Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Congenital hypertrophy of the retinal pigment epithelium (CHRPE), traditionally regarded as a benign stationary condition, has recently been shown in 5 cases to give rise to an elevated, solid tumor. However, the histopathologic nature of the tumor that arises from CHRPE has not been previously determined. A 65-year-old woman developed a progressively enlarging peripheral fundus tumor that arose from a focus of classic CHRPE. The tumor produced a localized exudative retinal detachment, cystoid macular edema, and surface-wrinkling retinopathy. The mass was removed by local resection, and histopathologic examination revealed a low-grade adenocarcinoma of the retinal pigment epithelium, apparently arising from CHRPE. Although CHRPE is usually a benign nonprogressive lesion, it can give rise to a malignant tumor. Congenital hypertrophy of the retinal pigment epithelium should be observed periodically for development of a neoplasm.
Congenital hypertrophy of the retinal pigment epithelium (CHRPE) is a well-known fundus abnormality that generally occurs as an asymptomatic flat lesion at the level of the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE).1-7 It can appear as a solitary condition1,2,8-10 or as multifocal lesions known as congenital grouped pigmentation or "bear tracks." Although the solitary and the multifocal forms were once believed to be stationary lesions, there have been reports of solitary CHRPE that showed minimal increase in diameter.11-15
We recently reported 5 cases of CHRPE, each of which spawned a slowly enlarging, elevated mass that we presumed to be a neoplasm of the RPE.16 At the time of that report, there was no available histopathologic diagnosis for any of the tumors. However, in one of those patients, the tumor recently showed enlargement, caused visual loss, and was removed by an eye-wall resection. We report the findings on that tumor, which proved to be a low-grade adenocarcinoma that apparently arose from CHRPE.
Report of a case
In January 1997, a 63-year-old woman with a 2-year history of slightly blurred vision in the right eye was found to have an ipsilateral fundus mass. She was referred to the Oncology Service at Wills Eye Hospital for management of a possible choroidal melanoma. She had undergone mastectomy for breast cancer 14 years earlier, with no local or systemic recurrence.
Her unaffected left eye had a visual acuity of 20/20 and was entirely normal. Her right eye had a visual acuity of 20/40 and normal intraocular pressure. Slitlamp biomicroscopy demonstrated a small, central posterior subcapsular cataract, and trace flare and trace cells in the anterior vitreous cavity. Fundus examination of the right eye disclosed a 12 × 10-mm, flat area of black pigmentation located between the ora serrata and the equator superiorly. It had a well-defined margin, scalloped border, and depigmented lacunae—characteristics of CHRPE. Arising abruptly from within the CHRPE was an amelanotic mass measuring 7 × 7 × 3 mm that was supplied and drained by slightly dilated retinal blood vessels (Figure 1). The mass appeared to involve full-thickness retina, lack intrinsic pigmentation, and contain fine corkscrew vessels. Sparse vitreous cells were evident above the mass, and surface-wrinkling retinopathy with mild cystoid macular edema accounted for the patient's vision loss.
A, Fundus drawing in January 1997 showing a fleshy yellow mass arising in area of congenital hypertrophy of the retinal pigment epithelium. B, Fundus photograph in January 1997.
Transcleral transillumination showed a moderate shadow measuring 12 × 10 mm in diameter, corresponding to the area of CHRPE. Within that shadow was a darker, distinct shadow measuring 7 × 7 mm, corresponding to the nodule seen clinically. With fluorescein angiography, the mass showed early hyperfluorescence and late staining, with leakage of fluorescein dye into the adjacent vitreous cavity (Figure 2). B-scan ultrasonography revealed a solid, dome-shaped mass that measured 3.0 mm in thickness (Figure 3A).
A, Fluorescein angiogram in venous phase showing retinal feeder vessels and hyperfluorescent mass superiorly. The frames in the arterial phase clearly showing filling through retinal blood vessels are not available. B, Late-phase fluorescein angiogram showing hyperfluorescent mass with leakage of fluorescein in the overlying vitreous.
A, B-scan ultrasonogram in January 1997 showing elevated mass with medium-low internal reflectivity. B, B-scan ultrasonogram taken 30 months later showing enlargement of the mass and higher internal reflectivity in the tumor.
Our initial differential diagnoses included retinal vasoproliferative tumor17,18 and neoplasm of the pigment epithelium.19,20 Choroidal melanoma and metastasis were believed to be less likely.
It was decided that we observe the lesion at 6-month intervals. During the next 36 months, the mass gradually enlarged in thickness (Figure 3B) and diameter (Figure 4), the visual acuity slowly worsened, the retinal feeder vessels became more dilated, and localized retinal exudation and secondary retinal detachment developed. The surface-wrinkling retinopathy and cystoid foveal edema became more pronounced. In addition, the smooth surface of the tumor disappeared because the tumor cells were diffusely infiltrating the overlying vitreous. Ultrasonography revealed that the thickness of the mass increased to 4.5 mm (Figure 3B).
A, Fundus drawing in late 1999 showing a fleshy yellow mass arising in the area of CHRPE and invading the overlying vitreous, producing subretinal exudation. B, Fundus photograph taken at the same time as Figure 4A. Note that the tumor has enlarged in diameter and thickness and is producing subretinal exudation.
The patient was informed that the enlarging tumor was likely to cause further vision loss secondary to vitreal seeding, retinal detachment, surface-wrinkling retinopathy, and vitreous hemorrhage. The options of diagnostic fine-needle aspiration biopsy, cryotherapy, irradiation, and tumor removal were discussed, and the patient elected to have tumor removal. After prophylactic laser photocoagulation posterior to the mass, the tumor was removed by a modified eye-wall resection.21 Postoperatively, the patient developed peripheral hemorrhagic retinal detachment and underwent pars plana vitrectomy, air/fluid exchange, vitreous instillation of sulfur hexafluoride gas, and cryotherapy. In February 2000, visual acuity was 20/400, and the retina was flat. There was pigment mottling in the fovea, and the area of the original tumor appeared as a flat yellow scar.
The specimen was fixed in formaldehyde and submitted for routine processing. Gross inspection showed an ovoid mass with a thin strip of sclera at its base. The superficial portion of the tumor was nonpigmented, and the deeper portion was pigmented. Microscopic examination revealed a segment of choroid and a partially pigmented moundlike tumor that rested on the denuded inner surface of Bruch's membrane. The sensory retina and the choroid were infiltrated with amelanotic tumor cells (Figure 5). The pigmented cells were arranged in a tubuloacinar configuration and contained large round melanosomes. The more superficial portion of the tumor that replaced the retina was composed of similar epithelial cells, except that they had minimal cytoplasmic pigmentation (Figure 6). Some of the nuclei contained prominent nucleoli, and rare mitotic figures were identified. The apical part of the neoplasm directly invaded the vitreous cavity, where it was topped by a layer of fibrinous exudate. There was extensive choroidal invasion by sheets and tongues of similar amelanotic tumor cells. Conspicuous foci of chronic inflammatory cells, including mature plasma cells with scattered Russell bodies, were present within the tumor and the underlying choroid. In some areas, the tumor cells formed cords and bands that rested on prominent periodic acid-Schiff–positive connective tissue septa, most likely representing basement membrane (Figure 7). Short segments of tall, heavily pigmented RPE cells consistent with residual CHRPE were present on Bruch's membrane at the base of the tumor(Figure 8).
Low-magnification photomicrograph of the tumor showing junction between basal pigmented cells and more superficial nonpigmented cells. The tumor has diffusely replaced the choroid (below) and the sensory retina (above) (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnification ×15).
Large amelanotic epithelial cells with nuclear pleomorphism located in the retina. Similar cells invaded the underlying choroid. One mitotic figure is evident (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnification ×250).
Section through the central portion of the tumor showing solid cords of epithelial cells that rest on septae of prominent basement membrane (periodic acid–Schiff, original magnification ×250).
Monolayer of deeply pigmented epithelial cells consistent with congenital hypertrophy of the retinal pigment epithelium near the base of the tumor. Note the abrupt transition between the congenital hypertrophy of the retinal pigment epithelium and the overlying mass (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnification ×250).
The tumor cells showed moderately intense immunoreactivity for vimentin, moderate diffuse and focally intense immunoreactivity for cytokeratin marker CAM 5.2, and trace to mild diffuse immunoreactivity for S100 protein. Scattered tumor cells showed intense immunoreactivity for cytokeratin marker AE1. Melanoma-specific antigen HMB-45 was nonreactive.
The tumor was classified as a low-grade adenocarcinoma of the RPE based on the local invasion of the choroid, retina, and vitreous, and the presence of nuclear pleomorphism with prominent nucleoli and occasional mitotic figures. The final diagnosis was low-grade adenocarcinoma arising from CHRPE.
Until recently, CHRPE was generally considered to be a stationary lesion with no known tendency to enlarge or spawn solid neoplasms. In recent years, however, solitary CHRPE has been observed on several occasions to increase in basal dimensions,11-15 and histopathologic studies have shown evidence of associated RPE hyperplasia in CHRPE lesions.7,15 Our group recently reported clinical observations on 5 cases of elevated, solid tumors that apparently arose from typical CHRPE.16 From our observations on those 5 cases, it seems that tumors arising from CHRPE slowly enlarge, invade the sensory retina, and develop a retinal blood supply. Eventually, they can cause intraretinal exudation, which can lead to an exudative retinal detachment, similar to that seen with retinal capillary hemangioma and Coats disease. Preretinal macular fibrosis and cystoid foveal edema are also common complications.
We believe that the tumors that arise from CHRPE have clinical and histopathological features similar to other neoplasms of the pigment epithelium.19,20 Such tumors are usually dark gray to black, invade the sensory retina, acquire a retinal blood supply, and produce exudative retinopathy.20 Although they are usually located in the peripheral fundus, they are frequently associated with preretinal gliosis and cystoid edema in the macular area. Based on our clinical observations of 5 cases and the histopathologic findings on the 1 case reported here, it seems that true neoplasms of the RPE can arise from CHRPE. In our case, the tumor proved histopathologically to be a low-grade adenocarcinoma of the RPE arising from a focus of CHRPE.
Even though the tumor in our patient arose from the CHRPE, it appeared clinically to be amelanotic. However, the deeper part of the tumor was pigmented histopathologically. This finding accounted for the dark shadow produced by transillumination of the seemingly amelanotic tumor. It seems that as these tumors proliferate, some of them lose pigmentation. We have seen another case of histopathologically proven adenocarcinoma of the RPE that was nonpigmented.22 In that case, the lesion presumably arose from a juxtapapillary hyperplasia of the RPE in an eye with ocular histoplasmosis.22
The pathogenesis of the tumor described here is uncertain. Tumors of the RPE may occur as reactive hyperplasia, benign adenoma, or malignant adenocarcinoma. It is tempting to speculate that other reported neoplasms of the RPE may have originated from foci of CHRPE, which underwent reactive hyperplasia and subsequent neoplasia.20 However, the stimulus for such change remains unknown. In a sense, such transformation of CHRPE into a neoplasm of the RPE may be analogous to the malignant transformation of a choroidal nevus into a malignant melanoma.
The diagnosis of an RPE neoplasm arising from CHRPE is best made by indirect ophthalmoscopy with recognition of a pigmented or nonpigmented mass arising from typical CHRPE with minimally dilated retinal feeding and draining blood vessels. It is possible that such tumors may clinically obscure the underlying CHRPE. If so, clinically the lesion is like other RPE tumors reported in the literature.20 Fluorescein angiography generally accentuates the feeder vessels and shows moderately intense hyperfluorescence of the mass. Ultrasonography shows an abruptly elevated mass with medium to high internal reflectivity, but the ultrasonographic findings alone may be insufficient to consistently differentiate a neoplasm of the RPE from choroidal melanoma.
The management of neoplasms arising from CHRPE should be similar to that of other tumors of the RPE.20 The ultimate treatment has not yet been determined, but it seems advisable to do fundus photography and examine the lesion periodically if it is small and asymptomatic. The other 4 patients we previously reported are currently being managed by observation only. However, the patient reported here required active treatment because the tumor was enlarging and was producing vision-threatening complications. Although the best treatment for symptomatic cases is unknown, options include treating the macular edema medically or with grid laser photocoagulation, or treating the tumor with laser photocoagulation, cryotherapy, plaque brachytherapy, or local resection. Local resection was performed in our patient with the hope that removing the tumor completely would stabilize the progressive complications.
The visual prognosis varies for patients with neoplasms arising from CHRPE. Most tumors are relatively small and show little change in the early stages. With time, however, there is slow enlargement of the mass and progressive exudative retinopathy, often with preretinal macular gliosis and cystoid macular edema causing visual loss. The systemic prognosis is excellent. To our knowledge, no adenocarcinoma of the RPE has exhibited distant metastasis.
In summary, we have documented a progressive, low-grade adenocarcinoma that appeared clinically and histopathologically to arise from CHRPE. We recommend that patients with CHRPE be followed up periodically for evolution of the lesion into a neoplasm.
Accepted for publication September 8, 2000.
This research was supported by the Eye Tumor Research Foundation, Philadelphia, Pa; the Award of Merit in Retina Research, Houston, Tex (Dr J. Shields); the Macula Foundation, New York, NY (Dr C. Shields); and the Noel T. and Sara L. Simmonds Endowment for Ophthalmic Pathology, Wills Eye Hospital (Dr Eagle).
Presented at the Annual Wills Eye Hospital Retina Club meeting, Philadelphia, Pa, September 15, 2000, and at the Fluorescein Club, American Academy of Ophthalmology Meeting, Dallas, Tex, October 22, 2000.
The authors acknowledge Eric Gurwin, MD, Steven Cohen, MD, and Carl Regillo, MD, for their assistance in the care of this patient, and Ramon Font, MD, for confirming the histopathologic diagnosis in consultation.
Corresponding author and reprints: Jerry A. Shields, MD, Oncology Service, Wills Eye Hospital, 900 Walnut St, Philadelphia, PA 19107.
Shields JA, Shields CL, Eagle RC, Singh AD. Adenocarcinoma Arising From Congenital Hypertrophy of Retinal Pigment Epithelium. Arch Ophthalmol. 2001;119(4):597–602. doi:10.1001/archopht.119.4.597
Coronavirus Resource Center
Create a personal account or sign in to: