To the Editor.—
Dr Barchi's article, "Myotonia: An Evaluation of the Chloride Hypothesis" (Arch Neurol 32:175, 1975), confirms many of the conclusions regarding low membrane chloride conductance that I have previously arrived at, using a similar mathematical model of myotonia.1.2However, I am in disagreement with Dr Barchi regarding the following points.1. He has apparently neglected the important resistive-capacitive pathway of the sarcotubular system in order to simplify his computations. By contrast, my work has illustrated the pronounced effect of small changes in the electrical properties of this system on the pattern of repetitive electrical activity in myotonia.2. Several of Dr Barchi's "suggestions" are difficult to justify. For example, his suggested explanation for the "warm-up" phenomenon must be considered with regard to other workers' opposing views, especially for the effects of altered external potassium ion concentration.3.43. Although Dr Barchi has presented convincing evidence of the
Bretag AH. Myotonia and Chloride. Arch Neurol. 1976;33(4):304. doi:10.1001/archneur.1976.00500040088018
Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Create a personal account or sign in to: