Note that the diagnosis or prescription was not present during the beneficiary’s first year of enrollment in the managed care plan. CPT indicates Current Procedural Terminology; GD, Graves disease.
eTable. International Classification of Diseases Codes Used in this Analysis and Medications Used in Analysis
Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Stein JD, Childers D, Gupta S, et al. Risk Factors for Developing Thyroid-Associated Ophthalmopathy Among Individuals With Graves Disease. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2015;133(3):290–296. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2014.5103
Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) is a common and debilitating manifestation of Graves disease (GD). Presently little is known about factors that may increase the risk of developing TAO among patients with GD.
To identify risk factors associated with the development of TAO among individuals with newly diagnosed GD.
Design, Setting, and Participants
In this longitudinal cohort study, all beneficiaries 18 years of age or older with newly diagnosed GD who were continuously enrolled in a large nationwide US managed care network and who visited an eye care professional 1 or more times from 2001 to 2009 were identified. International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision, Clinical Modification billing codes were used to identify those who developed manifestations of TAO. Multivariable Cox regression was used to determine the hazard of developing TAO among persons with newly diagnosed GD, with adjustment for sociodemographic factors, systemic medical conditions, thyrotropin levels, and medical and surgical interventions for management of hyperthyroidism.
Main Outcomes and Measures
Manifestations of TAO measured by hazard ratios (HRs) with 95% CIs.
Of 8404 patients with GD who met the inclusion criteria, 740 (8.8%) developed TAO (mean follow-up, 374 days since initial GD diagnosis). After adjustment for potential confounders, surgical thyroidectomy, alone or in combination with medical therapy, was associated with a 74% decreased hazard for TAO (adjusted HR, 0.26 [95% CI, 0.12-0.51]) compared with radioactive iodine therapy alone. Statin use (for ≥60 days in the past year vs <60 days or nonuse) was associated with a 40% decreased hazard (adjusted HR, 0.60 [CI, 0.37-0.93]). No significant association was found for the use of nonstatin cholesterol-lowering medications or cyclooxygenase 2 inhibitors and the development of TAO.
Conclusions and Relevance
If prospective studies can confirm our finding that a thyroidectomy and statin use are associated with substantially reduced hazards for TAO among patients with GD, preventive measures for this burdensome manifestation of GD may become a reality.
Graves disease (GD) is among the most common autoimmune disorders in the United States, affecting nearly 1% of women.1 Some reports2,3 indicate that up to half of patients with GD develop thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO), making it the most prevalent extrathyroidal manifestation. Debilitating components of TAO include proptosis, diplopia, and exposure keratopathy. In rare cases, vision loss may result from corneal ulceration or compressive optic neuropathy. Currently available treatments, such as the use of corticosteroids and immune modulators, do not prevent the long-term consequences of TAO. Identifying modifiable risk factors that predispose patients with GD to develop TAO could dramatically alter the management of these patients. Thus far, the only recognized modifiable risk factors associated with TAO are smoking, exposure to radioactive iodine (RAI), and dysthyroidism.3
Thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy is associated with inflammatory cell infiltration, accumulation of the glycosaminoglycan hyaluronan, and expansion of extraocular muscles and fat.4 Activating antibodies against the thyrotropin receptor drives the hyperthyroidism. However, their role in TAO has yet to be established. In fact, the proximate link between systemic, antigen-specific processes in GD and the development of TAO remains unclear.
We examined longitudinal health care claims data from 8404 individuals with newly diagnosed GD to identify risk factors for developing TAO. Specifically, our study sought to determine whether the choice of management of hyperthyroidism in GD (treatment with antithyroid medications, exposure to RAI, or thyroid ablation) altered the risk of developing TAO. In addition, the effect of elevated serum thyrotropin levels and the effect of the use of statins (3-hydroxy-3-methyl glutaryl–coenzyme A reductase inhibitors) and cyclooxygenase 2 (COX-2) inhibitors were assessed. In this analysis, we find that a thyroidectomy or statin use significantly reduced the relative risk of developing TAO, whereas elevations in serum thyrotropin levels and exposure to RAI increased the risk.
The Clinformatics database (OptumInsight) contains detailed de-identified health care claims data of all beneficiaries in a large US managed care network. Beneficiaries receiving any form of eye care from January 1, 2001, through December 31, 2009, were identified. This subset of beneficiaries comprises those with 1 or more International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM)5 codes for any eye-related diagnosis (codes 360-379.9), with the Current Procedural Terminology6 code for any eye-related visits or for any diagnostic or therapeutic procedures (codes 65091-68899 or codes 92002-92499), or with any other claim submitted by an ophthalmologist or optometrist during their time in the medical plan. Claims (inpatient, outpatient, or skilled nursing facility) for ocular and nonocular conditions, sociodemographic information (age, sex, race, education, and household net worth), and all records of filled outpatient medication prescriptions were analyzed. All individuals had dual enrollment in the medical and pharmacy plans. This data source has been used previously to study patients with ocular diseases.7,8 The University of Michigan institutional review board approved our study as a nonregulated study.
The study cohort included individuals 18 years of age or older with newly diagnosed (incident) GD who were included in the database for at least 1 continuous year and had visited an eye care professional (ophthalmologist or optometrist) at least once during their participation in the plan. Patients with GD were identified using ICD-9-CM diagnostic codes 242.00 and 242.01. We excluded those individuals who were in the plan for fewer than 365 days, those who had noncontinuous enrollment, and those who had received a diagnosis of GD or TAO during their first year in the plan (nonincident cases). Enrollees who received a diagnosis of benign or malignant neoplasms of the orbit and orbital pseudotumor were also excluded. In addition, to help ensure that the cohort consisted of individuals with bona fide GD, individuals who received a diagnosis of GD but had no record in the claims database indicating treatment for GD (eg, exposure to RAI, a thyroidectomy, or medication) and no record of thyrotropin testing to confirm the diagnosis were excluded. Those with no record in the claims database of treatment for GD during their time in the plan but with evidence of GD based on laboratory testing were included in the analyses. After these exclusions, 8404 patients with newly diagnosed GD were included in our study (Figure).
Diagnosis of TAO was based on billing codes for Graves orbitopathy, eyelid retraction, restrictive strabismus, proptosis, exposure keratopathy, or compressive optic neuropathy (eTable in the Supplement).
Individuals who filled 1 or more prescriptions for statins, COX-2 inhibitors, or antithyroid medications were identified, and medication use was quantified (eTable in the Supplement). Information regarding use of nonprescription medications was not available.
Statistical analyses were performed using SAS version 9.3 software (SAS Institute). The characteristics of the participants were summarized using mean values and standard deviations for continuous variables and frequencies and percentages for categorical variables. A Cox proportional hazards model with delayed entry was used to estimate the hazard of developing TAO based on the predictors of interest. The first year of enrollment was used as a “look-back” period. Individuals receiving 1 or more codes for TAO during this period were excluded from the analysis in order to exclude those with preexisting TAO. All beneficiaries were observed from the date of first diagnosis of GD until they either developed TAO or were censored. Censoring occurred when the individual disenrolled from the plan or at the end of the study period (December 31, 2009). First, single-variable models were used to test potential predictors individually. Multivariable models were adjusted for age at first GD diagnosis, sex, race, level of education attained, household net worth, and geographic region of residence at the time of enrollment. Other variables included in the model were record in the claims database of thyroidectomy, exposure to RAI, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, connective tissue disease, serum thyrotropin level, Charlson Comorbidity Index9 (a measure of overall health), and the use of statins, other cholesterol-lowering medications, antithyroid medications, and COX-2 inhibitors. In the multivariable model, thyrotropin levels were dichotomized into 5 mIU/L or less at all measurements and greater than 5 mIU/L at any measurement. A second multivariable model was run using a thyrotropin concentration of 7 mIU/L as the cutoff instead of 5 mIU/L. In the regression model, treatment with RAI alone was the omitted reference for which other interventions were compared against. For all analyses, P < .05 was considered to be statistically significant.
Exposure to medications for a given individual frequently changes over time owing to adherence and other factors. Assuming its constancy can lead to erroneous conclusions. To address this concern, we created time-dependent covariates to quantify medication use. For each day that an individual with GD was at risk of developing TAO in the model, we determined the total number of days in the previous year that the individual was prescribed each medication class. On a particular day, if the enrollee had a record of receiving a prescription for the medication of interest for at least 60 days in the past year, they were counted as a user of the medication for that day. We quantified the number of days each enrollee was prescribed each medication from the index date to the date of first diagnosis of TAO or censoring.
A total of 8404 individuals were identified with newly diagnosed GD, with a mean (SD) length of medical plan enrollment of 2050 (827) days. Of these 8404 enrollees, 740 (8.8%) developed TAO during the follow-up (compared with all patients with GD, the mean [SD] total plan enrollment time for those who developed TAO was 2066  days [P = .56]). The mean (SD) length of time between first GD diagnosis and first TAO diagnosis was 374 (422) days. Those who developed TAO were younger (mean [SD] age, 45.1 [11.7] years) than those without ocular manifestations (mean [SD] age, 46.6 [12.7] years) (P = .001). However, no predilection based on sex (P = .63) or race (P = .27) was identified (Table 1).
The 740 individuals who developed TAO were identified by the following codes: proptosis (602 [81.4%]), Graves eye disease (403 [54.5%]), restrictive strabismus (223 [30.1%]), eyelid retraction (191 [25.8%]), exposure keratopathy (77 [10.4%]), and compressive optic neuropathy (29 [3.9%]). Some individuals exhibited more than 1 of these ocular manifestations at initial diagnosis of TAO.
Treatment for thyroid dysfunction for individuals with GD included antithyroid medications alone (n = 4277), exposure to RAI alone (n = 2196), antithyroid medications in combination with exposure to RAI (n = 1125), and thyroidectomy alone or with antithyroid medications (n = 779). A total of 1885 patients with GD had no record in the claims database of treatment for hyperthyroidism during their time in the health plan.
In the multivariable models, we observed no significant association between age, race, geographical region of residence, household net worth, or level of education and the hazard of developing TAO (P > .05 for each comparison). Women with GD demonstrated a 25% decreased hazard of developing TAO relative to men (adjusted hazard ratio [HR], 0.75 [95% CI, 0.56-1.02]), a finding that was close to but not statistically significant (P = .06).
In the multivariable regression model, neither medical therapy with antithyroid medications alone nor in combination with RAI appeared to alter the risk for developing TAO compared with receiving RAI alone (P > .05 for both comparisons). Individuals who received a thyroidectomy alone or who received a thyroidectomy along with antithyroid medications had a 74% decreased hazard of TAO (adjusted HR, 0.26 [95% CI, 0.12-0.51]) when compared with those receiving RAI alone. Those patients not requiring treatment for hyperthyroidism exhibited a 73% decreased hazard of developing TAO (adjusted HR, 0.27 [95% CI, 0.18-0.39]) relative to those treated with RAI alone (Table 2).
Dysthyroidism has been associated with increased incidence and worsening of TAO.10 Therefore, we determined the effect of elevated serum thyrotropin levels on the risk of TAO. Individuals with at least 1 measurement of the serum thyrotropin level that was greater than 5 mIU/L were found to have a 21% increased hazard of TAO (adjusted HR, 1.21 [95% CI, 0.91-1.59]) relative to those with a thyrotropin level of 5 mIU/L or less for all test measures, although this finding did not reach statistical significance (P = .19). In a separate regression model adjusting for the same comorbidities, individuals with a thyrotropin level of greater than 7 mIU/L for all test measures manifested a 31% increased hazard (adjusted HR, 1.31 [95% CI, 0.97-1.76]) relative to those with a thyrotropin level of 7 mIU/L or less for all test measures, a finding that was close to but not statistically significant (P = .07) (Table 2).
Without adjustment for potential confounding factors, individuals with GD who were prescribed statins for at least 60 days in the year of observation had a 40% decreased hazard of developing TAO (unadjusted HR, 0.60 [95% CI, 0.47-0.75]) compared with those not similarly treated, including exposure of fewer than 60 days (P < .001). After adjustment for covariates, enrollees with GD and with 60 days or more of statin use continued to manifest a 40% decreased hazard compared with those with less exposure to statins (adjusted HR, 0.60 [95% CI, 0.37-0.93]). There was no statistically significant difference in the risk of developing TAO between those exposed to other cholesterol-lowering medications besides statins (adjusted HR, 1.00 [95% CI, 0.50-1.82]) and those not exposed to these medications (Table 2).
In both the univariable and multivariable models, no significant difference in the hazard of TAO could be detected between individuals prescribed COX-2 inhibitors and individuals not receiving these medications (adjusted HR, 0.79 [95% CI, 0.28-1.73]). (Table 2)
Among the 8404 individuals with GD, 536 had at least 1 determination of thyroid-stimulating immunoglobulin (TSI). Of these 536 individuals, 275 (51.3%) had undetectable TSI levels, whereas 261 (48.7%) had detectable levels of greater than 130%. Of the 261 individuals with undetectable TSI levels, 19 (7.3%) manifested TAO. Of the 275 individuals with greater than 130% detectable levels of TSI, 50 (18.2%) developed TAO (P < .001).
The overarching pathogenic factors shared by GD and TAO remain unidentified. Here we followed a large cohort of patients with newly diagnosed GD to identify risk factors associated with the development of TAO. Although several risk factors have been identified previously, to our knowledge, this is the first study to assess multiple, potentially modifiable risk factors in a large cohort of patients. Because both the natural history and the treatment of GD can be idiosyncratic, we determined the risk factors over several years. Our findings indicate that thyroidectomy for the treatment of hyperthyroidism or statin use may lower the risk of developing TAO. Further studies will be required to determine whether a causal relationship can be identified between these factors and TAO. In addition, assessing the effect that modifying these factors might exert on the course of TAO will also require further inquiry.
Strategies for managing GD-associated hyperthyroidism differ among practitioners. Although the therapeutic options currently used offer potentially effective control of thyroid function, each might affect the risk of developing or worsening TAO differently.11,12 Because RAI ablation can exacerbate TAO, there may be a role for prophylactic low-dose oral corticosteroids, which have been found to mitigate any negative effect.13 In the present analysis, we searched the database to see whether the enrollees given RAI had a record of prescriptions for corticosteroids in the 15-day window around the timing of the RAI and determined that very few patients (only 2) had been prescribed corticosteroids. Our findings indicate that the risk of developing TAO is substantially reduced if patients undergo a thyroidectomy compared with RAI ablation.
Elevated levels of serum thyrotropin and TSI may negatively affect TAO. Specifically, several groups have found an association between TSI levels and the incidence of TAO.14-17 Our study supports the notion that a greater proportion of patients with TAO exhibit high TSI levels.
Another issue related to the putative role of thyrotropin in TAO concerns the elevations of thyrotropin levels that sometimes occur following surgical or radioactive iodine ablation. This can result from inadequate monitoring. It has been suggested that elevated serum thyrotropin levels might trigger the activity of TAO, a suspicion that has been strengthened by reports of its worsening in patients with hypothyroidism.18,19 In the present analysis, we observed an increased risk of TAO among individuals with elevated thyrotropin levels, a finding that approached statistical significance using a cutoff of 7 mIU/L.
Another goal of our study was to identify medications that might delay or prevent TAO. Because the majority of patients with GD will not develop clinically significant TAO, any preventative strategy would need to be safe and well tolerated. Our study analyzed several classes of medications with proven or suspected anti-inflammatory activity. Among them, statins represent a widely used class of drugs that reduce low-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels. The JUPITER (Justification for the Use of Statin in Prevention: An Intervention Trial Evaluating Rosuvastatin) trial20 assessed the potential benefit of statins among healthy participants. In that study,20 rosuvastatin reduced systemic markers of inflammation (eg, C-reactive protein), cholesterol levels, and the number of vascular events.21-23 The study identified the anti-inflammatory actions of statins that were independent of their cholesterol-lowering properties. Statins have been proposed as an adjuvant anti-inflammatory therapy.24-35
Of note, our cohort of individuals who received the diagnosis of GD included 22% for whom no method of treatment for hyperthyroidism could be identified in the database. Some of these patients may have manifested euthyroid or subclinical GD, and this may help explain why this group was found to have a reduced risk of TAO relative to the group treated with RAI only. Alternatively, exposure to RAI may increase the risk of TAO.
Our data analysis relied on diagnostic coding and is therefore subject to certain vagaries. Coding for GD is relatively straightforward. However, the manifestations of TAO can be subtle and may be overlooked. Thus, the individuals identified with TAO in this database are likely those with more severe disease. Although this bias is acknowledged, the goal of our study was to identify modifiable risk factors for developing TAO among patients with GD. The approach taken here appears to have identified a population with such modifiable risk factors. The data analysis was also limited because environmental exposures (eg, smoking) and over-the-counter medications could not be assessed. Only if there is differential management of GD by smoking status (ie, smokers are more likely to receive one of these interventions relative to other interventions) could the lack of data on smoking status affect the study findings. We have no reason to believe that smokers with GD are managed differently than nonsmokers. Finally, all the enrollees in our study had commercial health insurance. It is unclear whether our study findings are generalizable to persons with other forms of insurance or to uninsured persons. Additional analyses using other data sources will be required to tease out the contributions of these factors.
In conclusion, our study identifies several factors that are associated with a reduction in the risk of developing TAO among patients with GD, including thyroidectomy compared with RAI alone and statin use. A prospective study is needed to substantiate these findings and to assess whether statin use or a thyroidectomy may delay or prevent TAO in patients with GD.
Submitted for Publication: August 28, 2014; final revision received October 16, 2014; accepted October 2, 2014.
Corresponding Authors: Joshua D. Stein, MD, MS, Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences, University of Michigan, 1000 Wall St, Ann Arbor, MI 48105 (email@example.com).
Published Online: December 11, 2014. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2014.5103.
Author Contributions: Dr Stein had full access to all of the data in the study and takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis.
Study concept and design: Stein, Gupta, Lee, Smith, Douglas.
Acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data: Stein, Childers, Gupta, Talwar, Nan, Smith, Douglas.
Drafting of the manuscript: Stein, Gupta, Nan, Douglas.
Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Childers, Gupta, Talwar, Lee, Smith, Douglas.
Statistical analysis: Childers, Talwar, Nan, Douglas.
Obtained funding: Smith, Douglas.
Administrative, technical, or material support: Stein, Smith.
Study supervision: Gupta, Lee, Smith, Douglas.
Conflict of Interest Disclosures: All authors have completed and submitted the ICMJE Form for Disclosure of Potential Conflicts of Interest and none were reported.
Funding/Support: This study was supported by the National Eye Institute K23 Mentored Clinician Scientist Award (grant 1K23EY019511 to Dr Stein); the Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Foundation; grants EY08976, EY011708, DK063121, EY016339, EY021197, and EY007003 to Drs Smith and Douglas; Research to Prevent Blindness; and the Bell Charitable Foundation.
Role of the Funder/Sponsor: The funders/sponsors had no role in the design and conduct of the study; collection, management, analysis, or interpretation of the data; preparation, review, or approval of the manuscript; and decision to submit the manuscript for publication.
Create a personal account or sign in to: