Red arrow indicates the reference plane at the Bruch membrane opening (white dots); cyan arrows, minimum rim width from the Bruch membrane opening; dark blue arrows, lamina cribrosa depth; and white line, surface of the anterior lamina cribrosa.
The positive data points at the right side of each graph indicate that the lamina cribrosa displaced anteriorly following acute intraocular pressure elevation, whereas the negative values at the left side of each graph indicate that it displaced posteriorly. PACG indicates primary angle-closure glaucoma; POAG, primary open-angle glaucoma; SAP, standard automated perimetry; and VFI, visual field index.
eTable. Spearman’s Rank Correlation Between Acute Intraocular Pressure Induced Percentage Decrease in Minimum Rim Width (MRW) Sectorially and Threshold Sensitivities of Corresponding Visual Field Clusters
Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Tun TA, Atalay E, Baskaran M, et al. Association of Functional Loss With the Biomechanical Response of the Optic Nerve Head to Acute Transient Intraocular Pressure Elevations. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2018;136(2):184–192. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2017.6111
Is functional loss in patients with glaucoma associated with the biomechanical response of the optic nerve head to acute transient intraocular pressure elevations?
In this study of 91 patients, functional loss was associated with optic nerve head biomechanics in primary open-angle glaucoma but not in primary angle-closure glaucoma.
Optic nerve head biomechanics are associated with glaucoma severity in primary open-angle glaucoma, and the 2 primary glaucoma subgroups may exhibit inherently different biomechanical properties.
The acute biomechanical response of the optic nerve head (ONH) to intraocular pressure (IOP) elevations may serve as a biomarker for the development and progression of glaucoma.
To evaluate the association between visual field loss and the biomechanical response of the ONH to acute transient IOP elevations.
Design, Setting, and Participants
In this observational study, 91 Chinese patients (23 with primary open-angle glaucoma [POAG], 45 with primary angle-closure glaucoma, and 23 without glaucoma) were recruited from September 3, 2014, through February 2, 2017. Optical coherence tomography scans of the ONH were acquired at baseline and at 2 sequential IOP elevations (0.64 N and then 0.90 N, by applying forces to the anterior sclera using an ophthalmodynamometer). In each optical coherence tomography volume, lamina cribrosa depth (LCD) and minimum rim width (MRW) were calculated. The mean deviation (MD) and the visual field index (VFI), as assessed by automated perimetry, were correlated with IOP-induced changes of LCD and MRW globally and sectorially.
Main Outcomes and Measures
The LCD, MRW, MD, and VFI.
Among the 91 patients, 39 (42.9%) were women; the mean (SD) age was 65.48 (7.23) years. In POAG eyes, a greater change in LCD (anterior displacement) was associated with worse MD and VFI (R = −0.64; 95% CI, −0.97 to −0.31; P = .001; and R = −0.57; 95% CI, −0.94 to −0.19; P = .005, respectively) at the first IOP elevation, and a greater reduction in MRW was also associated with worse MD and VFI (first IOP elevation: R = −0.48; 95% CI, −0.86 to −0.09; P = .02; and R = −0.57; 95% CI, −0.94 to −0.20; P = .004, respectively; second IOP elevation: R = −0.56; 95% CI, −0.98 to −0.13; P = .01; and R = −0.60; 95% CI, −1.03 to −0.17; P = .008, respectively), after adjusting for age, sex, and baseline IOP. A correlation was found between the reduction in MRW in the inferior-temporal sector and the corresponding visual field cluster in POAG eyes at the second elevation (ρ = −0.55; 95% CI, −0.78 to −0.18; P = .006).
Conclusions and Relevance
The biomechanical response of the ONH to acute IOP elevations was associated with established visual field loss in POAG eyes, but not in primary angle-closure glaucoma eyes. This suggests that ONH biomechanics may be related to glaucoma severity in POAG and that the 2 glaucoma subgroups exhibit inherently different biomechanical properties.
The lamina cribrosa (LC) is thought to be the main site of damage to retinal ganglion cell axons, which occurs at the onset and during the course of glaucoma.1 Glaucomatous damage is typically characterized by functional loss (the pattern of visual field [VF] defects) and structural changes such as distinct cupping of the optic nerve head (ONH) and thinning of the retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL).2
Spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) allows the deep structures of the eye, particularly the RNFL, the neuroretinal rim (NRR), and the LC, to be assessed in vivo through volumetric imaging with interpolated B-scans that closely match histologic sections.3 Thus, small-scale structural changes of the LC4 (a sign of cupping) and of the minimum rim width5,6 (MRW), a sign of RNFL thinning at the NRR, can be objectively measured.
Structure-function relationships in glaucomatous eyes have been reported by various studies using SD-OCT.7-10 Such relationships may help us understand the pathogenesis and monitor glaucoma at various stages. While RNFL thickness has remained a key structural parameter to link with visual function, recent studies investigated parameters related to the LC. Ren et al11 found that a deep LC was associated with worse VF in young glaucomatous eyes; in contrast, Park et al12 reported that LC depth (LCD) was not correlated with VF loss.
Others have instead investigated dynamic intraocular pressure (IOP)–induced LC changes under the hypothesis that the biomechanical response of the LC to acute changes in IOP could underlie the axonal damage. For instance, Quigley et al13 reported that glaucomatous eyes with no significant changes in LCD following IOP-lowering procedures had more VF loss than those with significant changes. In a small population with glaucoma, we demonstrated that local LC strains (induced by IOP lowering via trabeculectomy) were associated with VF loss.14 We believe that deriving such relationships in more patients and in response to acute IOP elevations could be critical for understanding glaucoma pathogenesis and improving glaucoma management.
In this study, we aimed to evaluate the association between glaucomatous functional loss and the biomechanical response of the ONH to acute transient IOP elevations in human eyes in vivo.
Chinese patients 50 years or older with phakic eyes and no known history of intraocular surgery were recruited from glaucoma clinics at the Singapore National Eye Centre in Singapore. This study was approved by the SingHealth Centralized Institutional Review Board and adhered to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki. Written informed consent was obtained from all patients. Primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) and primary angle-closure glaucoma (PACG) were defined according to the published definitions.15 Angle closure in an eye was defined as having 2 or more closed quadrants without indentation. All glaucoma cases had high IOP (>21 mm Hg) at least once after being diagnosed as having glaucomatous optic neuropathy clinically.
Standard automated perimetry (Swedish Interactive Threshold Algorithm standard 24-2 program; Humphrey Field Analyzer II-750i, Carl Zeiss Meditec) was performed at baseline before any procedure was undertaken. A reliable VF examination was defined using the criteria of a false-positive error rate less than 15%16 and fixation loss less than 33%.16,17 We did not include false-negative index in our reliability criteria because, although false-negative error is meant to assess participant inattention, failing to respond to stimuli (high false-negative error) may also be a feature of a glaucomatous eye.18 Indices for VF such as mean deviation (MD) and VF index (VFI) were used in this study. The threshold sensitivities of 52 VF points (in decibels) were clustered and averaged into 6 regions according to Garway-Heath et al19 to correlate with the corresponding sector of the ONH.
The acute transient IOP elevation model was previously described20 and validated.21,22 An ophthalmodynamometer (spring-load indenter) was used to elevate IOP 2 times on 1 eye of each patient. The indenter applied an external force perpendicular to the anterior sclera through the temporal side of the lower eyelid. The applied forces (0.64 N [82.5 g] and then 0.9 N [95 g]) were used to obtain the desired IOP of approximately 35 and 45 mm Hg, respectively. After each IOP increment, IOP was held constant and measured with a Tono-Pen AVIA applanation tonometer (Reichert Inc) while the indenter was maintained in place. The interval between the 2 IOP elevations was 15 minutes. This time was necessary because we believe the first IOP elevation may be responsible for pushing aqueous humor out of the anterior chamber, thus resulting in IOP lowering. After 15 minutes, IOP returned to its approximate baseline value.
The ONH of each patient was imaged 3 times using SD-OCT (Spectralis; Heidelberg Engineering): once before IOP elevation (baseline) and once for each of the 2 IOP elevations. Each OCT volume scan consisted of 97 serial horizontal B-scans (30-µm distance between B-scans; 384 A-scans per B-scan; and 20 B-scans averaging) that covered a rectangular area of 15° × 10° centered on the ONH.21,22 Each imaging session with IOP elevation took approximately 2 to 3 minutes.
Raw SD-OCT images were postprocessed and enhanced using adaptive compensation to remove blood vessel shadows and to improve the visibility of the LC.23-25 For each eye, the anterior LC and Bruch membrane opening (BMO) of postprocessed OCT volumes were then manually delineated using custom-written MATLAB (MathWorks Inc) algorithms.21,26 The position of the anterior LC was defined by a sharp increase in axial signal intensity (corresponding to collagen) extending laterally up to the LC insertion points in the peripapillary sclera.3 The BMO was defined as the end point of the Bruch membrane layer (or retinal pigment epithelium) on either side of the ONH.27
Using the aforementioned delineations, we reconstructed the ONH structures in 3-dimensionally and our custom algorithms derived the following parameters according to published protocols.21,22,26,27
The LCD was defined as the distance from each anterior LC point to the BMO reference plane. The mean depth of all LC points on the anterior LC surface was reported as the mean LC depth (Figure 1).
The BMO area was defined as the area of the anterior-most boundary of the neural canal. The MRW was defined as the shortest distance from the BMO points to the retinal inner limiting membrane. The MRW measures the thickness of nerve fibers or axons at the NRR (Figure 1).27 The MRW values were further empirically categorized into 6 sectors, comprising four 45° sectors (superior temporal, superior nasal, inferior temporal and inferior nasal) and two 90° sectors (temporal and nasal).
Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS for Windows software version 19.0 (IBM Corp). Continuous variables were described as the mean and standard deviation. We used the Spearman rank correlation coefficient (ρ) to assess the associations between functional loss and ONH structural parameters at baseline, and between functional losses and changes in MRW regionally to acute IOP elevations. The ONH structural changes (Δ) were calculated for each parameter as percentage Changes ([Baseline Value − Value at IOP Elevation/Baseline Value] ×100). A positive ΔLCD value denotes the anterior LC displacement to acute IOP elevations (toward the vitreous humor), whereas a negative value indicates that the LC was displaced posteriorly. We used linear regression models to assess acute IOP-induced structure-function relationship in each group after adjusting for age, sex, and baseline IOP.
Ninety-one Chinese patients (23 with POAG, 45 with PACG, and 23 without glaucoma; 39 [42.9%] female; mean [SD] age, 65.48 [7.23] years) were included in the final analysis after excluding 10 patients (2 of whom had poor LC visibility due to cataract or uncorrectable blood vessel shadowing and 8 of whom had unreliable VF test results after 2 attempts). Table 1 shows the demographic and clinical characteristics of the 91 patients. The PACG eyes, as compared with POAG eyes, had significantly thinner central corneal thickness (mean [SD], 534.66 [35.38] vs 558.42 [32.82] µm; P = .04) and smaller axial length (mean [SD], 23.27 [1.33] vs 24.56 [1.51] mm; P = .02). Patients with PACG were older than patients without glaucoma (mean [SD] age, 68.36 [6.27] vs 60.35 [5.62] years; P < .001), but there was no significant difference in age between patients with PACG and those with POAG (mean [SD] age, 68.36 [6.27] vs 65.00 [7.67] years; P = .14).
There was no significant difference in BMO area at baseline, IOP at baseline, and IOP at both elevations among the groups (all P > .05). The mean (SD) en face visibility of the anterior LC was relatively good (81.36% [14.25%] of en face BMO area) (Table 1).
For all glaucoma cases, a thinner MRW was associated with worse MD (ρ =0 .44; 95% CI, 0.23-0.61; P < .001) or with worse VFI (ρ = 0.46; 95% CI, 0.25-0.63; P < .001) at baseline (Table 2). This association held true for each glaucoma group (PACG and POAG). Specifically, a thinner MRW was associated with worse VFI (ρ = 0.31; 95% CI, 0.02-0.55; P = .04) in PACG eyes and with worse MD (ρ = 0.68; 95% CI, 0.37-0.85; P < .001) and worse VFI (ρ = .70; 95% CI, 0.41-0.86; P < .001) in eyes with POAG. The LCD and BMO area at baseline were not associated with MD or VFI in both glaucoma subgroups (all P > .05) (Table 2).
After adjusting for age, sex, and baseline IOP, a greater percentage decrease in MRW in eyes with POAG was associated with worse MD and worse VFI (first IOP elevation, R = −0.48; 95% CI, −0.86 to −0.09; P = .02; and R = −0.57; 95% CI, 0.94 to −0.20; P = .004, respectively; second IOP elevation, R = −0.56; 95% CI, −0.98 to −0.13; P = .01; and R = −0.60; 95% CI, −1.03 to −0.17; P = .008, respectively). However, the percentage decrease in MRW in PACG eyes was not associated with MD or VFI at the first IOP elevation (R = 0.07; 95% CI, −0.28 to 0.41; P = .70; and R = −0.03; 95% CI, −0.36 to 0.31; P = .87, respectively) or at the second IOP elevation (R = 0.08; 95% CI, −0.24 to 0.39; P = .62; and R = 0.11; 95% CI, −0.19 to 0.41; P = .47, respectively) (Table 3).
A greater ΔLCD was associated with worse MD (R = −0.64; 95% CI, −0.97 to −0.31; P = .001) (Figure 2B) or with worse VFI (R = −0.57; 95% CI, −0.94 to −0.19; P = .005) (Figure 2D) in POAG eyes at the first IOP elevation, after adjusting for age, sex, and IOP at baseline. This result indicated that in POAG eyes the LC with worse VF loss displaced anteriorly in response to acute IOP increase (approximately 35 mm Hg), while the LC with mild VF loss displaced posteriorly. However, this association between ΔLCD and VF indices was not found in PACG eyes at the first IOP elevation (Figure 2A and C). At the second IOP elevation, no such association was found in any of the 2 groups.
The ΔBMO area (akin to change in disc area) at both IOP elevations was not associated with MD or VFI in all groups (all P > .05) (Table 2). There was no significant structure-function association following acute IOP elevations in patients without glaucoma after adjusting for age, sex, and baseline IOP (all P > .05).
At the second IOP elevation, an independent association was found between a greater decrease in MRW in the inferior temporal sector and threshold sensitivities of the corresponding VF cluster (ρ = −0.55; 95% CI, −0.78 to −0.18; P = .006) in POAG eyes. No association was found in PACG eyes for any IOP increase (eTable in the Supplement).
In this study, we assessed the relationships between established functional loss (detected by standard automated perimetry) and structural changes of the ONH in response to acute transient IOP elevations (derived from OCT). At baseline, we found that a thinner MRW was associated with worse functional loss (assessed by MD or VFI) in both POAG and PACG eyes. Following acute transient IOP elevations, a reduction in MRW was associated with worse functional loss in POAG eyes; however, this relationship was not present in eyes with PACG and eyes without glaucoma. At the first IOP elevation, the LC displaced anteriorly in POAG eyes with worse VF loss but posteriorly when those losses were minimal. Our data suggest that the biomechanical response of the ONH to acute transient IOP elevations is different between POAG and PACG and may be of importance to improve our understanding of glaucoma pathogenesis.
At baseline, we found that a thinner MRW was associated with worse functional loss, and this relationship was true in both POAG and PACG . These findings might be explained by a loss of ganglion cell axons at onset or during the progression of glaucoma.1 Other OCT studies have also found an association between MRW and VF indices.28,29 Our study confirms the association between the severity of glaucoma and MRW (a good surrogate for the number of axons entering the ONH6). In addition, we found that the MRW of glaucomatous eyes were significantly thinner than that of nonglaucomatous eyes at baseline.
An experimental glaucoma study in 51 monkeys showed that MRW thinning exceeded RNFL thinning, suggesting the IOP-related stress and strain could damage the axons not only at the LC but also more dramatically via direct transverse compression within the NRR itself.30 Thus, it is important to assess the biomechanical response of the NRR (assessed by MRW) together with the LC to get a comprehensive understanding of the 3-dimensional changes associated with IOP elevations. Following acute transient IOP elevations, a greater reduction in MRW in POAG eyes was associated with increased VF loss at both IOP elevations (Table 3) after adjusting for age, sex, and baseline IOP. However, this relationship was not present in eyes with PACG and or those without glaucoma, suggesting strong biomechanical variabilities across diagnostic groups.
It is important to emphasize that both anterior and posterior displacements of the LC (following changes in IOP) have been observed with SD-OCT by several groups, including ours.13,14,21,31,32 Following an acute transient IOP elevation, it has been hypothesized that a compliant sclera could yield a larger scleral canal opening, thus pulling the LC taut to displace anteriorly. On the other hand, a stiff sclera could limit scleral canal expansion, thus exposing the LC to the full effects of IOP to make it displace posteriorly.33,34 However, whether scleral stiffness is solely responsible for LC movements remains to be demonstrated.
We are aware of only 1 study that attempted to link IOP-induced LC movements with VF loss. Quigley et al13 reported that the LC displacement (either anterior or posterior) was large in eyes with mild VF loss, but minimal or nonexistent in eyes with severe VF loss. This was assessed in 25 POAG eyes and 2 PACG eyes that underwent various IOP-lowering procedures. In contrast, following an acute elevation of IOP, we observed that LCs with more VF loss displaced anteriorly, whereas LCs with less VF loss displaced posteriorly in POAG eyes. Our results suggest that the direction of LC movement (anterior or posterior) following a change in IOP may be an important factor to stratify POAG. However, it is unclear whether this differential behavior would be a result of tissue remodeling in various stages of the disease. This phenomenon (anterior movements with more VF loss) was observed only in POAG eyes but not in PACG eyes, suggesting the possible existence of inherently different mechanisms involved, or similar mechanisms but with different extents of vulnerability of the ONH in the response of IOP-induced stress. Eyes with PACG in this study had shorter axial lengths and might therefore have smaller scleral canals that resist deformations.35
An experimental glaucoma study in 9 monkeys found that the ONH’s structural changes such as rim area decrement and LC displacement occurred earlier than RNFL thinning.36 Thus, structural ONH changes (both LC displacement and reduction in MRW) to different IOP levels (achieved with acute IOP models) may provide useful clinical applications to predict the prognosis and progression of glaucoma, particularly for POAG cases. For this study, we recruited only Chinese patients because it is the main ethnicity in Singapore (>70%) and because variations in ONH biomechanical properties could exist across ethnicities.33 Therefore, our results may not be generalizable to other population groups.
Furthermore, we found that there was no relationship between baseline LCD and VF indices in all cases as well as in PACG and POAG eyes separately. Previous studies have also failed to demonstrate any relationship between the baseline LCD and VF loss.12,13 Our results suggest that IOP-induced LCD changes may be more useful than LCD alone at any specific time point for prognosis of glaucoma.
The changes in MRW were assessed not only globally but also sectorially because sectorial variations in MRW have been observed in both nonglaucomatous27 and glaucomatous6 eyes. We found that a reduction in MRW in the inferior temporal sector at IOP elevation was independently associated with VF loss in the superior nasal region of the disc in POAG eyes. Pollet-Villard et al8 reported that the highest correlation was found between baseline MRW in the inferior temporal sector and threshold sensitivity of the corresponding VF sector. We further confirmed this association but from a biomechanical perspective.
Several limitations in our work warrant further discussion. First, the IOP elevations may vary among the observers; however, the reported repeatability was good.21,22 Second, LC visibility was limited in some OCT images and 2 patients were excluded. Third, the BMO reference plane may migrate posteriorly toward the sclera with aging,37 or when the peripapillary choroid was compressed by acute IOP elevations32,38; this may have affected the values of LCD and MRW.39 Fourth, our OCT sectors’ sizes are a slight variation to those ONH sectors defined by Garway-Heath et al.19 Fifth, our results should hold true if other OCT devices were to be used; however, a proper device comparison analysis should be performed to confirm this. Finally, 9 patients with glaucoma received losartan, and this may have affected their scleral rigidity40 and thus influenced our results. However, by adding this medication to our statistical models, our results remained the same.
In summary, we established a relationship between functional loss induced by glaucoma and acute IOP-induced structural changes of the ONH. Although the ONH’s structural changes induced by acute transient IOP elevations were associated with VF loss in POAG eyes, no association was observed in the PACG group. This suggests a differential biomechanical response (to IOP) in the 2 subgroups of primary glaucoma.
Corresponding Author: Michaël J. A. Girard, PhD, Ophthalmic Engineering and Innovation Laboratory, Department of Biomedical Engineering, National University of Singapore, 4 Engineering Dr 3, E4-04-08, 117583, Singapore (firstname.lastname@example.org).
Accepted for Publication: November 13, 2017.
Published Online: January 4, 2018. doi:10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2017.6111
Author Contributions: Drs Tun and Girard had full access to all of the data in the study and take responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis.
Concept and design: Atalay, Baskaran, Aung, Girard.
Acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data: All authors.
Drafting of the manuscript: Tun, Atalay, Aung, Girard.
Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Atalay, Baskaran, Nongpiur, Htoon, Goh, Cheng, Perera, Aung, Strouthidis, Girard.
Statistical analysis: Atalay, Nongpiur, Htoon, Aung.
Obtained funding: Aung, Girard.
Administrative, technical, or material support: Tun, Goh, Cheng, Aung, Girard.
Supervision: Baskaran, Perera, Aung, Strouthidis, Girard.
Conflict of Interest Disclosures: All authors have completed and submitted the ICMJE Form for Disclosure of Potential Conflicts of Interest and none were reported.
Funding/Support: This study was supported by the National University of Singapore Young Investigator Award grant NUSYIA_FY13_P03; R-397-000-174-133 (Dr Girard), and by National Medical Research Council grant NMRC/STAR/0023/2014 (Dr Aung). Dr Strouthidis was supported by the National Institute for Health Research Biomedical Research Centre based at Moorfields Eye Hospital National Health Service Foundation Trust and University College London Institute of Ophthalmology.
Role of the Funder/Sponsor: The funders had no role in the design and conduct of the study; collection, management, analysis, and interpretation of the data; preparation, review, or approval of the manuscript; and decision to submit the manuscript for publication.
Disclaimer: The views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the National Health Service, the National Institute for Health Research, or the UK Department of Health.
Additional Contributions: Thierry Chabin, MD (Sainte-Foy-lès-Lyon, France) provided the ophthalmodynamometer used in this study. He received no compensation.