Copyright 2002 American Medical Association. All Rights Reserved.
Applicable FARS/DFARS Restrictions Apply to Government Use.2002
JOHN ORLANDO ROE (1848-1915) (Figure
1), an otolaryngologist who hailed from Rochester, NY, should be
rightfully credited as the father of aesthetic rhinoplasty. Unfortunately,
his contemporary, Jacques Joseph, has often been unjustly heralded as the
proper bearer of this title.1-2
Although Joseph's contributions at the time to the nascent field of facial
plastic surgery should not be underestimated, Roe's pioneering endeavors were
truly innovative and clearly antedated Joseph's work by 11 years. Joseph,
often curmudgeonly disposed, would turn irascible and flush a bright red when
his rival's name was invoked in his presence—an incident that Aufricht
recounted—and would infrequently and erroneously cite Roe's achievements.3 Unlike the prevailing extranasal technique of the
day—which marked the patient's nose with multiple incisions and which
differs radically from present, external techniques—Roe devised a unique
intranasal approach that corrected the tip, or a "pug-nose" deformity, his
findings of which were published in 1887, and the dorsum, or "angular deformities,"
which was reported 4 years later. His first article in 1887 demonstrated his
technique with preoperative and postoperative illustrations (Figure 2), which Joseph would later adopt in 1898 with his single
case study. Moreover, Roe's second article in 1891 was historic in the use
of preoperative and postoperative photographs to document his findings (Figure 3), which Joseph would also use much
later in 1902.
Lam SM. John Orlando Roe: Father of Aesthetic Rhinoplasty. Arch Facial Plast Surg. 2002;4(2):122–123. doi:
Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Create a personal account or sign in to: