Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Copyright 2011 American Medical Association. All Rights Reserved. Applicable FARS/DFARS Restrictions Apply to Government Use.2011
To investigate the molecular etiology of 2 unrelated patients with a multisystem mitochondrial disorder accompanied by optic atrophy in one of them.
Clinical examination and neurophysiological, radiological, morphological, and molecular analyses.
Tertiary care neuromuscular clinic and molecular genetics laboratory.
A 65-year-old man (patient 1) with dyschromatopsia and vision loss since childhood developed progressive external ophthalmoplegia, ptosis, and myopathy in the seventh decade of life and was found to have optic atrophy. A 63-year-old man (patient 2) with a similar phenotype, without visual symptoms, experienced also hearing loss and parkinsonism.
Main Outcome Measures
Description of the clinical and molecular findings.
A muscle biopsy specimen showed ragged-red, ragged-blue, and cytochrome c oxidase–negative fibers in both patients. Because optic atrophy in patient 1 suggested an autosomal dominant OPA1-related disorder, the OPA1 gene was first sequenced, the results of which did not detect any mutations. Southern blot and polymerase chain reaction analyses of muscle mitochondrial DNA revealed multiple deletions. Sequencing of POLG detected a novel variant, c.3104 + 3A>T, in both patients. Patient 1 was compound heterozygous for a known p.F749S mutation; patient 2 had p.G848S as the second mutation. Analysis of POLG complementary DNA showed that c.3104 + 3A>T results in skipping of exon 18.
Early-onset dyschromatopsia and optic atrophy can occur not only in OPA1-related but also in POLG-related disorders with significant impact on genetic counseling.
The nuclear gene POLG encodes for the catalytic subunit of the sole mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) polymerase gamma (Polγ).1 Mutations in POLG result in a broad phenotypic spectrum ranging from fatal infantile hepatoencephalopathy to late-onset progressive external ophthalmoplegia.2,3 Recently, POLG mutations were reported in 2 patients who manifested with optic neuritis and unmatched cerebrospinal fluid oligoclonal bands years before the development of a classic POLG phenotype.4
Mutations in OPA1, the leading gene for autosomal dominant optic atrophy, can result in a multisystem neurological disease in which optic atrophy may be absent.5,6 While OPA1 mutations are inherited with autosomal dominant modality, although with variable penetrance,6POLG mutations can demonstrate autosomal recessive or dominant inheritance.7 We investigated the molecular etiology of 2 unrelated patients with a multisystem mitochondrial disorder, accompanied by optic atrophy in one of them.
A 65-year-old man with dyschromatopsia and poor vision since childhood presented with a 3-year history of progressive ptosis, dysphagia, exercise-induced myalgia, proximal limb weakness, and unintentional weight loss. His medical history was significant for type 2 diabetes mellitus. A cataract was removed when the patient was 50 years old. Clinical examination revealed bilateral optic atrophy (Figure 1), reduced visual acuity of 20/150 OD and 20/200 OS, moderate symmetric bilateral ptosis, severe ophthalmoparesis, mild generalized weakness, and mild distal superficial sensory loss in his feet with hypoactive tendon reflexes. Ishihara test results confirmed dyschromatopsia; optical coherence tomography showed retinal nerve fiber layer thickness loss. The patient's creatine kinase level was normal. Electromyographic studies showed mixed myopathic and neurogenic changes with normal nerve conductions. Tibial somatosensory evoked potentials were normal. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed diffuse volume loss of the optic chiasm and optic nerves, a left-sided chronic occipital infarct, multiple lacunar infarcts, and mild diffuse cerebral atrophy (Figure 2A and B).
Patient 1. View of right (A) and left (B) optic disc atrophy.
Brain magnetic resonance imaging findings. Left parietal cortical chronic infarct, T1-weighted (A) and volume loss of the optic nerves and chiasm, T2-weighted (B) in patient 1. C, Mild generalized atrophy and subcortical/periventricular white matter signal abnormality in patient 2, fluid-attenuated inversion recovery.
A 63-year-old man with long-standing exercise intolerance and sensorineural hearing loss developed progressive ptosis, limited eye movements, dysphagia, and generalized weakness in his mid-40s, and, more recently, parkinsonism and cataracts. Clinical examination showed muscle weakness similar to that observed in patient 1 with no optic atrophy. In addition, patient 2 had asymmetric parkinsonism that was levodopa responsive. The patient's creatine kinase level was 596 U/L (reference range, 52-336 U/L) (to convert to microkatals per liter, multiple by 0.0167). Electromyographic studies showed diffuse myopathic changes. Brain magnetic resonance imaging revealed mild diffuse cerebral atrophy and moderate periventricular and subcortical white matter signal changes (Figure 2C). Magnetic resonance spectroscopy disclosed no increased lactate peaks.
In both patients, a muscle biopsy specimen showed scattered ragged-red and ragged-blue fibers and numerous cytochrome c oxidase–negative fibers (Figure 3). The biochemical measurement of the muscle respiratory enzymes did not reveal deficiencies in complex activities in patient 1. Electrocardiogram, 24-hour Holter monitoring, and echocardiogram were normal in both patients. Neither patient had similarly affected family members.
Patient 1. Muscle biopsy specimen showing scattered ragged-blue (A) and cytochrome c oxidase (COX)–negative fibers (B) in succinate dehydrogenase and COX-stained sections, respectively. C, A ragged-red fiber in trichrome-stained section.
Total DNA was extracted from the muscle tissue of patient 1 and from a blood sample of patient 2 using DNA isolation kits (Gentra Systems, Inc, Minneapolis, Minnesota) according to the manufacturer protocols. Mitochondrial DNA common point mutations, including 3243A>G, 3271T>C, 3460G>A, 8344A>G, 8356T>C, 8363G>A, 8993T>G, 8993T>C, 11778G>A, 14459G>A, and 14484T>C, were screened by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR)/allele-specific oligonucleotide hybridization method. Mitochondrial DNA deletions were analyzed by Southern blot and PCR. OPA1 in patient 1 was sequenced first, and the result was negative. POLG was sequenced in both patients. In addition, ANT1, PEO1, POLG2, and OPA3 were also analyzed in patient 1. Sequencing was performed as previously described,2,5 using National Center for Biotechnology Information GenBank sequences: NM_002693, NM_015560, NM_001151, NM_021830, and NM_007215 for POLG, OPA1, ANT1, PEO1, and POLG2, respectively. NM_001017989.2 and NM_025136.2 were used for OPA3 isoforms A and B. To determine the effect of the novel POLG variant on splicing, POLG complementary DNA synthesized from blood RNA from patient 2 was analyzed using the iScript reverse transcriptase–PCR kit (Bio-Rad, Hercules, California). Exonic primers, 5′, GAGCAGGGGCACTGATCTAC-3′ (forward) and 5′, ACCGGGGTACGTGGTATGT-3′ (reverse) in exons 17 and 19, respectively, were used for PCR/sequence analysis of the aberrantly spliced RNA, according to standard protocols. In patient 1, deletions in the OPA1 and other mitochondrial-related nuclear genes were analyzed by custom-designed oligonucleotide array comparative genomic hybridization.8
Both patients harbor a novel splice-site mutation in intron 18 of POLG (OMIM 174763), c.3104 + 3A>T. This mutation occurs in compound heterozygosity with previously reported pathogenic mutations, p.F749S in patient 1 and p.G848S in patient 2 (http://tools.niehs.nih.gov/polg/). Using exonic primers spanning from exon 17 to 19, analysis of POLG cDNA showed 2 bands. The 447–base pair (bp) band represented the wild-type transcript, while the 324-bp band represented a transcript lacking exon 18 (Figure 4A and B). Sequencing of the PCR product confirmed exon 18 skipping (Figure 4C). The novel mutation was detected in the asymptomatic mother of patient 2, suggesting that the mutation is recessive. The asymptomatic family member's blood of patient 1 was unavailable for analysis. However, Southern blot and PCR analyses of patient 1's muscle DNA showed multiple mtDNA deletions (Figure 5), a pattern consistent with the pathogenicity of the POLG mutations. Mitochondrial DNA common point mutations were not detected in the muscle mtDNA of patient 1. In particular, mtDNA mutations associated with Leber optic neuropathy were not found. Sequencing of genes causing late-onset progressive external ophthalmoplegia and/or optic atrophy, OPA1, ANT1, PEO1, POLG2, and OPA3 in patient 1 did not detect any pathogenic mutations. Large deletions in OPA1 or other mitochondrial-related nuclear genes were not detected by oligonucleotide array comparative genomic hybridization.
Analysis of POLG complementary DNA. A, Location of c.3104 + 3A>T, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and sequencing primers. B, Polymerase chain reaction: patient, P, shows a 447–base pair (bp) band similar to that observed in the control, C, and a 324–base pair band; DNA marker, M. C, Sequencing of PCR product-confirmed exon 18 skipping.
Patient 1. Muscle mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) Southern blot and polymerase chain reaction to detect multiple deletions. A, Patient 1 (Pt1) muscle DNA was digested by restriction endonucleases EagI, XhoI (both have single-cutting site in mtDNA), and Hin dIII (has 3-cutting sites in mtDNA). Arrows with asterisk indicate mtDNA fragments with deletions; M, DNA marker; C, control; and kb, kilobase. B, Polymerase chain reaction across deletion junctions was used to confirm multiple deletions in patient 1 mtDNA. M: DNA marker; 1-5: primer pairs that can only amplify mtDNA with deletions; 6: primer pair that amplifies mt5460-6194 was used as an internal control. Patient 1 muscle mtDNA showed clear multiple deletions in primer pairs 1 to 5 but not significant in blood mtDNA.
We identified a novel POLG mutation, c.3104 + 3A>T, in 2 patients, occurring in compound heterozygosity with previously reported pathogenic mutations. The c.3104 + 3A>T is predicted to abolish the splicing donor site. Indeed, analysis of c.3104 + 3A>T POLG transcripts revealed skipping of exon 18, resulting in in-frame deletion of 41 amino acids in the polymerase catalytic domain. Previously reported point mutations in exon 18 have resulted in reduced enzyme catalytic activity or reduced DNA-binding affinity in light of their location in the putative DNA-binding channel.9 Therefore, skipping of exon 18 is expected to reduce both Polγ catalytic activity and DNA-binding affinity. The novel mutation was detected in the blood sample of the asymptomatic mother of patient 2, suggesting that the mutation is likely recessive. In addition, the novel mutation was not detected in 2600 individuals analyzed for POLG, including 200 normal control subjects.
Although the optic atrophy and long history of dyschromatopsia and vision loss in patient 1 were suggestive of an autosomal dominant OPA1 gene mutation,6,10 patient 1 had an autosomal recessive POLG-related disorder. This finding has a significant impact on genetic counseling, underscoring the importance of molecular analysis for a definite diagnosis. Patient 2 had no visual symptoms and no optic atrophy. Because optical coherence tomography was not performed in patient 2, subclinical optic atrophy, eventually segregating with c.3104 + 3A>T, cannot entirely be excluded. We have identified another patient with POLG mutations, homozygous for p.A467T, manifesting optic atrophy in the setting of Alpers syndrome (L.-J.W., unpublished observation, September 1, 2010). In this case, sequencing analysis of OPA1 and OPA3 did not detect any point mutations. Large deletions in mitochondrial-related nuclear genes were also not detected by oligonucleotide array. Thus, we attribute with confidence the optic atrophy to the POLG mutations. Of interest, 2 patients with optic neuritis and oligoclonal bands in cerebrospinal fluid, previously diagnosed as having multiple sclerosis, developed ataxia, myopathy, progressive external ophthalmoplegia, and cognitive impairment later in life and were found to carry recessive POLG mutations.4 Conversely, patients with pathogenic dominant OPA1 mutations can lack optic atrophy.5,6 Therefore, POLG- and OPA1-related disorders may have clinical overlap.
The other 2 detected POLG mutations were previously reported in compound heterozygosity and expected to be pathogenic. p.F749S was described in association with p.A467T in Alpers syndrome.11 p.G848S has been reported in compound heterozygosity with several other mutations and in association with a broad phenotypic spectrum but not with levodopa-responsive parkinsonism, as observed in patient 2 (http://tools.niehs.nih.gov/polg/).
In conclusion, the present study demonstrates that optic atrophy may occur in POLG-related disorders and that POLG-related disorders can be differentiated from OPA1-related disorders only by molecular analysis.
Correspondence: Margherita Milone, MD, PhD, Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, 200 First St SW, Rochester, MN 55905 (Milone.Margherita@mayo.edu).
Accepted for Publication: October 20, 2010.
Author Contributions:Study concept and design: Milone and Wong. Acquisition of data: Milone, Wang, Liewluck, Chen, Leavitt, and Wong. Analysis and interpretation of data: Milone, Wang, Liewluck, Leavitt, and Wong. Drafting of the manuscript: Milone and Wong. Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Milone, Wang, Liewluck, Chen, Leavitt, and Wong. Obtained funding: None. Administrative, technical, and material support: Milone, Wang, Liewluck, Chen, Leavitt, and Wong. Study supervision: Milone and Wong.
Financial Disclosure: None reported.
Funding/Support: This article was supported by grant UL1 RR024150 from the National Institutes of Health/National Center for Research Resources Clinical and Translational Science Awards (Dr Milone).
Role of the Sponsor: The National Institutes of Health had no role in the design and conduct of the study; in the collection, analysis, and interpretation of the data; or in the preparation, review, or approval of the manuscript.
Disclaimer: The contents of this article are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.
Additional Contributions: We thank the 2 patients for their cooperation in the study.
This article was corrected for errors on June 13, 2011.
Milone M, Wang J, Liewluck T, Chen L, Leavitt JA, Wong L. Novel POLG Splice Site Mutation and Optic Atrophy. Arch Neurol. 2011;68(6):806–811. doi:10.1001/archneurol.2011.124