In reply
Dr Charpiat raises valid points. A tendency to underestimate the rate of supratherapeutic dosing would be driven by the proportion of patients studied who were underweight, which we did not measure.1 Weight-based dosing is widely used in children younger than 12 years, but not in the adult population we studied.2 However, we did perform secondary analyses for elderly patients and patients with chronic liver disease, who may be at increased risk of toxic effects from acetaminophen use or have lower therapeutic windows.