[Skip to Navigation]
February 14, 1994

A Noninvasive Strategy for the Treatment of Patients With Suspected Pulmonary Embolism

Author Affiliations

From the Clinical Trials Unit, Division of General Internal Medicine (Drs Hull, Raskob, and Pineo), University of Calgary (Alberta); Sections of Medicine (Drs Ginsberg, Panju, and Brill-Edwards) and Diagnostic Imaging (Dr Coates), ChedokeMcMaster Hospitals, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario.

Arch Intern Med. 1994;154(3):289-297. doi:10.1001/archinte.1994.00420030093009

Background:  Pulmonary embolism has historically presented a formidable diagnostic problem because of the nonspecificity of the clinical findings associated with this disorder and the diagnostic uncertainties and challenges presented by both ventilation-perfusion lung scanning and pulmonary angiography. We have reported previously that serial noninvasive leg testing provides a practical noninvasive alternative to pulmonary angiography in patients with nonhigh probability (nondiagnostic) lung scans and adequate cardiorespiratory reserve. We have reevaluated this observation prospectively to (1) confirm or refute our original observation in an independent cohort and (2) to increase the numbers sufficiently to provide narrow confidence limits for the observed outcomes.

Methods:  A prospective comparative study in 1564 consecutive patients with suspected pulmonary embolism who underwent ventilation-perfusion lung scanning and objective testing for proximal-vein thrombosis.

Results:  On long-term follow-up of 627 patients with the following characteristics: (1) abnormal, nondiagnostic lung scans, (2) not taking anticoagulant therapy, and (3) serial noninvasive test results negative for proximal-vein thrombosis, only 12 patients (1.9%; 95% confidence limits, 0.8% to 3.0%) had venous thromboembolism. By comparison, venous thromboembolism on follow-up occurred in four (0.7%) of 586 patients (95% confidence limits, 0.02% to 1.3%) with normal lung scans in whom anticoagulant therapy was withheld and in eight (5.5%) of 145 patients (95% confidence limits, 1.8% to 9.2%) with high probability lung scans who received anticoagulant therapy.

Conclusions:  Our findings indicate that the clinician has a practical noninvasive strategy in patients with adequate cardiorespiratory reserve and nondiagnostic lung scans that (1) avoids pulmonary angiography, (2) identifies patients with proximal-vein thrombosis who require treatment, and (3) avoids the need for treatment and further investigation in the majority of patients.(Arch Intern Med. 1994;154:289-297)

Add or change institution