Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Pathogenic mutations of the human mitochondrial genome are associated with well-characterized, progressive neurological syndromes, with mutations in the transfer RNA genes being particularly prominent.
To describe a novel mitochondrial transfer RNAPro gene mutation in a woman with a myoclonic epilepsy with ragged-red fibers–like disease.
Design, Setting, and Patient
Case report of a 49-year-old woman presenting with a myoclonic epilepsy with ragged-red fibers–like disease comprising myoclonic jerks, cerebellar ataxia, and proximal muscle weakness.
Histochemical analysis of a muscle biopsy revealed numerous cytochrome-c oxidase–deficient, ragged-red fibers, while biochemical studies indicated decreased activity of respiratory chain complex I. Molecular investigation of mitochondrial DNA revealed a new heteroplasmic mutation in the TψC stem of the mitochondrial transfer RNAPro gene that segregated with cytochrome-c oxidase deficiency in single muscle fibers.
Our case serves to illustrate the ever-evolving phenotypic spectrum of mitochondrial DNA disease and the importance of performing comprehensive mitochondrial genetic studies in the absence of common mitochondrial DNA mutations.
Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mutations are associated with an impressive spectrum of clinical presentations ranging from severe encephalopathy in the neonatal period to late-onset progressive external ophthalmoplegia and exercise intolerance in adults.1 The syndrome of myoclonic epilepsy with ragged-red fibers (MERRF) is one of the most common clinical phenotypes associated with mtDNA mutation, with most patients harboring a specific, maternally inherited point mutation (m.8344A>G) in the transfer RNALys (tRNALys) gene.2 Other MERRF mutations have been identified in both this gene (eg, m.8356T>C3 and m.8363G>A4) and other mitochondrial tRNA genes,5 but unlike mutations causing mitochondrial encephalomyopathy with lactic acidosis and strokelike episodes that exhibit considerable genetic heterogeneity, these appear to be restricted to tRNA genes.
Here we describe a patient with clinical and diagnostic features of MERRF and additional neurological complications due to a novel mutation (m.15967G>A) in the mitochondrial-encoded tRNAPro gene that may have arisen sporadically in the patient.
A 49-year-old woman presented with a 2-year history of progressive loss of balance and weakness of her arms. At age 27 years, she developed myoclonic jerks and generalized seizures that showed excellent response to sodium valproate. At age 37 years, she developed acute bilateral hearing loss. At age 47 years, she underwent bilateral cataract surgery. Her mother has type 2 diabetes mellitus and her maternal grandmother had type 1 diabetes mellitus. The youngest of her 3 sisters has learning disability and migraine; the other 2 sisters are healthy. She has 3 children, 2 of whom are healthy and 1 of whom has severe dyslexia. All of the 3 children later declined genetic testing.
On examination, she was found to have a Mini-Mental State Examination score of 24 out of 30. She had bilateral deafness, and some pigmentary change was noted in her retina. Her speech was dysarthric. She had proximal muscle weakness and her reflexes were either absent or attenuated. Cerebellar ataxia was demonstrated in all of her limbs and her gait was ataxic. All of her modalities of sensation were normal.
Visual evoked responses were normal. Electroencephalography showed a burst of high-amplitude, 4- to 5-Hz, multiple spike and wave activity with left-sided emphasis. Nerve conduction study results were normal. Mild neurogenic change was noted on electromyography. Her audiogram revealed bilateral sensorineural hearing loss. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed extensive, high signal change in the cerebral white matter, basal ganglia, and thalami as well as cerebral and cerebellar atrophy (Figure 1). Creatine kinase level, renal and hepatic profiles, thyroid function, vitamin B12 and folate levels, autoantibody screen results, serum immunoglobulin level, serum lactate level, full blood cell count, and syphilis serology results were all either normal or negative. Examination results of the cerebrospinal fluid were unremarkable.
Fluid-attenuated inversion recovery magnetic resonance images showing bilateral high signal in the basal ganglia, thalami, and adjacent white matter with a background of cerebral atrophy.
A screen of the m.3243A>G and m.8344A>G mtDNA mutations in blood revealed no abnormalities, prompting muscle biopsy for further investigations.
Standard histological and histochemical analyses of quadriceps muscle biopsy were performed on fresh frozen sections (10 μm), while the activities of the respiratory chain complexes and the matrix marker citrate synthase were determined as previously described.6
Total DNA was extracted from several tissues, including blood and muscle, by standard procedures. Mitochondrial DNA rearrangements were investigated in muscle DNA prior to direct sequencing of the entire mitochondrial genome.
To determine the level of heteroplasmy of a novel m.15967G>A variant, we designed a polymerase chain reaction (PCR)–restriction fragment length polymorphism assay as follows: a 131–base pair (bp) PCR product spanning the mutation site was amplified using a forward primer (nucleotides 15879-15897) and an M-13 tailed (lowercase) reverse mismatch primer (nucleotides H15991-15968), 5′-caggaaacagctatgaccGGGTGCTAATGGTGGAGTTAGAGA-3′, with the single mismatch nucleotide shown in bold. In combination with the m.15967G>A mutation, this serves to introduce a novel Alw26I restriction site, permitting the detection of mutated mtDNA that is cut to 2 smaller bands (94 bp and 37 bp). Prior to the last cycle of PCR, 5 μCi of [α-32P]–labeled deoxycytidine triphosphate (3000 Ci/mmol) was added (to convert microcuries to becquerels, multiply by 37 000; to convert curies per millimole to becquerels per millimole, multiply by 3.7 × 1010). Labeled products were precipitated, digested with 10 U of Alw26I, and separated through a 12% nondenaturing polyacrylamide gel, and the radioactivity in each fragment was quantified using ImageQuant software (GE Healthcare, Chalfont St Giles, England).
Enzyme histochemistry of the proband's muscle biopsy revealed a significant number of fibers (>10%) exhibiting cytochrome-c oxidase (COX) deficiency (Figure 2A), with several fibers showing evidence of subsarcolemmal mitochondrial accumulation typical of ragged-red changes. Analysis of respiratory chain complex activities in a skeletal muscle homogenate showed a decrease in complex I activity to approximately 30% of control values when expressed relative to the activity of the matrix marker enzyme citrate synthase. Interestingly, complex IV activity was normal.
Characterization of a novel transfer RNAPro mutation. A, Histochemical demonstration of combined cytochrome-c oxidase (COX) and succinate dehydrogenase activities, revealing COX-deficient (blue-stained) fibers and evidence of mitochondrial proliferation. B, Sequencing electropherogram demonstrating the heteroplasmic m.15967G>A transition in the patient. C, Quantitation of the relative amounts of mutated and wild-type mitochondrial DNA by polymerase chain reaction–restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis in different tissues, highlighting the highest levels of the mutation in muscle (band at 131 base pairs [bp]), low levels in urinary epithelial cells, and absence of the mutation in blood. D, Graphical representation of single-muscle-fiber polymerase chain reaction analysis clearly shows the mutation segregating with a biochemical defect in COX-deficient muscle fibers.
The presence of large-scale mtDNA rearrangements in the patient's muscle DNA was excluded by long-range PCR assays. Direct sequencing of the entire mitochondrial genome revealed a previously unreported m.15967G>A transition in the mitochondrial tRNAPro gene (Figure 2B), which appeared heteroplasmic on the chromatogram. Analysis by a PCR–restriction fragment length polymorphism assay confirmed heteroplasmy at this site, with the highest levels of the m.15967G>A mutation present in the patient's muscle (69% mutant load), lower levels in urinary epithelia (approximately 10%), and undetectable levels in blood (Figure 2C). Analysis of urinary epithelia and blood from the proband's clinically unaffected mother and 2 sisters failed to identify the m.15967G>A mutation, suggesting a de novo mutation event.
Finally, we performed single-muscle-fiber analysis to determine whether the amount of mutated mtDNA correlated with the observed biochemical phenotype in individual cells. Substantially higher levels of the m.15967G>A mutation were detected in COX-deficient fibers (mean [SD], 98.80% [0.89%]; n = 10 fibers) than in COX-positive fibers (mean [SD], 31.10% [11.23%]; n = 10 fibers) (P < .001, 2-tailed t test), confirming segregation of the m.15967A genotype with respiratory chain dysfunction (Figure 2D).
Pathogenic mtDNA mutations can manifest as distinct clinical syndromes, but sometimes patients may present with additional clinical features that can complicate the diagnosis. Our patient presented with the clinical features of MERRF, including a long-standing history of myoclonic epilepsy. Additionally, she presented with other clinical features (proximal myopathy, sensorineural deafness, cerebellar ataxia, and pigmentary retinopathy) that are typical in patients with mitochondrial genetic disease.1 Muscle biopsy revealed histochemical and biochemical abnormalities indicative of mitochondrial involvement, and once common mtDNA mutations were excluded, we undertook detailed molecular genetic investigation of the mitochondrial genome, which identified the causative mutation.
The pathogenicity of the m.15967G>A tRNAPro mutation is suggested based on its fulfillment of established canonical criteria.7,8 First, it is not a recognized neutral polymorphic variant as the mutation was not represented in either of the large, publicly available databases of human mtDNA sequences.9,10 Second, it was clearly heteroplasmic and present at higher levels in postmitotic skeletal muscle than in mitotic cells such as urinary epithelial cells (Figure 2C). Third, single-muscle-fiber PCR–restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis clearly demonstrated that the mutation segregates with COX-deficient fibers (Figure 2D). The highest level of mutated mtDNA detected in any of the COX-positive fibers was 90%, implying a high biochemical threshold for the m.15967G>A mutation. Fourth, the mutation affects a nucleotide that, although showing poor phylogenetic conservation within the tRNAPro structure, is predicted to disrupt a highly conserved Watson-Crick base pair within the TψC stem (Figure 3).11
Effect of the mutation. A, Schematic representation of the mitochondrial transfer RNAPro cloverleaf structure showing the position of the mutation, which affects a nucleotide involved in Watson-Crick base pairing in the TψC stem. DHU indicates dihydrouridine. B, Phylogenetic analysis of this region of the transfer RNAPro gene reveals that the base pair involving the nucleotide at position m.15967 is strictly conserved throughout species, providing further evidence for pathogenicity.
Surprisingly, although more than 120 different pathogenic mitochondrial tRNA gene mutations have now been described, mutations in the tRNAPro gene have been described in only 3 previous patients. The m.15990C>T anticodon swap mutation was identified in a young girl with pure myopathy,12 and the m.16002A>G mutation was described in an adult patient with muscle weakness and exercise intolerance.13 The only other patient presented with mild fatigability, dysphagia, and unsteady gait due to 2 heteroplasmic mtDNA mutations, including m.15995G>A in tRNAPro.14
A further interesting aspect of this tRNAPro mutation is that it was not detected in tissues (urinary epithelial cells and blood) from either the patient's mother or her 2 clinically unaffected siblings, suggesting that the m.15967G>A mutation arose in the germline as a de novo mutational event. It is conceivable that the mutation has been transmitted and is present at detectable levels in postmitotic muscle but not in rapidly dividing cells where deleterious mitochondrial tRNA mutations may be actively selected against.15 Recent data from 2 mouse models have indicated evidence of a strong purifying selection against the transmission of pathogenic mtDNA mutations at the level of the female germline.16,17 Although the overwhelming majority of disease-associated tRNA mutations are maternally inherited, examples of sporadic, nontransmissible tRNA point mutations are documented.18-21 This demonstrates the importance of performing extensive family studies in newly diagnosed patients to assess the risk of transmission from mothers to their offspring and in doing so providing accurate and informative genetic counseling.
Correspondence: Robert W. Taylor, PhD, FRCPath, Mitochondrial Research Group, The Medical School, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE2 4HH, England (firstname.lastname@example.org).
Accepted for Publication: September 9, 2008.
Author Contributions:Study concept and design: Taylor. Acquisition of data: Blakely, Trip, Swalwell, He, and Wren. Analysis and interpretation of data: Swalwell, Rich, Turnbull, Omer, and Taylor. Drafting of the manuscript: Omer and Taylor. Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Blakely, Trip, Swalwell, He, Wren, Rich, Turnbull, and Taylor. Statistical analysis: Blakely, Swalwell, and He. Obtained funding: Taylor. Administrative, technical, and material support: Turnbull, Omer, and Taylor. Study supervision: Turnbull, Omer, and Taylor.
Financial Disclosure: None reported.
Funding/Support: This work was supported by the Wellcome Trust, the Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Trust, and the UK National Commissioning Group for Rare Mitochondrial Disorders of Adults and Children (Drs Turnbull and Taylor).
Blakely EL, Trip SA, Swalwell H, et al. A New Mitochondrial Transfer RNAPro Gene Mutation Associated With Myoclonic Epilepsy With Ragged-Red Fibers and Other Neurological Features. Arch Neurol. 2009;66(3):399–402. doi:10.1001/archneurol.2008.576
Artificial Intelligence Resource Center