Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Chamberlain MC, Kormanik PA. Salvage Chemotherapy With Tamoxifen for Recurrent Anaplastic Astrocytomas. Arch Neurol. 1999;56(6):703–708. doi:10.1001/archneur.56.6.703
Copyright 1999 American Medical Association. All Rights Reserved. Applicable FARS/DFARS Restrictions Apply to Government Use.1999
A prospective phase 2 study of daily oral tamoxifen citrate in young adults with recurrent anaplastic astrocytomas.
Twenty-four patients (15 men; 9 women) aged 19 to 45 years (median age, 31.5 years) with recurrent anaplastic astrocytomas were treated. All patients had been treated previously with surgery and involved-field radiotherapy (median dose, 60 Gy; range, 59-61 Gy). In addition, 22 patients were treated adjuvantly with nitrosourea-based chemotherapy (combined procarbazine hydrochloride, lomustine, and vincristine sulfate in 16; carmustine in 6). All patients were treated with salvage chemotherapy at first recurrence, with 1 to 4 chemotherapy regimens (median, 1 regimen). Tamoxifen citrate was administered orally at a fixed dosage of 80 mg/m2 as a single or a twice-daily dosage. Neurologic and neuroradiographic evaluation were performed every 12 weeks, operationally defined as a single cycle of tamoxifen.
All patients were able to undergo evaluation. A median of 4 cycles of tamoxifen (range, 1-8 cycles) were administered. No tamoxifen-related toxic effects were seen, nor were there any treatment-related deaths. Four patients (17%) demonstrated a neuroradiographic partial response; 11 patients (46%), stable disease; and 9 patients (38%), progressive disease following a single cycle of tamoxifen. Time to tumor progression ranged from 3 to 25 months (median, 12 months). Survival ranged from 3 to 27 months (median, 13 months). Five patients are alive, with 3 receiving alternative chemotherapy regimens and 2 continuing to receive tamoxifen. In the group with responding and stable disease, median survival was 15 months (range, 8-27 months).
Tamoxifen demonstrated modest efficacy with no apparent toxic effects in this heavily pretreated cohort of young adults with recurrent anaplastic astrocytomas.
THE TREATMENT of recurrent primary brain tumors is problematic, as only partially effective therapeutic modalities are available. These therapies include chemotherapy, radioactive seed implants, stereotactic radiotherapies, immunotherapy, and reoperation.1-7 Chemotherapy for recurrent malignant primary brain tumors is experimental, primarily because response to chemotherapy is palliative and of limited duration. Those drugs most active are the nitrosoureas, such as carmustine and lomustine, in addition to procarbazine hydrochloride, cyclophosphamide, diaziquone, and platinum compounds.1-3,5,7,8 An alternative approach to the treatment of recurrent primary brain tumors is the hormonal agent tamoxifen citrate.9-13
Several recent studies have indicated that the proliferation of malignant gliomas in part depends on excessive activation of protein kinase C (PKC)-mediated pathways.14-24 Protein kinase C constitutes a family of proteins that play an important role in growth factor–mediated signal transduction and that are overexpressed in malignant gliomas.25-31 Consistent with this hypothesis, inhibition of PKC by nonselective protein kinase inhibitors such as polymyxin B sulfate, staurosporine, and tamoxifen blocks glioma proliferation in vitro.14-31 In addition, several phase 1 and 2 clinical studies in patients with recurrent malignant gliomas have demonstrated modest efficacy for oral tamoxifen in the control of tumor growth in vivo.9-13
The objective of this single-institution phase 2 trial was to observe the safety and efficacy of tamoxifen citrate given at a dosage of 80 mg/m2 per day. Twenty-four young adults with recurrent anaplastic astrocytomas who had undergone previous surgery, radiotherapy, and at least 1 chemotherapy regimen containing nitrosoureas and who were no longer responding to therapy were entered into the study.
Patients must have undergone previous surgery and had a recurrent neuropathologically proven anaplastic astrocytoma. Patient ages could range from 18 to 50 years. Tumors must have progressed following definitive radiotherapy and at least 1 previous chemotherapy regimen that included a nitrosourea. At least 4 weeks must have elapsed since the last dose of chemotherapy (6 weeks for nitrosoureas), and patients must have recovered from the adverse effects of previous therapy. Patients could not have received previous tamoxifen therapy. Patients must have had radiographically measurable intracranial disease wherein recurrent tumor was bidimensionally measurable using radiography (cranial contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging [MRI] or computed tomography [CT]).32 Reoperation for confirmation of recurrent anaplastic astrocytomas was not required. Pregnant or lactating women were not permitted to participate. Patients of child-bearing potential age implemented adequate contraceptive measures during participation. Patients must have had an Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status of 0 to 2 (Karnofsky score ≥60) and a life expectancy greater than 3 months.
Adequate hematologic, renal, and hepatic functions were required and were defined by the following: absolute granulocyte count of at least 1.5×109/L or white blood cell count of at least 4.0×109/L; platelet count of at least 100×109/L; total bilirubin level of no more than 30.8 µmol/L (1.8 mg/dL); transaminase level of no more than 3 times the upper limit of normal; creatinine concentration of no more than 137.2 µmol/L (1.8 mg/dL); and normal results of an electrocardiogram.
All patients were aware of the neoplastic nature of their disease and willingly consented to participate after being informed of the procedures to be used, experimental nature of the therapy, alternatives, potential benefits, side effects, risk, and discomforts. Patients with meningeal gliomatosis were not eligible. No serious concurrent medical illnesses or active infection could be present that would jeopardize the ability of the patient to receive tamoxifen therapy. Patients could not have active concomitant malignant disease except skin cancer (squamous cell or basal cell).
Cranial CT was performed on a commercially available scanner (GE 9800; General Electric, Milwaukee, Wis). Contiguous 10-mm-thick axial sections were obtained from the foramen magnum to the vertex before and after intravenous administration of iodinated contrast media (Conray 43; Mallinckrodt, Inc, St Louis, Mo). All postcontrast CT images were obtained within 20 minutes of iodinated contrast media infusion.
Cranial MRI was performed on a 1.5-T superconducting magnum (Signa; General Electric). Using a spin-echo pulse sequence, axial T2-(repetition time [TR], 3000 milliseconds; echo time [TE], 80 milliseconds) and proton density-weighted (TR, 3000 milliseconds; TE, 30 milliseconds) images were initially acquired. Subsequently, sagittal axial and coronal T1-weighted (TR, 600 milliseconds; TE, 25 milliseconds) images were acquired. Slice thickness was 5 mm, with a 2.5-mm interval between successive slices in all instances; a 256×256 matrix was used. After intravenous administration of 0.1 mmol/kg of gadolinium–pentetic acid dimeglumine (Berlex Laboratories, Cedar Knolls, NJ), coronal, axial, and sagittal T1-weighted sequences (TR, 600 milliseconds; TE, 25 milliseconds) were obtained. All postcontrast images were obtained within 30 minutes of gadolinium infusion. Cranial contrast-enhanced CT and MR images were independently reviewed by a panel of 3 neuroradiologists.
Tamoxifen citrate (Nolvadex; Zeneca Pharmaceuticals, Wilmington, Del) was administered to all patients at an oral fixed dosage of 80 mg/m2per day. Patients elected to take tamoxifen as a single or twice-daily oral dosage. Concurrent dexamethasone therapy was permitted for control of neurologic signs and symptoms. Tamoxifen was administered continuously and daily, pending clinical neuroradiographic evaluation at 1 and 3 months and subsequently, as we shall indicate. Tamoxifen was administered regardless of white blood cell count, absolute granulocyte count, or platelet count. All toxic effects, including hematologic due to oral tamoxifen therapy, were rated according to the Cancer and Leukemia Group B expanded toxic effects criteria.32
Oral dexamethasone was given concurrently in 17 patients, and dosage was increased in 8 patients with documented clinical and neuroradiographic progression. Dexamethasone dosage was decreased in 7 patients, and therapy was discontinued in 2 patients as patient clinical status permitted.
Blood counts were obtained monthly, neurologic examination was performed monthly, and contrast-enhanced cranial MRI and CT were performed at 1 and 3 months and every 3 months thereafter. A single cycle of tamoxifen was defined operationally as 3 consecutive months of daily oral tamoxifen therapy.
Neuroradiographic response criteria as defined by Macdonald et al32 were used. Complete response (CR) was defined as the disappearance of all enhancing or nonenhancing tumor on results of consecutive CT or MRI at least 1 month apart, with the patient neurologically stable or improved and taking no corticosteroids. Partial response (PR) was defined as a reduction of at least 50% in the size of tumor on results of consecutive CT or MRI at least 1 month apart, with the corticosteroid dosage stable or decreased and the patient neurologically stable or improved. Progressive disease (PD) was defined as an increase of a 25% or more in the size of tumor or any new tumor on results of CT or MRI, or the patient neurologically worse while receiving a stable or increased corticosteroid dosage. Stable disease (SD) was defined as all other situations.
In patients with SD, PR, or CR, 1 additional cycle of tamoxifen was administered, following which patients again underwent assessment. Tamoxifen therapy was continued until documentation of PD, at which time patients were removed from study and therapy was discontinued or alternative therapy was offered.
The study design was that of a phase 2 prospective protocol. It was assumed, based on a review of the literature, that a maximum tolerated dosage of 160 mg/d of tamoxifen citrate had been established. At this dosage, 24 response-assessable patients were studied to allow estimation of the response rate with a maximum SE of 10%. The study was approved by the University of California, San Diego, Institutional Review Board, and consent for the study was obtained from all patients.
Twenty-four patients (15 men; 9 women) aged 19 to 45 years (median age, 31.5 years), with recurrent anaplastic astrocytoma (Table 1) were treated with tamoxifen. Recurrent anaplastic astrocytomas were defined by objective neuroradiographic progression (≥25% increase in tumor size) compared with previous neuroradiographic images using the criteria reported by Macdonald et al.32
Patients presented at the time of tumor recurrence with the following signs and symptoms: increasing headache (n=13), worsening seizures (n=14), progressive hemiparesis (n=7), new-onset homonymous hemianopsia (n=3), and gait ataxia (n=1). Patient performance status using the Karnofsky scale ranged from 70 to 100 (median, 90) at the time of neuroradiographically documented tumor recurrence and initiation of tamoxifen therapy. All patients had undergone previous subtotal resection of tumor. Tumor locations, including multicentric tumors, were as follows: frontal lobe (n=9), temporal lobe (n=3), occipital lobe (n=4), parietal lobe (n=7), thalamus (n=2), septum pellucidum (n=1), and cerebellum (n=1). Twenty-two patients had lobar tumors, and 2 patients had multicentric tumors each with 2 noncontiguous locations. Results of pathological examination (reviewed by a panel of 3 neuropathologists at University of California, San Diego) showed all tumors to be anaplastic astrocytomas.
All 24 patients had been treated previously with adjuvant limited-field radiotherapy (Table 1), and in all, conventional fractionated radiotherapy was used in which 1.8 to 2.0 Gy was administered daily, with a median dose of 60 Gy (range, 59-61 Gy).
All patients were treated previously with a nitrosourea-based chemotherapy. Twenty-two patients received adjuvant chemotherapy as follows: 16, procarbazine, lomustine, and vincristine sulfate (range, 1-7 cycles; median, 4.5 cycles); 6, carmustine (range, 3-6 cycles; median, 5 cycles). All patients were treated with salvage chemotherapy before the introduction of tamoxifen and received a range of 1 to 4 therapies (median, 1) (Table 1). Patients received an average of 5 cycles of salvage chemotherapy (range, 2-23 cycles). Tamoxifen therapy was begun in all patients immediately following documentation of salvage-chemotherapy failure as demonstrated by neuroradiographic progression and, in 18 patients (80%), clinical disease progression.
All patients were examined for toxic effects. No treatment-related complications were seen. In particular, no evidence of myelosuppression, retinopathy, coagulopathy, or cardiac arrhythmia were seen. No treatment-related deaths occurred.
A total of 96 cycles of tamoxifen were administered. A median of 4 cycles of tamoxifen were administered, with a range of 1 to 8 cycles. For inpatients with objective neuroradiographic responses or SD (15 patients [62%]), a median of 5 cycles of tamoxifen were administered, with a range of 2 to 8 cycles. Tamoxifen was administered at the prescribed dose daily and continuously without interruption in all patients. No other antiglial agents aside from dexamethasone were used during the study.
All patients underwent assessment for response (Table 1). Following a single cycle of tamoxifen (3 months of continuous daily oral administration), 9 patients demonstrated PD and were offered alternative therapy; 4 patients (17%), PR; and 11 patients (46%), SD, for a total response rate of 62%. No improvement was seen in pretreatment neurologic examination or Karnofsky performance status aside from amelioration of headache in 6 patients. Furthermore, in patients with treatment response, oral dexamethasone dosage was stable or decreased. At the conclusion of tamoxifen therapy, Karnofsky performance status ranged from 50 to 70, with a median of 70 in the entire study group. The median time to tumor progression was 12 months, with a range of 3 to 25 months in the entire study group. In patients with PD, median time to tumor progression was 3 months (range, 1 to 3 months). Survival in the entire cohort ranged from 3 to 27 months, with a median of 13 months. Five patients are alive, with 3 receiving alternative therapies, and 2 continuing to receive tamoxifen. In patients with nonresponding PD, median survival was 4 months, with a range of 3 to 4 months. In patients with an objective response or SD, median survival was 15 months, with a range of 8 to 27 months. Nineteen patients have died, and all deaths were directly attributable to the effects of progressive intracranial tumor. Patients with no response to tamoxifen after initial SD were offered alternative therapy.
A number of prognostic variables affect survival in patients with malignant gliomas, including histologic characteristics of tumor, patient age, and patient performance status.1-6,33,34 Accordingly, we selected patients with favorable prognostic features, in particular relatively young patients with excellent performance status (median Karnofsky performance status of 90) and histologic findings of anaplastic astrocytoma tumor. In a seminal report on the outcome of patients with anaplastic astrocytoma, Prados et al35 concluded that these patients can be expected to have a median survival of more than 3 years, that young age and high Karnofsky performance status have a positive influence on survival, and that salvage therapies can extend survival after the onset of tumor progression for nearly a year. As such, our results should not be extrapolated to the larger group of patients with recurrent malignant gliomas but rather confined to the subset of patients with 20% to 25% of all malignant gliomas.
Despite the favorable group of patients selected for inclusion in our study, all patients underwent heavy pretreatment. As has become standard for patients with malignant gliomas, most patients (92%) were offered adjuvant nitrosourea-based chemotherapy following cytoreductive surgery and involved-field radiotherapy. Subsequently, all patients at the time of first tumor recurrence were treated with a variety of salvage chemotherapy protocol regimens before initiation of tamoxifen therapy. Therefore, tamoxifen therapy was begun after at least 2 chemotherapy regimens, adjuvant radiotherapy, and surgery had failed. No patient was believed to be a candidate for reoperation or stereotactic radiotherapies, 2 modalities that may have a significant palliative impact on patients with recurrent malignant gliomas.2-6 Investigational protocols were therefore deemed medically and ethically appropriate, and, as such, a prospective study of long-term daily oral tamoxifen therapy was initiated.
A range of tamoxifen dosages have been championed in various reports, but no published data exist regarding a dose-response relationship.13 It has been shown in vitro that to block the proliferation of malignant glioma cell lines, concentrations several-fold higher than those typically obtained during the treatment of breast cancer are required.14-17,19,22,23 Five- to 10-µmol concentrations of tamoxifen per liter in vitro inhibits protein kinase C.22,23 These in vitro inhibitory levels are achievable in vivo with oral tamoxifen citrate dosages of 160 to 240 mg/d.9-13 The selection of a dosage of 80 mg/m2 per day was based primarily on these findings and secondarily on issues of high-dose oral tamoxifen toxic effects.
The most commonly reported side effects of high-dose oral tamoxifen are the induction of hot flashes; deep venous thrombosis; nausea; neurotoxic effects as manifested by tremor, ataxia, and dizziness; and QT interval elongation on results of electrocardiography.9-14 Side effects of oral tamoxifen are dose dependent, wherein lower doses have a low incidence of side effects. As judged by the lack of toxic effects in our study at a dosage of 80 mg/m2 per day (160-180 mg/d), a higher dosage of tamoxifen may have been appropriate and could be identified in a standard phase 1 dose escalation study in patients with recurrent malignant gliomas.
Two other criticisms aside from dose selection may be directed at our study. First, no attempt was made to administer a loading dose of tamoxifen. Therefore, antiglial proliferative effects of tamoxifen are correspondingly delayed until tissue levels of tamoxifen and its active metabolite n-desmethyltamoxifen (n-dMT) are achieved.36-39 Several groups have recently examined this approach and have demonstrated that cytostatic micromolar concentrations of tamoxifen could be achieved within several days following administration of tamoxifen dosages in the range of 200 to 1000 mg/d.9-13 Moreover, continued delivery of high-dose oral tamoxifen increases plasma concentrations of tamoxifen and n-dMT to levels of 5 to 10 µmol/L. Tamoxifen and n-dMT cross the blood-brain barrier and have been shown to accumulate intratumorally to therapeutically effective levels.36-39
The second criticism of our study relates to the lack of performance of pharmacokinetic studies. Since tamoxifen and n-dMT are cytostatic agents, sustained tumor levels are necessary for optimal effect. To achieve maximal effect, serum levels in the range of 5 to 10 µmol of tamoxifen per liter should be realized. The failure of tamoxifen in one third of patients in our study may reflect insufficient serum and tissue levels of tamoxifen. Future studies of high-dose oral tamoxifen may address both of these issues by measuring serum levels during initiation of tamoxifen and on achieving steady-state concentrations. A flexible dosing schedule based on serum levels would appear more appropriate using the 5- to 10-µmol/L tamoxifen concentration as the therapeutic target serum levels.36-39
A variety of response rates to high-dose oral tamoxifen in patients with recurrent malignant gliomas have been reported and on average are in the range of 25% to 35%.9-13 Confounding interpretation of these studies are the variable daily dosage of tamoxifen administered, differing tumor histological characteristics, frequent coadministration of chemotherapy, initiation of tamoxifen therapy immediately after completion of radiotherapy, and in general, a failure to obtain measurements of serum tamoxifen levels. The response rate in our study (17% PR; 46% SD), although modestly lower than previously reported, is not confounded by the above-mentioned difficulties of previous studies, save for the failure to assay serum levels of tamoxifen.
In conclusion, daily oral tamoxifen at a dosage of 80mg/m2 per day in this small cohort of heavily pretreated young adults with recurrent anaplastic astrocytomas is associated with modest activity and no observable clinical toxic effects. Future studies of tamoxifen in patients with malignant gliomas appear warranted, including combination therapies with vinca alkaloids, etoposide, and platinum compounds. Combination therapy with vinca alkaloids or etoposide is based on tamoxifen interference with p-glycoprotein–dependent drug efflux, the major mechanism of drug resistance with these agents.40,41 Alternatively, combination therapy with platinum compounds enhances cellular responsiveness and increases in vitro tumor cytotoxic effects.42
Accepted for publication March 25, 1998.
Corresponding author: Marc C. Chamberlain, MD, Kaiser Permanente Medical Group, Department of Neurology, 1011 Baldwin Park Blvd, Baldwin Park, CA 91706 (email@example.com).
Create a personal account or sign in to: