Customize your JAMA Network experience by selecting one or more topics from the list below.
Csendes A, Braghetto I, Burdiles P, Smok G, Henríquez A, Burgos AM. Late Results of the Surgical Treatment of 125 Patients With Short-Segment Barrett Esophagus. Arch Surg. 2009;144(10):921–927. doi:10.1001/archsurg.2009.83
The results of surgical treatment of patients with long-segment Barrett esophagus (BE) have been extensively reported. However, few publications refer to the results of surgery 5 years after the fact among patients with short-segment BE. This study aimed to determine the late results of 3 surgical procedures in patients with short-segment BE by subjective and objective measurements.
Prospective, nonrandomized study starting on March 1, 1987, and ending on December 31, 2005.
A prospective, descriptive study of a group of patients.
A total of 125 patients with short-segment BE underwent 3 operations in different periods: duodenal switch plus highly selective vagotomy and antireflux technique in 31 patients, vagotomy plus partial gastrectomy and Roux-en-Y loop with antireflux surgery in 58 patients, and laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication in 36 patients.
Main Outcome Measures
Late subjective and objective outcomes of the 3 different surgical procedures.
No operative mortality and only 2 postoperative complications (1.6%) occurred. The regression from intestinal metaplasia to cardiac or oxyntocardiac mucosa occurred in 60.8% to 65.4% of the patients, at a mean time of 39 to 56 months after surgery. Visick grading showed Visick grade I or II in 86.3% to 100.0% of the patients. No progression to low- or high-grade dysplasia or adenocarcinoma occurred.
On the basis of these results, laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication seems to be the surgical option for patients with short-segment BE because it is less invasive, has fewer side effects, and produces good results in the long-term follow-up.
Barrett esophagus (BE) is a condition in which the normal squamous epithelium of the distal esophagus is replaced by an abnormal columnar epithelium that undergoes 2 metaplastic changes. The first change is in the appearance of cardiac mucosa, and the second is in the presence of specialized intestinal metaplasia.1-7 This disease is the final consequence of long-standing duodenogastroesophageal reflux, and its importance lies in its association with a risk of a 30- to 125-fold development of adenocarcinoma. Currently, BE is divided into 2 groups8: short-segment BE (if the endoscopic distance between the gastroesophageal junction and the upper limit of the columnar mucosa is less than 3 cm) and long-segment BE (if this distance is more than 3 cm).
The outcomes of the surgical treatment of patients with long-segment BE have been extensively published by many authors and summarized by some of us in several review articles.9-11 However, despite patients with short-segment BE being much more common than patients with long-segment BE, the results of surgical treatment among patients with short-segment BE have been analyzed and published by only 6 groups of authors,12-17 to our knowledge. Therefore, the purpose of the present prospective study was to determine the late subjective and objective outcomes of 3 different surgical procedures performed in different time periods as treatment of patients with short-segment BE: laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication,18 open antireflux surgery with duodenal switch,19 and open antireflux surgery with distal gastrectomy plus Roux-en-Y loop.20,21
This prospective, nonrandomized study started on March 1, 1987, when a special surgical protocol was established for patients with BE, either with a short- or long-segment columnar epithelium, and ended on December 31, 2005.20 A total of 125 patients with short-segment BE were included; all the patients had BE secondary to chronic pathologic gastroesophageal reflux. Exclusion criteria included cardiac intestinal metaplasia, hiatal hernia without BE, scleroderma or achalasia with short-segment BE, and low- or high-grade dysplasia (these patients were described in another publication19). Patients with esophageal or cardial adenocarcinoma were also excluded.
A careful clinical assessment that assessed the presence of typical gastroesophageal reflux symptoms was performed in all patients before and several times after surgery. For the late clinical evaluation, a modified Visick gradation was used, as previously described.10,18
All endoscopic procedures were performed by 2 of the authors (A.C. and I.B.) using an XQ-20 endoscope (Olympus Corporation; Tokyo, Japan) and later a video endoscope manufactured by the same company. Extensive details of the procedures have been published previously.8,10,19,21 The presence of isolated or confluent erosions was carefully recorded, as well as the presence of a hiatal hernia, which was defined as a saclike structure between the diaphragmatic pinch-cock and the endoscopic gastroesophageal junction. This procedure was performed in all patients before and several times after surgery (every 1 or 2 years).
In all patients, 4 biopsy specimens were obtained immediately below the squamous-columnar junction and 2 samples 2 cm distally. They were submerged in a 10% formalin solution and stained with hematoxylin-eosin and Alcian blue at pH 2.5 to determine the type of epithelium that lined the distal esophagus. Fundic mucosa was identified by the presence of parietal and chief cells at the deep glandular layer. Cardiac mucosa was identified by the presence of mucous-secreting columnar cells. Oxyntocardiac mucosa was defined by the presence of parietal cells and mucous-secreting columnar cells. Intestinal metaplasia was defined by the presence of well-defined goblet cells, confined by positive staining with Alcian blue. The presence of Helicobacter pylori was investigated in the gastroesophageal biopsy specimens and the antrum specimens.
Esophageal manometric studies were performed after a 12-hour fast with the patient in the supine position. The complete details have been extensively published in previous reports.8,19-21 Three manometric characteristics were determined at the lower esophageal sphincter (LES): total length (in millimeters), abdominal length (in millimeters), and resting pressure (in Hg of mercury), as well as the amplitude of the contraction of the distal esophageal waves (in millimeters of mercury). An amplitude of less than 30 mm Hg was considered an ineffective peristaltic contraction. The presence of a mechanically incompetent sphincter was diagnosed if at least 1 of the following parameters was present: resting pressure equal to or less than 6 mm Hg, an abdominal length equal to or less than 10 mm, and a total length equal to or less than 20 mm. This test was performed before and 1 to 2 years after surgery.
Esophageal 24-hour pH monitoring was performed after a 12-hour fast by introducing the catheter (Digitrapper Synectics; Stockholm, Sweden) through the nose. The catheter was placed 5 cm proximal to the manometric upper limit of the LES (which is why manometric measurements are always performed before pH is studied). The details of this procedure have been published previously.8,19-21 Among the 6 different parameters that can be evaluated, the most practical is the total percentage of time in which the intraesophageal pH remains below 4, which is usually less than 4% in 24 hours.
Esophageal 24-hour spectrophotometric bilirubin monitoring was developed to determine the magnitude of duodenogastroesophageal reflux by measuring the total intraluminal concentration of bilirubin at the distal esophagus.8,19,20 Special dietary advice was given to the patient concerning certain foods, the consumption of which interferes with measurements. The final calculation is based on the percentage of time that bilirubin is measured in the esophagus with an absorbance greater than 0.2 (usually below 2% during 24-hour monitoring session).
For the present study, regression of intestinal metaplasia was considered to be the disappearance of intestinal metaplasia into cardiac or oxyntocardiac mucosa in 2 consecutive endoscopic and biopsy studies.
For statistical evaluation, the Mann-Whitney test, Fisher exact test, and χ2 test were used, with P < .05 considered to be statistically significant. All values are expressed as means and standard deviations.
Three surgical techniques were used in these 125 patients with short-segment BE in different periods: (1) acid suppression and duodenal diversion procedure20,21 performed by laparotomy, a truncal or selective vagotomy, an antireflux procedure, partial distal gastrectomy, and a Roux-en-Y gastrojejunal anastomosis with a loop 70 cm long (this technique was used between 1987 and 1995); (2) laparotomic duodenal switch procedure, associated with highly selective vagotomy and an antireflux surgery19 (this operation was performed between 1992 and 1995); and (3) laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication18 (this procedure has been performed from 1996 to the present).
Two types of antireflux technique were used in these patients. The first technique was Nissen fundoplication, either open or laparoscopic, whose surgical steps were described in detail in a previous publication.18,22 Basically, a 4-cm “floppy” wrap was created, which sutured the anterior and posterior walls of the gastric fundus after division of 3 to 4 short gastric vessels. A 360° wrap was constructed around the esophagogastric junction in a “floppy” fashion; late complications, such as displacement or intussusceptions of the wrap, were prevented by the suturing of the proximal and distal stitches to the esophageal wall. This procedure was designed to restore the normal manometric characteristics of the LES. The second technique was posterior gastropexy with calibration of the cardia, or Hill-Larrain technique.22,23 Three to 4 short gastric vessels were always divided. The posterior crus of the diaphragm was approximated with 2 nonabsorbable silk stitches. For posterior gastropexy and calibration of the cardia, the procedure was performed by the approximation of the anterior portion of the gastroesophageal junction or cardia with its posterior equivalent from right to left in an “adjusted” or calibrated long wrap, using 4 to 5 nonabsorbable interrupted stitches. The last stitch was evaluated by a tense ring created around a 30F bougie catheter. Two stitches of this calibration were then sutured to the distal segment of the crus (posterior gastropexy). This procedure is thought to work by helping the patient to regain the normal tension of the sling fibers of the LES and to increase the length of the abdominal portion of the sphincter by means of posterior gastropexy.
The main clinical and endoscopic features of the 125 patients with short-segment BE are given in Table 1. No significant differences were found among the 3 groups in any parameter evaluated. Among the 31 patients who underwent the laparotomic duodenal switch procedure, the antireflux technique was a posterior gastropexy with cardial calibration in 20 patients and a Nissen fundoplication in 11. Among the 58 patients who underwent the acid suppression and duodenal diversion procedure, posterior gastropexy with cardial calibration was performed in 31 patients and a Nissen fundoplication in 27 patients. Among patients who underwent the laparoscopic procedure, Nissen fundoplication was performed in 33 patients and calibration of the cardia in 3 patients. Therefore, Nissen fundoplication was used in 71 patients and posterior gastropexy with calibration of the cardia in 54 patients. No operative mortality was observed. The postoperative course was uneventful in all patients who underwent laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. One patient who underwent the duodenal switch procedure developed gastric stasis after surgery, which required endoscopic dilatation, with uneventful posterior evolution. After vagotomy and partial gastrectomy, 1 patient developed a gastric fistula, which required subsequent operation and drainage, with an excellent postoperative course. The only significant difference among these operations was observed in the length of the hospital stay, which was significantly shorter for laparoscopic fundoplication compared with the other 2 techniques.
Table 2 gives the manometric features before and after the antireflux procedure in the 3 groups. Because this test only measures the effect of antireflux technique on the LES and the amplitude of distal esophageal waves, the changes after surgery were similar. There was an increase in LES pressure compared with preoperative values, which was statistically significant in all groups. There was an increase in the abdominal length of the LES compared with preoperative values, which was highly statistically significant in all 3 groups. There was a statistically significant increase in the total length of the LES in all groups. There was a statistically significant decrease in the presence of an incompetent LES. There was a similar increase in the amplitude of the distal esophageal waves after surgery but without statistical significance. The comparison of each parameter in the 3 groups, eg, of values before and after surgery, showed no statistically significant difference.
Table 3 gives the results of the functional studies before and after surgery in each group. The 24-hour pH monitoring before surgery and the Bilitec studies before surgery showed similar results in all 3 groups (P > .5). After the antireflux procedure, a significant reduction was seen in acid reflux in all groups compared with preoperative values. However, this reduction was not uniform: after duodenal switch, 80.7% of the patients had acid reflux with normal or below-normal values; an entirely similar value (82.8%) of reduction of acid reflux was observed among patients with acid suppression who underwent the duodenal diversion procedure. However, after Nissen fundoplication only 75.0% of the patients showed absence of abnormal acid reflux. The results of the 24-hour bile monitoring were evaluated before and after surgery mainly in the open procedures: they showed an abolition of duodenoesophageal reflux of 83% to 100% compared with preoperative values. This monitoring was not performed after Nissen fundoplication.
Table 4 gives the histologic changes at the short-segment columnar mucosa in its comparison of patients before and several times after surgery. In each group at least 3 endoscopic and biopsy procedures were performed after surgery. Some patients were lost to follow-up, and all evaluations were performed only after 12 months of the operation. Mean follow-up varied from 54 to 106 months. Persistence of intestinal metaplasia after at least 3 endoscopic and histologic analyses was observed in a similar proportion of patients in each group (35%-39%), a finding that was not statistically significant (P>.7). Regression to cardiac or oxyntocardiac mucosa occurred in 61% to 65% of the patients comparing all groups, without statistical significance (P>.58). The time to regression varied from 39 to 56 months after surgery, without statistical significance (P>.11).
Table 5 gives the Visick gradation months after surgery. We considered Visick grades I and II to be good postoperative results, although Visick grade II corresponded to patients who had to start taking proton pump inhibitors again to remain asymptomatic. These grades were registered in 86% of patients after duodenal switch, in 94% of patients after acid suppression and the duodenal diversion procedure, and in 100% of patients after laparoscopic fundoplication. Visick grades III and IV corresponded to patients with persistence of esophagitis or with dumping syndrome. None of the patients showed progression to low- or high-grade dysplasia or adenocarcinoma.
The results of the present prospective, nonrandomized study suggest that in patients with short-segment BE who undergo surgical treatment, laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication is the procedure of choice compared with the other 2 more aggressive surgical procedures. In these patients with short-segment BE, regression from intestinal metaplasia to cardiac or oxyntocardiac mucosa occurred in nearly 60% of the patients, at a mean time of 50 months after the procedure. In addition, no progression to low- or high-grade dysplasia occurred.
For most surgeons dedicated to the care of patients with BE, the surgical treatment is focused on the reestablishment of the competence of the LES. Careful review of all publications concerning this topic9 shows that final results are usually shown in a mixed fashion. To our knowledge, only 6 publications have focused their results exclusively on patients with short-segment BE (Table 6).
The first report12 followed up 22 patients with short-segment BE for 5 years, including another 9 patients who underwent mucosal thermal ablation. There was a loss of intestinal metaplasia to cardiac or cardiac-fundic mucosa in 59% of the patients. No mention of the time to regression was given. The main problems with this report are that the investigators performed only 1 postoperative endoscopy plus biopsy in most patients and no functional studies are reported. From the whole group (66 patients), including both patients with short-segment and long-segment BE, moderate to severe gastroesophageal reflux disease symptoms were present in 35%, antisecretory medications were used in 27%, and an additional operation was performed in 7 patients (11%). The second report13 includes 33 patients with short-segment BE who mainly underwent laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. At least 2 postoperative endoscopies and biopsies were performed. Regression from intestinal metaplasia to cardiac mucosa occurred in 33% of the patients, after a follow-up of 50 months. No functional studies were reported. The third report was probably the most complete study; it included manometric and 24-hour pH monitoring evaluations before and after surgery. The problems with this study were mainly the short endoscopic follow-up period (30 months after surgery) and the fact that only 1 postoperative endoscopy was reported in most patients. There was a loss of intestinal metaplasia in 56% of the patients at a period of 30 months after surgery. The fourth report15 described 9 patients with short-segment BE who underwent Nissen-Rossetti fundoplication, with a 67% regression from intestinal metaplasia to squamous epithelium at a mean follow-up of 45 months. This finding is intriguing because the regression of intestinal metaplasia is to cardiac or oxyntocardiac mucosa and rarely to complete disappearance of the columnar mucosa and its replacement by squamous epithelium. The strength of this study is the performance of complete functional studies, which found that 42% of patients with BE had an abnormal acid reflux test result late after surgery. This study showed again what we have pointed out several times: control of symptoms does not happen parallel to the abolishment of acid reflux. The fifth report16 described 11 patients who underwent laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. The follow-up is short (28 months after surgery), and no functional studies were reported. In 6 patients (55%) regression to cardiac mucosa occurred. The sixth publication17 followed up 59 patients with short-segment BE who underwent laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication. The criterion of the authors for regression was a decrease or disappearance of the columnar lined distal esophagus, but no mention is made of loss of intestinal metaplasia. No functional studies were reported.
In our study, we started to perform an acid suppression and duodenal diversion procedure for patients with BE20 in 1987 based on the fact that the harmful refluxate material in the esophagus is composed mainly of gastric and duodenal juice. Later, we included another type of duodenal diversion19 for patients with BE, which included, besides the Roux-en-Y loop as part of the duodenal switch, an antireflux procedure plus highly selective vagotomy. In 1995, we gradually incorporated laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication as the only surgical technique for these patients18 because it is much less aggressive than the other 2 techniques and we had conquered the learning curve for the laparoscopic antireflux procedure. Besides, in a prospective, randomized trial that compared the results of laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication with calibration of the cardia with posterior gastropexy, we demonstrated similar late results at 10 years of follow-up,22 which is why we adopted Nissen fundoplication as the antireflux procedure of choice. The careful follow-up of all 125 patients who underwent these 3 procedures that assessed subjective and objective variables showed that the results are similar comparing the 3 techniques, measured with symptomatic evaluations (Visick grading), functional studies (manometric tests, 24-hour pH monitoring, and 24-hour bile monitoring), and histologic evaluations expressing the percentage of loss of intestinal metaplasia to cardiac or oxyntocardiac mucosa.
Finally, the less aggressive surgical approach has shown that laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication is the treatment of choice when dealing with the surgical treatment of patients with short-segment BE. Patients with low-grade dysplasia were not included in this study and have been described elsewhere.21 As described recently for patients with long-segment BE,24 none of our patients who underwent the duodenal diversion procedure has developed high-grade dysplasia or adenocarcinoma, even after 120 months of follow-up. Although the follow-up after Nissen fundoplication is shorter (54 months), we have not seen any progression among these patients. We need a longer follow-up to determine the real effect of this technique. We ask other authors to report their results with a much longer follow-up (no studies have more than 5 years, and 2 studies have only 2½ years of follow-up) and to perform at least 3 postoperative endoscopies in each patient and incorporate functional studies in their evaluations to determine by several objective parameters the real long-term effect of Nissen fundoplication. We do not believe that a follow-up by telephone or written questionnaire is an adequate way to determine the late results of a particular surgical procedure, especially when dealing with patients with BE.
In conclusion, after we compared 3 different operations for patients with short-segment BE, we found that laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication is the procedure of choice because it is less invasive, has fewer side effects, and produces good results in long-term follow-up, results that are similar to those found with other more aggressive surgical techniques.
Correspondence: Attila Csendes, MD, Department of Surgery, Clinical Hospital, University of Chile, Santos Dumont 999, Santiago, Chile (email@example.com).
Accepted for Publication: July 22, 2008.
Author Contributions:Study concept and design: Csendes and Braghetto. Acquisition of data: Braghetto, Smok, and Henríquez. Analysis and interpretation of data: Csendes, Braghetto, Burdiles, and Burgos. Drafting of the manuscript: Henríquez and Burgos. Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Csendes, Burdiles, and Smok. Statistical analysis: Burgos. Administrative, technical, and material support: Smok and Henríquez. Study supervision: Burdiles.
Financial Disclosure: None reported.