Clinical Congress of Surgeons of North America ,  Surg Gynec Obstet 23 ( (suppl) ):13-16, 1916.
9.
Bowman, J.G.:  Hospital Standardization Series, General Hospitals of 100 or More Beds, Report for 1919 ,  Bull Amer College Surg 4:3-36 ( (Jan) ) 1920.
10.
 Manual of Hospital Standardization , Chicago: American College of Surgeons, 1946, p 8.
11.
 Conference on Hospital Standardization ,  Bull Amer College Surg 4:3-9 ( (Jan) ) 1919.
12.
Dickinson, R.L.:  The New "Efficiency" Systems and Their Bearing on Gynecological Diagnosis ,  Amer J Obstet Dis Women Child 70:865-884 ( (Dec) ) 1914.
13.
Dickinson, R.L.:  Hospital Efficiency From the Standpoint of a Hospital Surgeon ,  Boston Med Surg J 172:775-778 ( (May 27) ) 1915.Crossref
14.
Ward, G.G.:  Audits Measure Our Results ,  Mod Hosp 69:86-88 ( (July) ) 1947.
15.
Ponton, T.R.:  The Medical Staff in the Hospital , Chicago: Physicians' Record Co., 1939.
16.
 Annual Approval Survey by Surgeons ,  Hospitals 23:118 ( (March) ) 1949.
17.
Falk, I.S.; Klem, M.C.; and Sinai, N.:  The Incidence of Illness and the Receipt and Costs of Medical Care Among Representative Families , Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1933.
18.
Miller, F.:  Hysterectomy: Therapeutic Necessity or Surgical Racket ,  Amer J Obstet Gynec 51:804-810 ( (June) ) 1946.
19.
Anderson, O.W.:  National Family Survey of Medical Costs and Voluntary Health Insurance , New York: Health Information Foundation, 1954.
20.
Klicka, K.S.:  The Use and Mechanics of the Medical Audit ,  Hospitals 22:43-45 ( (Jan) ) 1948.
21.
Klicka, K.S.:  Control of Surgery ,  Mod Hosp 71:84-86 ( (Dec) ) 1948.
22.
Southmayd, H.J., and Smith, G.:  Small Community Hospitals , New York: Commonwealth Fund, Division of Publications, 1944, pp 159-164.
23.
Lembcke, P.A. (ed.):  The Regional Hospital Plan—The Second Year's Experience , Rochester, NY: Council of Rochester Regional Hospitals, 1947, pp 27-29.
24.
Slee, V.N.:  Statistics Influence Medical Practice ,  Mod Hosp 83:55-58 ( (July) ) 1954.
25.
Lembcke, P.A.:  Measuring the Quality of Medical Care Through Vital Statistics Based on Hospital Service Areas: I. Comparative Study of Appendectomy Rates ,  Amer J Public Health 42:276-286 ( (March) ) 1952.Crossref
26.
Lembcke, P.A.:  The Professional Audit , read before the  Medical Record Librarians Section, United Hospital Fund, New York, Jan 19, 1954.
27.
Myers, R.S.:  Hospital Statistics Don't Tell the Truth ,  Mod Hosp 83:53-54 ( (July) ) 1954.
28.
Eisele, C.W.:  Opinions Are No Basis for an Objective Analysis ,  Mod Hosp 83:64 ( (July) ) 1954.
29.
Morrissey, E.J.:  Needed: A Firm Hand to Eliminate Abuses ,  Hospitals 28:100-101 ( (March) ) 1954.
30.
Lembcke, P.A.:  The Necessity for Closer Relationships Between Small and Large Hospitals ,  Canad Hosp 26:29-92 ( (June) ) 1949.
31.
Pearl, R.:  Modern Methods in Handling Hospital Statistics ,  Bull Hopkins Hosp 32:184-194 ( (June) ) 1921.
32.
Myers, R.S.; Slee, V.N.; and Hoffman, R.G.:  Medical Audit ,  Mod Hosp 85:77-83 ( (Sept) ) 1955.
33.
 Group Undertakes Hospital Record Study ,  Hospitals 30:96 ( (July 16) ) 1956.
34.
Eisele, C.W.; Slee, V.N.; and Hoffman, R.G.:  Can the Practice of Internal Medicine Be Evaluated?  Ann Intern Med 44:144-161 ( (Jan) ) 1956.Crossref
35.
Eisele, C.W.:  Methods of Evaluating Medical Care in Hospitals ,  Rocky Mountain Med J 53:1117-1121 ( (Dec) ) 1956.
36.
Rosenfeld, L.S.:  Quality of Medical Care in Hospitals ,  Amer J Public Health 47:856-865 ( (July) ) 1957.Crossref
37.
Trussell, R.E.; Morehead, M.A.; and Ehrlich, J.:  The Quantity, Quality and Costs of Medical and Hospital Care Secured by a Sample of Teamster Families in the New York Area , New York: Columbia University Press.
38.
Makover, H.B.:  The Quality of Medical Care, Methodology of Survey of the Medical Groups Associated With the Health Insurance Plan of New York ,  Amer J Public Health 41:824-832 ( (July) ) 1951.Crossref
39.
Lembcke, P.A.:  Medical Auditing by Scientific Methods, Illustrated by Major Female Pelvic Surgery ,  JAMA 162:646-655 ( (Oct 13) ) 1956.Crossref
40.
Doyle, J.C.:  Unnecessary Ovariectomies: Study Based on Removal of 704 Normal Ovaries From 546 Patients ,  JAMA 148: 1105-1111 ( (March) ) 1952.Crossref
41.
Doyle, J.C.:  Unnecessary Hysterectomies: Study of 6,248 Operations in 35 Hospitals During 1948 ,  JAMA 151:360-365 ( (Jan 31) ) 1953.
42.
Beecher, H.K., and Todd, D.P.:  A Study of the Deaths Associated With Anesthesia and Surgery ,  Ann Surg 140:1-34 ( (July) ) 1954.Crossref
43.
Lembcke, P.A.:  A Scientific Method for Medical Auditing ,  Hospitals 33:65-71 (June 16, pt (1) ; 65-72 July 1, pt 2) 1959.
44.
Lembcke, P.A., and Johnson, O.G.:  A Medical Audit Report —Comparison of the Findings in a 200-Bed Suburban Hospital With Those in University Teaching Hospitals (multilithed) 1963.
45.
Hogben, L.: Science for the Citizen (1938); quoted by Nash, C.B.:  PSI and Probability Theory ,  Science 120:582 ( (Oct 8) ) 1954.
×