[Skip to Content]
Sign In
Individual Sign In
Create an Account
Institutional Sign In
OpenAthens Shibboleth
[Skip to Content Landing]
September 1969

Multiple Primary Malignant Neoplasms

Author Affiliations

Morgantown, WVa
From the Department of Surgery, West Virginia University School of Medicine, Morgantown, WVa. Dr. Campbell is now captain, 392d Aerospace Medical Group, Vandenberg Air Force Base, Calif.

Arch Surg. 1969;99(3):401-405. doi:10.1001/archsurg.1969.01340150109023

Almost a century ago Billroth1 described two patients in both of whom developed more than one primary malignant neoplasm. Although not published until 1869, one of these patients was reported in 1860 according to Warren and Gates2 and Judge.3 Since that time, there has been a permutation of the occurrence rate of this disease from that of a rare medical curiosity to a commonplace medical enigma today. Although Renaud4 in 1847 and Rokitansky5 in 1855 apparently reported the first patients with multiple primary malignant tumors, these are poorly documented and Billroth is usually credited with the first reports which stimulated interest in this phenomenon.

Selection of Patients  The patients of this study were derived from the Tumor Registry of the West Virginia University Medical Center between August 1960 and July 1967. The diagnosis of multiple primary malignant disease was determined by the criteria established by

Billroth, Theodor, cited by Eisenstaedt, J.S.:  Multiple Primary Malignant Tumors ,  JAMA 110:2056-2059 ( (June 18) ) 1938.Crossref
Warren, S., and Gates, O.:  Multiple Primary Malignant Tumors: Survey of Literature and Statistical Study ,  Amer J Cancer 16:1358-1414 ( (Nov) ) 1932.
Judge, A.F.:  Multiple Primary Malignant Tumors ,  Ann Otol 59:614-621 ( (Sept) ) 1950.
Renaud, F., cited by Doran, A.:  Trans Obstet Soc London 38:322-326 ( (Oct) ) 1896.
Rokitansky, cited by Mercanton,  F Rev med de la Suisse Rom 13:173-193 ( (March) ) 1893.
Moertel, C.G.; Dockerty, M.D.; and Baggentoss, A.H.:  Multiple Primary Malignant Neoplasms: I. Introduction and Presentation of Data ,  Cancer 14:221-230 ( (March) -April) 1961.Crossref
Lund, C.C.:  Second Primary Cancer in Cases of Cancer of Buccal Mucosa: Mathematical Study of Susceptibility to Cancer ,  New Eng J Med 209:1144-1152 ( (Dec 7) ) 1933.Crossref
Albrecht, P.:  Über die Multiplizität Primarer Maligner Geschwüste ,  Oncologia (Basel) 5:12-42 ( (May) ) 1952.Crossref
Cooper, Z.L:  A Study of 106 Cases of Multiple Skin Cancer ,  Surg Clin N Amer 24:1022-1027 ( (Oct) ) 1944.
Phillips, C.:  Multiple Skin Cancer: A Statistical and Pathologic Study ,  Southern Med J 35:583-590 ( (June) ) 1942.Crossref
Rappin:  A propos d'un cas d' epitheliomatose cutanee multiple ,  Gaz med de Nantes ( (Aug 15) ) 1928
abstracted,  Cancer Review 4:324 ( (June) ) 1929.
MacDonald, E.J.:  Occurrence of Multiple Primary Cancers in a Population of 200,000 ,  Ada Un Int Cancr 16: 1702-1710 ( (Oct) ) 1960.
Sarasin, R.:  Les manifestations successives des epitheliomes des muqueuces de la cavite buccale: Sont elles des recidives vares ou resultent-elles de nouvelles cancerisations?  Radiophys Radiother 3:33 ( (March) ) 1933.
Wilkins, S.A., Jr., and Vogler, W.R.:  Cancer of the Gingiva ,  Surg Gynec Obstet 105:145-152 ( (Aug) ) 1957.
Czerny:  II. Aus der Heidelberger Chirurgischen Klinik: Nachtrag zur Darm-resection ,  Berl Klin Wschr 17:683-684 ( (Nov) ) 1880.
Slaughter, D.P.:  The Multiplicity of Origin of Malignant Tumors: Collective Review ,  Int Abstr Surg 79:89-98 ( (Aug) ) 1944.
Taylor, H.C.:  The Coincidence of Primary Breast and Uterine Cancer ,  Amer J Cancer 15:277-279 ( (Jan) ) 1931.
Bailar, J.C., III:  The Incidence of Independent Tumors Among Uterine Cancer Patients ,  Cancer 16:842-853 ( (July) ) 1963.Crossref
Cahan, W.G.:  Lung Cancer Associated With Cancer Primary in Other Sites ,  Amer J Surg 89:494-514 ( (Feb) ) 1955.Crossref
Campbell, L.V., Jr., et al:  Metastasis of Cancer to Cancer ,  Cancer 22:635-643 ( (Sept) ) 1968.Crossref
Mersheimer, W.L.; Ringel, A.; and Eisenberg, H.:  Some Characteristics of Multiple Primary Cancers ,  Ann NY Acad Sci 114:896-921 ( (April) ) 1964.Crossref